Is this an Ebay scam ?
Discussion
I recently bought a piece of camera equipment on ebay.
The seller has just emailed me and said that he has sent his newer, updated item that was replacing the old one by mistake, and requested I return it to him, and offered to pay postage.
Is this a scam ? Maybe he will claim the item has been posted and he will have proof ? He has great feedback score, +2000, member since 1999, but anything out of ordinary on ebay sets my scam alert flashing.
The seller has just emailed me and said that he has sent his newer, updated item that was replacing the old one by mistake, and requested I return it to him, and offered to pay postage.
Is this a scam ? Maybe he will claim the item has been posted and he will have proof ? He has great feedback score, +2000, member since 1999, but anything out of ordinary on ebay sets my scam alert flashing.
ExPat2B said:
Well I have asked him to send the other one, and he has refused, saying it would be too much risk to him.
I guess my only other option is to raise an ebay case and send it back recorded delivery.
If you take your other option, at best you're likely to be out the cost of the postage to return it.I guess my only other option is to raise an ebay case and send it back recorded delivery.
If he doesn't trust you enough to send the correct one first, I'd invite him to visit you in person at a location of your convenience to swap them over simultaneously.
Why should you be left out of pocket for his mistake?
Kermit power said:
ExPat2B said:
Well I have asked him to send the other one, and he has refused, saying it would be too much risk to him.
I guess my only other option is to raise an ebay case and send it back recorded delivery.
If you take your other option, at best you're likely to be out the cost of the postage to return it.I guess my only other option is to raise an ebay case and send it back recorded delivery.
If he doesn't trust you enough to send the correct one first, I'd invite him to visit you in person at a location of your convenience to swap them over simultaneously.
Why should you be left out of pocket for his mistake?
ExPat2B said:
Well I have asked him to send the other one, and he has refused, saying it would be too much risk to him.
I guess my only other option is to raise an ebay case and send it back recorded delivery.
Too much risk and yet he wants you to send 'his' back? I guess my only other option is to raise an ebay case and send it back recorded delivery.

NO! Do NOT send it back wait until he has sent the other out. Sounds very, very dodgy to me.
I have done this in the past to customers and always send the replacement out first and then paid/arranged for the wrong one to be collected.
Morningside said:
ExPat2B said:
Well I have asked him to send the other one, and he has refused, saying it would be too much risk to him.
I guess my only other option is to raise an ebay case and send it back recorded delivery.
Too much risk and yet he wants you to send 'his' back? I guess my only other option is to raise an ebay case and send it back recorded delivery.

NO! Do NOT send it back wait until he has sent the other out. Sounds very, very dodgy to me.
I have done this in the past to customers and always send the replacement out first and then paid/arranged for the wrong one to be collected.
To my mind...
Option 1 = He sends the correct one and the money to cover you returning the one you've currently got, and you return the other after that.
Option 2 = He brings the one you should have to you. It's not your fault he's so far away.
If he doesn't trust you to do option 1, and he's not willing to travel for option 2, then...
Option 3 = You keep the one you've got.
As far as I'm concerned, there would be no option 4.
ExPat2B said:
Kermit power said:
ExPat2B said:
Well I have asked him to send the other one, and he has refused, saying it would be too much risk to him.
I guess my only other option is to raise an ebay case and send it back recorded delivery.
If you take your other option, at best you're likely to be out the cost of the postage to return it.I guess my only other option is to raise an ebay case and send it back recorded delivery.
If he doesn't trust you enough to send the correct one first, I'd invite him to visit you in person at a location of your convenience to swap them over simultaneously.
Why should you be left out of pocket for his mistake?
Gassing Station | The Lounge | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



