BMW 328i E36 Touring: very heavy oil consumption
BMW 328i E36 Touring: very heavy oil consumption
Author
Discussion

B234R

Original Poster:

85 posts

132 months

Sunday 6th December 2015
quotequote all
Well, I bought a 328i E36 with 130,000 miles at the end of June and after 1,500 miles I saw the oil level had lowered a bit. Nothing special.

A few days later I changed the oil (5w40, Motul X-Cess BMW LL-01), and since that, my car drinks oil like crazy, about 1.5 litres/ 600 miles. BMW says that up to 1 litre/ 600 miles is "acceptable", but even that is huge.

A week ago I changed the CCV valve and its two hoses. After that I made two tests:

-First test, about 380 miles, including city driving on short trips (cold engine), motorway at moderate speeds, and mountain roads using lots of RPMs. Oil consumption: 0.25 litres. That´s about 0.4 litres/600 miles, a considerable reduction.

-Second test, yesterday, about 180 miles, single carriage roads at moderate speeds, only revving the engine to 5,000 RPM three or four times. Oil consumption: 0.6 litres, or 2 litres/600 miles eek

I´m completely baffled about this irregular oil consumption. The car pulls very well, fuel economy is good, and a compression test has shown acceptable figures.

I´m planning to use an engine cleaner like the Xenum M-Flush (I´ve heard good comments about it), and after that switch to 10w40 oil. But I´m afraid it will not be too succesful. Could it be better a 10w60, like Mobil 1 Extended Life, or is it too thick for the oil pump? Low temperatures are not a worry where I live.

If you have some helpful experience, it would be nice...

Thanks!

Mave

8,217 posts

246 months

Sunday 6th December 2015
quotequote all
What are you hoping to achieve with the oil treatment? Have you done any diagnosis other than compression check? I'm not aware of any valve problem with that engine, but it could be valve seal related if you're burning more oil when you spend more time at small throttle openings?

B234R

Original Poster:

85 posts

132 months

Monday 7th December 2015
quotequote all
Mave said:
What are you hoping to achieve with the oil treatment? Have you done any diagnosis other than compression check? I'm not aware of any valve problem with that engine, but it could be valve seal related if you're burning more oil when you spend more time at small throttle openings?
I´m interested in the engine cleaner, first, because despite the oil is relatively new, when I check the level the oil in the dipstick is dirtier than it should; and second, because perhaps the piston rings are stuck and that cleaner could loose them.

I haven´t done anything apart from the compression test, I´ll take the car to the workshop to do a leak down test, and we´ll see if valve seals are shot.

Thanks for your answer.

Mave

8,217 posts

246 months

Monday 7th December 2015
quotequote all
I'm not sure if a leak down test will check valve stem seals - old school way was to floor it I second and then come right off the throttle, with someone behind you looking for q hint of blue from the tail pipe.

B234R

Original Poster:

85 posts

132 months

Monday 7th December 2015
quotequote all
Well, that´s a cheap (and fun) test, so I´ll give it a go.

Thanks.

McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Monday 7th December 2015
quotequote all
Starting at the start - the sump nut and oil filter are correctly tightened and well sealed, aren't they?

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Monday 7th December 2015
quotequote all
Oil flush, oil treatment - spend the money in the pub instead, it'll be of more use. You could have an old Nikasil engine - this is the alloy block with Nikasil (Nickel silicon coating) and when it wears off to a degree, the engine loses a bit of compression and oil usage soars. This idea was replaced in Feb/March 1998 (so during the run off R registrations) with a steel linered block. Clueless sorts still call these units alusil, but it's not. It's steel linered. Alusil is silicon alloy from which later V8 and V12 blocks were cast.
BMW replaced a lot of shagged Nikasil engined under good will (when BMW exhibited such a trait - a long tome ago now) with steel liner short blocks. The way you can identify these is by looking at the block under the starter (passenger side) for a rusty steel tag secured by a small bolt. Nikasil blocks will have a cast in lug that is pear shaped, a bit like the engine when it goes tits up.

5/40 is too thin for a high mileage 15-20 year old BMW. You need to be running a 10/40 in that - nothing fancy, just a decent semi synthetic.

McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Monday 7th December 2015
quotequote all
iSore said:
5/40 is too thin for a high mileage 15-20 year old BMW. You need to be running a 10/40 in that - nothing fancy, just a decent semi synthetic.
Really? Both my 161k E46 road car and 180k E36 track car use 0W/40 Mobil 1, neither use a drop, it comes out pretty good at changes, and the track car never sounds tappety no matter how hard it's driven.

B234R

Original Poster:

85 posts

132 months

Monday 7th December 2015
quotequote all
McSam said:
Starting at the start - the sump nut and oil filter are correctly tightened and well sealed, aren't they?
Yes, there are no oil leaks. The ground is clean...well, more or less, I have a very small leak of power steering fluid.

B234R

Original Poster:

85 posts

132 months

Monday 7th December 2015
quotequote all
iSore said:
Oil flush, oil treatment - spend the money in the pub instead, it'll be of more use. You could have an old Nikasil engine - this is the alloy block with Nikasil (Nickel silicon coating) and when it wears off to a degree, the engine loses a bit of compression and oil usage soars. This idea was replaced in Feb/March 1998 (so during the run off R registrations) with a steel linered block. Clueless sorts still call these units alusil, but it's not. It's steel linered. Alusil is silicon alloy from which later V8 and V12 blocks were cast.
BMW replaced a lot of shagged Nikasil engined under good will (when BMW exhibited such a trait - a long tome ago now) with steel liner short blocks. The way you can identify these is by looking at the block under the starter (passenger side) for a rusty steel tag secured by a small bolt. Nikasil blocks will have a cast in lug that is pear shaped, a bit like the engine when it goes tits up.

5/40 is too thin for a high mileage 15-20 year old BMW. You need to be running a 10/40 in that - nothing fancy, just a decent semi synthetic.
I haven´t checked it, but I´m almost sure that my car has a Nikasil block. Nikasil problems were rare in Spain, where I live (and the car has spent its life here). Of course, it´s possible the poor car had a hard life and needs oil rings, valve seals, etc. normal wear if the car has been abused.

The compression test showed this:

Cylinder 1: 10.8 bar (156,64 psi)
Cylinder 2: 12 bar (174,04 psi)
Cylinder 3: 11 bar (159,54 psi)
Cylinder 4: 11 bar (159,54 psi)
Cylinder 5: 11.2 bar (162,44 psi)
Cylinder 6: 11.1 bar (160,99 psi)

Through they´re not great, they´re acceptable, and the variation between cylinder 1 and 2 is not excessive. I think.

This week I´ll change the oil to 10w40 and we´ll see, but having spent a bit of time reading experiences on the Internet, it´s curious how some 328i don´t use a drop of oil and another ones need frequent top ups.

I´m very grateful for your help chaps clap

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Monday 7th December 2015
quotequote all
McSam said:
eally? Both my 161k E46 road car and 180k E36 track car use 0W/40 Mobil 1, neither use a drop, it comes out pretty good at changes, and the track car never sounds tappety no matter how hard it's driven.
Lucky you! :-)

But normally, M54 engined stuff drinks oil and the standard 'fix' is to change to a thicker oil.



iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Monday 7th December 2015
quotequote all
B234R said:
I haven´t checked it, but I´m almost sure that my car has a Nikasil block. Nikasil problems were rare in Spain, where I live (and the car has spent its life here). Of course, it´s possible the poor car had a hard life and needs oil rings, valve seals, etc. normal wear if the car has been abused.

The compression test showed this:

Cylinder 1: 10.8 bar (156,64 psi)
Cylinder 2: 12 bar (174,04 psi)
Cylinder 3: 11 bar (159,54 psi)
Cylinder 4: 11 bar (159,54 psi)
Cylinder 5: 11.2 bar (162,44 psi)
Cylinder 6: 11.1 bar (160,99 psi)

Through they´re not great, they´re acceptable, and the variation between cylinder 1 and 2 is not excessive. I think.

This week I´ll change the oil to 10w40 and we´ll see, but having spent a bit of time reading experiences on the Internet, it´s curious how some 328i don´t use a drop of oil and another ones need frequent top ups.

I´m very grateful for your help chaps clap
175 psi is where it should be, and 159 psi indicates that it's just starting to get tired. Not terminal, but I'd change the oil and see how it goes. I'm sure it'll be okay.

The Nikasil issue is rare in Germany too.

McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Monday 7th December 2015
quotequote all
iSore said:
McSam said:
Really? Both my 161k E46 road car and 180k E36 track car use 0W/40 Mobil 1, neither use a drop, it comes out pretty good at changes, and the track car never sounds tappety no matter how hard it's driven.
Lucky you! :-)

But normally, M54 engined stuff drinks oil and the standard 'fix' is to change to a thicker oil.
Ah, it's an M54 problem, then? Both of mine are M52s, like the OP's car. 0W/40 seems to be the oil of choice for the 328i.

Those compression figures are really at the low end of what I'd hope to see, and it's quite telling that #2 is 9% higher than average - you can't magically make more compression, so it suggests the others are somewhat lacking..

For comparison, my M52TUB28:
No. 1 - 192psi
No. 2 - 193psi
No. 3 - 191psi
No. 4 - 192psi
No. 5 - 191psi
No. 6 - 195psi

Obviously these gauges aren't exactly calibrated for the absolute values, but in terms of variation..

B234R

Original Poster:

85 posts

132 months

Monday 7th December 2015
quotequote all
Yes, the compression values aren´t too healthy but according to Bentley workshop manual they aren´t bad (minimum must be 10-11 bar/ 142-156 psi).

I´m going to switch to 10w40 (if the car drinks 5w40 oil, I´m afraid 0w40 would be like water) and watch.

If my car´s drinking habit continues, I´ll have another compression test with different gauges and a leak down test. And I´ll see if it is worth to remove the head to put new valve seals, piston rings, etc..or look for a good used engine, from a 328i E36 (few in Spain) or a 328i E46/ 528i E39 (rather more available).

Thanks!!!


helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Monday 7th December 2015
quotequote all
328i E46 is a different engine, the M52tu, with twin vanos.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 8th December 2015
quotequote all
B234R said:
Yes, the compression values aren´t too healthy but according to Bentley workshop manual they aren´t bad (minimum must be 10-11 bar/ 142-156 psi).

I´m going to switch to 10w40 (if the car drinks 5w40 oil, I´m afraid 0w40 would be like water) and watch.

If my car´s drinking habit continues, I´ll have another compression test with different gauges and a leak down test. And I´ll see if it is worth to remove the head to put new valve seals, piston rings, etc..or look for a good used engine, from a 328i E36 (few in Spain) or a 328i E46/ 528i E39 (rather more available).

Thanks!!!
0/40, 5/40, 10/40 isn't going to make a scrap of difference except, perhaps, for a few minutes when you start up. You do realise what those numbers mean don't you? To all intents and purposes, given your circumstances, they are all the same.


B234R

Original Poster:

85 posts

132 months

Tuesday 8th December 2015
quotequote all
Right, I forgot E46 had double Vanos. And is it difficult to install an early single Vanos 528i E39?

I´m afraid that switching to a thicker oil isn´t going to work, but right now it´s the cheaper thing to do...the only hope is the engine drinks more oil when cold, that´s why I´m going to try 10w40, or perhaps even 15w40.

The thing that I don´t understand is that in the first test oil consumption lowered a lot, and in the second was so high. And with that kind of thirst (almost 2 litre/600 miles) I should see a lot of blue smoke in the exhaust, and the rear end should be very dirty. There are only a few tiny black points.


528Sport

1,470 posts

265 months

Tuesday 8th December 2015
quotequote all
Hi,
My old 528 (1999) M52tu engine (double vanos) drank no oil between services and it had 170K on the clock
amazing.

Then one cold day I started it up and a huge cloud of blue smoke appeared, checked oil and was half way between max-min.

I changed the ccv as you have done but I also cleaned out the dipstick tube, on mine and I assume yours will be the same the pipe that the bottom ccv hose connects onto was jammed solid with crap (dipstick tube is Y shaped, one side for dipstick, one side went to ccv and bottom goes to sump. it was the Y tube that was blocked on mine. )

It took ages to clean out but after this was done the issue went away


hope that helps


Dave



Edited by 528Sport on Tuesday 8th December 15:05

B234R

Original Poster:

85 posts

132 months

Tuesday 8th December 2015
quotequote all
I suppose you mean the small bit at the bottom of the dipstick

http://www.etk.cc/bmw/EN/search/selectCar/E39/Lim/...

What did you use to clean it? is it difficult to remove it?

Thanks!

B234R

Original Poster:

85 posts

132 months

Wednesday 9th December 2015
quotequote all
Mave said:
I'm not sure if a leak down test will check valve stem seals - old school way was to floor it I second and then come right off the throttle, with someone behind you looking for q hint of blue from the tail pipe.
This afternoon, I floor it in second till 6000 rpm and a friend behind my car sees lots of blue smoke....step off the throttle and no smoke. I suppose that means piston rings shot or bore wear. I´m not happy.