The creeping march and expansion of CCTV....your views?
Discussion
Long-ish post - the TL;DR version is - do you agree with CCTV being installed on new housing estates?
Ok. There's no point in ranting / moaning, or even discussing, the placement and expansion of CCTV in town centres, and on major roads and junctions. That's already happened, it's never going away, and the fact is that we live in an electronically managed and surveyed society - where the majority of people congregate and / or drive. That's fine, to a point.
Fair enough - I also get that monitoring roads, especially with ANPR equipped devices, has probably caught far more dodgy drivers than has irritated / inconvenienced normal law abiding folk. I am happy to accept that, as a law-abiding driver, I have never been stopped or inconvenienced, as a result of a camera surveying roads. Equally, I have also never been stopped / inconvenienced as a result of being surveyed by a 'town centre' camera either - and again, I am happy that they have helped to stop / detect a lot of crime, especially in these days of far fewer Policemen on the ground.
But what has prompted my thread, is the apparent expansion of CCTV into suburban / domestic areas. My job as a Paramedic involves spending 10, 12 hour shifts out on the road, visiting mainly domestic properties, so I get to see a lot, 'out and about' so to speak. Living down on the South Coast, recently (especially in the last few years) there has been a huge surge in housebuilding - we've had quite a few huge brownfield sites around here, originally with sprawling factories on them, re-developed into new housing estates.
Many of them are 'out of town' - not in the sticks, granted, but definitely suburban in their character, and not what I would call part of / close to a town centre. The sort of new build estates with a mix of housing, from flats to detached properties, very much like the one I live on that was developed in the 1980's - where you would get a mix of singles, professionals, and families. Somewhere you would expect to move to, have a nice 'middle class' experience, and enjoy a quiet, peaceful existence. Somewhere to escape to after a long day at work, to relax, chill and be yourself. Where kids might play in the street and on the green spaces - very much like I did when I was a kid in the 80's. Does that make sense? Know what I mean?
However, getting to the point, because I am aware I may have been rambling
- what has struck me, and if I am honest - disturbed me somewhat recently - is that most of these new estates have a complex network of CCTV cameras dotted around them. And by that I mean, a properly designed and executed surveillance system - basically with coverage of pretty much every single street, close, mews, green, play area - the whole nine yards basically.
It's not like these places even have primary thoroughfares through them, or shops - maybe I could understand if they did...but they're surveying normal, domestic housing areas. Despite that - they all have 100% occupancy, indeed round here, because of the housing shortage, estates like these spring up and are filled PDQ.
So the new incumbents, whether buying or renting, MUST see these cameras everywhere before they move in - after all, they're not unobtrusive at all. Which begs the question - it seems that many people are happy to buy / rent a house with presumably 24-hour CCTV surveillance right outside their front doors, and - who knows - maybe even into their gardens and possibly into their personal living space! I have seen how amazing the latest HD cameras can be - they can zoom in with incredible clarity, even at night, to a monstrous distance - so if the angle was right, could easily see right into someone's lounge or bedroom...
Anyway, I have DEFINITELY rambled on a bit - but I just wanted to discuss my feelings and reasons for posting really. I am definitely uncomfortable with the proliferation of CCTV around new-build, domestic housing estates: I feel that there is no need at all, and wondered what the justification might be, and the mindset of the tenants who are clearly happy to accept such an intrusion to their lives?
And I also wonder what the general consensus of the PH massive is on this? Would you / do you accept such monitoring around your gaff? As I said, I don't think you have an argument if you choose to live in a town centre - but what about in these suburban housing estates? Is this just par for the course in our modern, progressive society given the cuts to frontline Policing - or is it an intrusion which may benefit from a little opposition and representation on a local level?
I would be interested to hear your thoughts. And sorry for the long post - but it's just what I do
Ok. There's no point in ranting / moaning, or even discussing, the placement and expansion of CCTV in town centres, and on major roads and junctions. That's already happened, it's never going away, and the fact is that we live in an electronically managed and surveyed society - where the majority of people congregate and / or drive. That's fine, to a point.
Fair enough - I also get that monitoring roads, especially with ANPR equipped devices, has probably caught far more dodgy drivers than has irritated / inconvenienced normal law abiding folk. I am happy to accept that, as a law-abiding driver, I have never been stopped or inconvenienced, as a result of a camera surveying roads. Equally, I have also never been stopped / inconvenienced as a result of being surveyed by a 'town centre' camera either - and again, I am happy that they have helped to stop / detect a lot of crime, especially in these days of far fewer Policemen on the ground.
But what has prompted my thread, is the apparent expansion of CCTV into suburban / domestic areas. My job as a Paramedic involves spending 10, 12 hour shifts out on the road, visiting mainly domestic properties, so I get to see a lot, 'out and about' so to speak. Living down on the South Coast, recently (especially in the last few years) there has been a huge surge in housebuilding - we've had quite a few huge brownfield sites around here, originally with sprawling factories on them, re-developed into new housing estates.
Many of them are 'out of town' - not in the sticks, granted, but definitely suburban in their character, and not what I would call part of / close to a town centre. The sort of new build estates with a mix of housing, from flats to detached properties, very much like the one I live on that was developed in the 1980's - where you would get a mix of singles, professionals, and families. Somewhere you would expect to move to, have a nice 'middle class' experience, and enjoy a quiet, peaceful existence. Somewhere to escape to after a long day at work, to relax, chill and be yourself. Where kids might play in the street and on the green spaces - very much like I did when I was a kid in the 80's. Does that make sense? Know what I mean?
However, getting to the point, because I am aware I may have been rambling
- what has struck me, and if I am honest - disturbed me somewhat recently - is that most of these new estates have a complex network of CCTV cameras dotted around them. And by that I mean, a properly designed and executed surveillance system - basically with coverage of pretty much every single street, close, mews, green, play area - the whole nine yards basically.It's not like these places even have primary thoroughfares through them, or shops - maybe I could understand if they did...but they're surveying normal, domestic housing areas. Despite that - they all have 100% occupancy, indeed round here, because of the housing shortage, estates like these spring up and are filled PDQ.
So the new incumbents, whether buying or renting, MUST see these cameras everywhere before they move in - after all, they're not unobtrusive at all. Which begs the question - it seems that many people are happy to buy / rent a house with presumably 24-hour CCTV surveillance right outside their front doors, and - who knows - maybe even into their gardens and possibly into their personal living space! I have seen how amazing the latest HD cameras can be - they can zoom in with incredible clarity, even at night, to a monstrous distance - so if the angle was right, could easily see right into someone's lounge or bedroom...
Anyway, I have DEFINITELY rambled on a bit - but I just wanted to discuss my feelings and reasons for posting really. I am definitely uncomfortable with the proliferation of CCTV around new-build, domestic housing estates: I feel that there is no need at all, and wondered what the justification might be, and the mindset of the tenants who are clearly happy to accept such an intrusion to their lives?
And I also wonder what the general consensus of the PH massive is on this? Would you / do you accept such monitoring around your gaff? As I said, I don't think you have an argument if you choose to live in a town centre - but what about in these suburban housing estates? Is this just par for the course in our modern, progressive society given the cuts to frontline Policing - or is it an intrusion which may benefit from a little opposition and representation on a local level?
I would be interested to hear your thoughts. And sorry for the long post - but it's just what I do

ecsrobin said:
If it stops/reduces crime then I'm all for it. Plus camera operators have to be vetted first so the chances of them using it incorrectly I would suggest are slim.
Not sure I buy the second point.I'm not much of a fan either, I probably wouldn't buy on such an estate, but housing choice is something of a luxury. The real kicker is probably the size of the management fee.
55palfers said:
Providing it is used for the purpose of deterring and detecting crime - perhaps.
NOT if it will be used to generate revenue for parking infringements, etc.
Also, relevant footage to be made available FOC to residents in the event of cars being keyed, etc.
This is the point I believe. I live on a. Ew development and we do have trouble with feral children and trouble makers from outlying areas. Even if it was fake CCTV i think it would be a good deterent. NOT if it will be used to generate revenue for parking infringements, etc.
Also, relevant footage to be made available FOC to residents in the event of cars being keyed, etc.
If it meant the local plod could spend less time sitting on our estate as a deterrent to the local dealer (who predictably lives in a social housing flat), it's got to be a good thing surely? Might discourage those who live in the flats from leaving long burnout lines up the road too.
Scary reading!
As Jefferson said "Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."
This is particularly misguided:
Too many wrongly characterize the debate as security versus privacy when the real choice is liberty versus control. It's attitudes like this which allow surveillance and data retention on a mass scale to perpetuate. You'd be the first to complain if there was a leak or a "bad apple" used the data for nefarious purposes. How about if your collar got felt for behaviour you think is perfectly acceptable but some unsanctioned vigilante neighbourhood CCTV brigade decides it's not cricket?
Best not let it be collected and retained as then there's no way it could be misused!
As Jefferson said "Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."
This is particularly misguided:
ecsrobin said:
Plus camera operators have to be vetted first so the chances of them using it incorrectly I would suggest are slim.
Quite the opposite I expect. The vetting on foreign nurses I'm sure is very thorough but that didn't stop one murdering 22 people. I doubt the checks on low level CCTV operators is anywhere near as good (or even expected to be). Too many wrongly characterize the debate as security versus privacy when the real choice is liberty versus control. It's attitudes like this which allow surveillance and data retention on a mass scale to perpetuate. You'd be the first to complain if there was a leak or a "bad apple" used the data for nefarious purposes. How about if your collar got felt for behaviour you think is perfectly acceptable but some unsanctioned vigilante neighbourhood CCTV brigade decides it's not cricket?
Best not let it be collected and retained as then there's no way it could be misused!
It all comes down to how the footage is used really. If it's solely used for the deterrence and investigation of vandalism, theft, violence and drug crime then that is a good thing. If it's used for peeking through my windows to see what I'm up to, making voyeur porn films, issuing parking tickets and tracking our every move and recording it in a giant database then that's not so good.
As far as I'm aware liberty doesn't imply not being recorded on camera, it comes down to if and how that footage is used for or against us.
As far as I'm aware liberty doesn't imply not being recorded on camera, it comes down to if and how that footage is used for or against us.
TurboHatchback said:
It all comes down to how the footage is used really. If it's solely used for the deterrence and investigation of vandalism, theft, violence and drug crime then that is a good thing. If it's used for peeking through my windows to see what I'm up to, making voyeur porn films, issuing parking tickets and tracking our every move and recording it in a giant database then that's not so good.
As far as I'm aware liberty doesn't imply not being recorded on camera, it comes down to if and how that footage is used for or against us.
But that's my point; you don't know what it is being used for. It's being collected by a commercial organisation without sanction or remit. The company could have a change in management or be sold to new owners with a different agenda at any time who would then have access to prior video collection. They could employ bad staff who misuse or leak the data. Their own security might not be up to scratch so it could be being stolen by somebody else. For all you know, one bad apple could be casing houses out for burglaries and conveniently pointing the camera elsewhere when his cronies go and break in. You just have no idea. As far as I'm aware liberty doesn't imply not being recorded on camera, it comes down to if and how that footage is used for or against us.
You're giving up information about you, your movements and property to an unknown and unregulated organisation in the vain hope they might protect you effectively from "the bad guys". It's security theatre designed to mislead the fearful into thinking they're protected.
The UK has very loose laws on public CCTV (and other monitoring) which have come about as our liberties have become eroded over time. Other countries are much more strict, even in the EU. Germany in particular has strict laws making public CCTV collection by non-governmental agencies illegal (to the point that dashcams are illegal in private cars). We just have a fairly lax CCTV Code of Practice and the Data Protection Act.
Chlamydia said:
_rubinho_ said:
How about if your collar got felt for behaviour you think is perfectly acceptable but some unsanctioned vigilante neighbourhood CCTV brigade decides it's not cricket?
Such as?GAjon said:
I imagine insurance companys have a lot to do with the insistance of CCTV systems on new developments.
I'm not sure they'd be that interested nor have much say in the matter, they're more concerned with flood exposure these days as the costs are so high. You look at a new housing estate with say 100 houses on, how many different insurers or parts of the same insurer will be involved, they all have their own agenda so who would lead an initiative to insist or contribute to installing and monitoring CCTV.
Gassing Station | The Lounge | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



