Pension salary exchange
Pension salary exchange
Author
Discussion

egor110

Original Poster:

17,675 posts

233 months

Friday 14th August 2015
quotequote all
My employer has put us all into a pension salary scheme.

From what I can gather the employer pays my portion plus the employer contributions into my pension , I then have my portion taken out of my wage packet and pay less national insurance.

Surely when I come to retire this will reduce my state pension as my n.i contributions have reduced.

Secondly I'm tied into this for a year before I can opt out, so I'm £80 a week better off.

Should i make extra n.i payments or use it to overpay the mortgage ( should be paid off in 5 years already) or dump it in a isa.

PurpleMoonlight

22,362 posts

187 months

Friday 14th August 2015
quotequote all
None of what you have written makes much sense.

What is a pension salary scheme? Is it a defined contribution or defined benefit scheme?

How can you be better off now by making pension contributions?


blank

3,765 posts

218 months

Friday 14th August 2015
quotequote all
Paying less NI won't matter.

As long as you've paid in for enough time.

I.e. someone who earns £50k a year for their working life doesn't get more pension than someone who earned £30k despite them paying way more NI over the years.

If your employer is paying something in addition to your salary sacrifice you'd be mad to opt out of free money unless you desperately need it!

timbo999

1,547 posts

285 months

Friday 14th August 2015
quotequote all
As blank says its how long you pay NI for (in years - you need 30 years for full state pension, soon to rise to 35 I think) not how much you pay in... Anyone who earns more than £109 a week pays NI and earns the same entitlement as someone who earns 10 times that.

As blank also says, the pension scheme you been enrolled in appears to a 'salary sacrifice' scheme.

What this means is that your employer takes the pension contribution off your salary before you pay any tax and NI (i.e. you 'sacrifice' some salary) - the advantage is that it then goes into your pension without you (or your employer) paying NI or tax on it. It is possible the most efficient way of paying into a pension.

If your employer is also making contributions then that is free money you can get no other way... so not taking it to pay off a mortgage seems counter intuitive unless you have a very high interest rate on your mortgage.


egor110

Original Poster:

17,675 posts

233 months

Saturday 15th August 2015
quotequote all
timbo999 said:
As blank says its how long you pay NI for (in years - you need 30 years for full state pension, soon to rise to 35 I think) not how much you pay in... Anyone who earns more than £109 a week pays NI and earns the same entitlement as someone who earns 10 times that.

As blank also says, the pension scheme you been enrolled in appears to a 'salary sacrifice' scheme.

What this means is that your employer takes the pension contribution off your salary before you pay any tax and NI (i.e. you 'sacrifice' some salary) - the advantage is that it then goes into your pension without you (or your employer) paying NI or tax on it. It is possible the most efficient way of paying into a pension.

If your employer is also making contributions then that is free money you can get no other way... so not taking it to pay off a mortgage seems counter intuitive unless you have a very high interest rate on your mortgage.
Does the fact my employer has opted out of the 2nd tier pension make any difference?

otherman

2,266 posts

195 months

Saturday 15th August 2015
quotequote all
I think you might mean a salary sacrifice scheme?

timbo999

1,547 posts

285 months

Saturday 15th August 2015
quotequote all
egor110 said:
Does the fact my employer has opted out of the 2nd tier pension make any difference?
No, its probably better value for money in that you get all the benefit of your contributions. One of the stated aims of S2P was to provide more income redistribution (i.e. the wealthy subsidise the less well off) than SERPS.

However, I believe S2P will be discontinued when the single tier pension is introduced (not sure when that might be...) although previous contributions will be honoured.



oop north

1,711 posts

158 months

Sunday 16th August 2015
quotequote all
Second tier pension. What do you mean by that? Cannot refer t s2p because it has not been possible to opt out of that for a few years. Flat rate pension I think applies from April 2016 (2017?). On its introduction the old s2p / serps pension is protected

James 33

366 posts

134 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
We are got a letter at work about Salary Sacrifice yesterday and have until 2nd November to opt out.
I have a few concerns before i make my mind up.
Every year we get a pay rise of around 2%. If on paper at least my Salary is now less then i will be looking at less of a pay increase. Also some of the longer serving guys at work are on final salary pensions so won't be affected by this. At the moment we all earn the same so come pay rise time they will get a bigger pay rise and the gap will get wider each year. Or am i missing something?

JulianPH

10,084 posts

144 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
OP - It sounds like your employer has enrolled you into their 'Auto Enrolment' pension (as all employers have to do by law).

Part of your salary is invested each month (tax free) and your employer also invests money for you each month (at their own cost - free to you).

You can opt out whenever you want, but you will be turning down free money.

As has been said, NI contributions are not impacted at all.

egor110

Original Poster:

17,675 posts

233 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
JulianPH said:
OP - It sounds like your employer has enrolled you into their 'Auto Enrolment' pension (as all employers have to do by law).

Part of your salary is invested each month (tax free) and your employer also invests money for you each month (at their own cost - free to you).

You can opt out whenever you want, but you will be turning down free money.

As has been said, NI contributions are not impacted at all.
I've been in royal mail's pension scheme since 1990 , my post was more is it worth doing the salary sacrifice which is different from your defined benefit/contribution pension.

Jimmy Recard

17,550 posts

209 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
egor110 said:
I've been in royal mail's pension scheme since 1990 , my post was more is it worth doing the salary sacrifice which is different from your defined benefit/contribution pension.
What have you been doing for the last three years?

dingg

4,547 posts

249 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
Posting letters?
Or sewing mailbags?

JulianPH

10,084 posts

144 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
Sorry OP, I'm with Purple Moonlight and Jimmy Recard on this. It makes no sense.

We can only provide information based upon what we are given...

anonymous-user

84 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
James 33 said:
Every year we get a pay rise of around 2%. If on paper at least my Salary is now less then i will be looking at less of a pay increase.
No this isn't correct. Part of your salary will be paid onto your pension instead of directly to you so any % increase will be applied to the base number before the pension is taken out.

What it does mean is if you get a 2% rise that your pension contribution will rise.

So if you get £1000 today and pay £200 of that as a salary sacrifice into your pension then after your pay rise youll
get £1020 of which £204 will go into pension and £816 will be your before tax and NI salary

CaptainSlow

13,179 posts

242 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
JulianPH said:
Sorry OP, I'm with Purple Moonlight and Jimmy Recard on this. It makes no sense.

We can only provide information based upon what we are given...
It's pretty clear he's in/was in a salary sacrifice scheme as noted three years ago.

James 33

366 posts

134 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
keirik said:
James 33 said:
Every year we get a pay rise of around 2%. If on paper at least my Salary is now less then i will be looking at less of a pay increase.
No this isn't correct. Part of your salary will be paid onto your pension instead of directly to you so any % increase will be applied to the base number before the pension is taken out.

What it does mean is if you get a 2% rise that your pension contribution will rise.

So if you get £1000 today and pay £200 of that as a salary sacrifice into your pension then after your pay rise youll
get £1020 of which £204 will go into pension and £816 will be your before tax and NI salary
Thanks. Thought that would be the case but wanted to be sure.

emicen

9,238 posts

248 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
James 33 said:
keirik said:
James 33 said:
Every year we get a pay rise of around 2%. If on paper at least my Salary is now less then i will be looking at less of a pay increase.
No this isn't correct. Part of your salary will be paid onto your pension instead of directly to you so any % increase will be applied to the base number before the pension is taken out.

What it does mean is if you get a 2% rise that your pension contribution will rise.

So if you get £1000 today and pay £200 of that as a salary sacrifice into your pension then after your pay rise youll
get £1020 of which £204 will go into pension and £816 will be your before tax and NI salary
Thanks. Thought that would be the case but wanted to be sure.
Unless someone on PH works for your company’s HR department, it’s probably the HR team you want to be making sure of things with wink

In most cases, raises are calculated on the pre-salary sacrifice salary. Also worth confirming they would write a letter confirming your pre-sacrifice salary for the purposes of mortgage applications etc.