RE: USA SUV SVP
Friday 16th August 2002
USA SUV SVP
The SUV is here to stay - deal with it, says Robert Farago
Discussion
"Pundits often claim that the SUV's elevated driving position is the key
to their success. Specifically, they maintain that the extra ability to
see what's ahead makes drivers-especially women-feel safer.
Supposedly, this height also creates a sense of superiority (a feeling
not unknown to pundits)."
How can you see ahead when the next vehicle is another SUV at the same height?!
to their success. Specifically, they maintain that the extra ability to
see what's ahead makes drivers-especially women-feel safer.
Supposedly, this height also creates a sense of superiority (a feeling
not unknown to pundits)."
How can you see ahead when the next vehicle is another SUV at the same height?!
Corporate hypocrisy is nothing new.
It's not BMW's job to shift the tide of excess and obesity in America. They just sell cars to whomever will buy them.
SUVs will fade from memory, eventually, as their consequences become more and more apparent -- as oil prices rise, the environment falls apart, and the soccer moms learn what it means to flip their 8-ton Excursion, crushing the life out of them and their children.
It's not BMW's job to shift the tide of excess and obesity in America. They just sell cars to whomever will buy them.
SUVs will fade from memory, eventually, as their consequences become more and more apparent -- as oil prices rise, the environment falls apart, and the soccer moms learn what it means to flip their 8-ton Excursion, crushing the life out of them and their children.
It's got a lot to do with safety also. Your average American 'Mom' feels much safer driving her kids about in a Ford Excursion than a Toyota Corolla. It's true! I've had a head on collision in my Range Rover with a Ford Escort. I had my wife and kids in the car and we were fine - the Escort driver was a bit of a mess!!
However, I've got a new Mini on order, so I don't dislike small cars. It's horses for courses. The Mini will sell in the States as a novelty. I'm sure as long as they have cheap gas, American will continue to drive big cars.
However, I've got a new Mini on order, so I don't dislike small cars. It's horses for courses. The Mini will sell in the States as a novelty. I'm sure as long as they have cheap gas, American will continue to drive big cars.
quote:
It's got a lot to do with safety also. Your average American 'Mom' feels much safer driving her kids about in a Ford Excursion than a Toyota Corolla. It's true! I've had a head on collision in my Range Rover with a Ford Escort. I had my wife and kids in the car and we were fine - the Escort driver was a bit of a mess!!
However, I've got a new Mini on order, so I don't dislike small cars. It's horses for courses. The Mini will sell in the States as a novelty. I'm sure as long as they have cheap gas, American will continue to drive big cars.
I whacked a Montego into a Range Rover - and won!
Oh dear. IMHO SUVs just reflect overall obesity in the U.S. and as usual we follow the trend with smaller versions.
Massive gas guzzlers. They should be classed and taxed as trucks.
I'm sure a Boeing 747 would be great to drive on the road and fly, but do we want everyone to have one to do their shopping in?
Massive gas guzzlers. They should be classed and taxed as trucks.
I'm sure a Boeing 747 would be great to drive on the road and fly, but do we want everyone to have one to do their shopping in?
Large engined vehicles are taxed more heavily in the UK than smaller vehicles. Not only in Road Tax, but in Petrol Excise duty also (as they generally use more fuel and hence generate more income for the treasury!).
It would be a sad world indeed if we all had to drive around in Trabants or similar.
When I go out in a vehicle, I have a choice of my bike (600 Bandit), which I can drive alone, a Chimeara, with one passenger, a Fiesta which allows me to take up to three passengers, or my Range Rover, which will haul me, my wife, three children, my Labrador and tow a trailer. It's horses for courses and I'm glad I am fortunate enough to have the choice. Big vehicles are more flexible and will do more things -including burning more fuel. It's a fact of life. It has very little to do with obesity, but four average Americans would have a job fitting into a Fiesta comfortably.
It would be a sad world indeed if we all had to drive around in Trabants or similar.
When I go out in a vehicle, I have a choice of my bike (600 Bandit), which I can drive alone, a Chimeara, with one passenger, a Fiesta which allows me to take up to three passengers, or my Range Rover, which will haul me, my wife, three children, my Labrador and tow a trailer. It's horses for courses and I'm glad I am fortunate enough to have the choice. Big vehicles are more flexible and will do more things -including burning more fuel. It's a fact of life. It has very little to do with obesity, but four average Americans would have a job fitting into a Fiesta comfortably.
I enjoyed that - great stuff. For a yank, his irony thing could almost pass as british.
Its not just the SUVs they go mad for - its pick-ups, the size of which you have never seen. They are 4x4xloads of power with front and back seats. I even saw one with a propeller on the back (for fording streams I guess). Like the SUVs, these are seldom used for "picking up" anything and are usually immaculately clean.
But as someone said - if UK fuel was as cheap as it is here, the roads wouyld be packed with sumilar redundancies.
Its not just the SUVs they go mad for - its pick-ups, the size of which you have never seen. They are 4x4xloads of power with front and back seats. I even saw one with a propeller on the back (for fording streams I guess). Like the SUVs, these are seldom used for "picking up" anything and are usually immaculately clean.
But as someone said - if UK fuel was as cheap as it is here, the roads wouyld be packed with sumilar redundancies.
Ive banged on about this on the evo forum aswell.
Read the article, SUVs make sense within the context in which they are used. Towing boats, going skiing etc.
I love the things as much as I love performance cars, they just have different uses. I much rather tackel a three hour drive to a ski resort in bad weather with 3 friends in an expedition etc than in some diesel audi (at best!!)
Personaly, my vote goes to the Yukon. Absolutely brilliant; in that uniquely american way!
Read the article, SUVs make sense within the context in which they are used. Towing boats, going skiing etc.
I love the things as much as I love performance cars, they just have different uses. I much rather tackel a three hour drive to a ski resort in bad weather with 3 friends in an expedition etc than in some diesel audi (at best!!)
Personaly, my vote goes to the Yukon. Absolutely brilliant; in that uniquely american way!
"Obviously, such common sense will have precious little impact on those who condemn SUVs. To be fair, there's a lot to hate about the breed. They guzzle gas like frat boys draining a keg of beer. They pour hydrocarbons into the atmosphere (although a single London bus emits more toxins than 50 SUVs)."
You're right about the gas consumption, but most of these things qualify for LEV (low emission vehicle) or ULEV (ultra-low emission vehicle) status. There are far more junkers out there using just as much gas and spewing way more pollutants into the air than there are SUVs. And most people feel very safe in their SUV, whether they actually are or not.
"And as long as Americans live in a free society, they'll feel free to buy the vehicle that best suits their desire for fun and comfort."
Exactly.
You're right about the gas consumption, but most of these things qualify for LEV (low emission vehicle) or ULEV (ultra-low emission vehicle) status. There are far more junkers out there using just as much gas and spewing way more pollutants into the air than there are SUVs. And most people feel very safe in their SUV, whether they actually are or not.
"And as long as Americans live in a free society, they'll feel free to buy the vehicle that best suits their desire for fun and comfort."
Exactly.
There is ONE big reason BMW is building Mini's. That is the USA's CAFE (Corporate Average Fuel Economy) requirement. It works like this - all USA BMW's are averaged by sales volume for their fuel economy, if the average is over a certain threshold, they pay a tax per vehicle to the US government. As BMW owns Mini, those Mini sales DROP the Corporate Average Fuel Economy to an acceptable level, so they can sell more high profit SUV's, 7 series, 5 series, etc. without paying the tax.
Not many people know this, but a small British firm based in Leyland has the answer to SUV fuel economy.
Torotrak plc has developed a revolutionary new transmission called IVT ( Infinitely Variable Transmission )have a look at: www.torotrak.com , Ford & GM have been developing it with Torotrak for many years for their SUV range ( as well as BMW, Getrag, ZF, Aisin, Volvo trucks etc, etc ). It gives up to 28% better fuel economy. Expect to see it on the market in the next 3 to 4 years ( thats when my Torotrak shares will make me very wealthy!!!!! ), the more SUVs the better!!!!
Torotrak plc has developed a revolutionary new transmission called IVT ( Infinitely Variable Transmission )have a look at: www.torotrak.com , Ford & GM have been developing it with Torotrak for many years for their SUV range ( as well as BMW, Getrag, ZF, Aisin, Volvo trucks etc, etc ). It gives up to 28% better fuel economy. Expect to see it on the market in the next 3 to 4 years ( thats when my Torotrak shares will make me very wealthy!!!!! ), the more SUVs the better!!!!
As long as we are espousing American stereotypes, lets get it straight.
We all make too much money, drive big cars that Top Gear loves to hate, we are all fat, wastefull, arrogant, polluting, armed to the teeth with guns, and more guns, and don't know anything about the world except what we see on Friday night WWF.
By the way... I drive a Chimaera 450, and a Volvo.
I had a Ford Explorer on order until I found out that Ford had replaced the cigarette lighter with a lipstick holder.
We all make too much money, drive big cars that Top Gear loves to hate, we are all fat, wastefull, arrogant, polluting, armed to the teeth with guns, and more guns, and don't know anything about the world except what we see on Friday night WWF.
By the way... I drive a Chimaera 450, and a Volvo.
I had a Ford Explorer on order until I found out that Ford had replaced the cigarette lighter with a lipstick holder.
As a "Yank" that much prefers small cars like the MX-5 I found the article not so enlightening and hyperbolic but funny.
I do want to point out that there are quite a few untruths written in this article. Firstly, there are not more gun owners than computer owners in the USA. Damn near everyone has a computer while maybe 40% of us own guns. Of course that 40% own about 15 guns each so there are many more guns than computers.
Secondly, SUV's do not comprise 50% of total passenger vehicle sales in the USA. Trucks compose 51% of USA sales. SUV's are a subset of the truck category and so are minivans and pick up trucks. Even the Chrysler PT Cruiser is classified as a truck.
SUV's, trucks, cars, etc. are all required to pass the same emmissions regulations in the USA. These regulations limit the amount of pollutants (including hydrocarbons) that can be emitted by a vehicle per mile driven. A Ford expedition emits no more pollutants than a Mazda MX-5. Unlike the UK the USA has not classified caron dioxide as a pollutant. Due to poor fuel efficiency the truck category does emit more carbon dioxide than cars.
It is true that the USA is the fattest country. It is not true that 50% of Americans are clinically obese. In reality close to 65% of Americans are "over-weight" but only 20% of Americans are clinically obese. Don't laugh, the UK is not far behind!
I do want to point out that there are quite a few untruths written in this article. Firstly, there are not more gun owners than computer owners in the USA. Damn near everyone has a computer while maybe 40% of us own guns. Of course that 40% own about 15 guns each so there are many more guns than computers.
Secondly, SUV's do not comprise 50% of total passenger vehicle sales in the USA. Trucks compose 51% of USA sales. SUV's are a subset of the truck category and so are minivans and pick up trucks. Even the Chrysler PT Cruiser is classified as a truck.
SUV's, trucks, cars, etc. are all required to pass the same emmissions regulations in the USA. These regulations limit the amount of pollutants (including hydrocarbons) that can be emitted by a vehicle per mile driven. A Ford expedition emits no more pollutants than a Mazda MX-5. Unlike the UK the USA has not classified caron dioxide as a pollutant. Due to poor fuel efficiency the truck category does emit more carbon dioxide than cars.
It is true that the USA is the fattest country. It is not true that 50% of Americans are clinically obese. In reality close to 65% of Americans are "over-weight" but only 20% of Americans are clinically obese. Don't laugh, the UK is not far behind!
cwage said: Corporate hypocrisy is nothing new.
It's not BMW's job to shift the tide of excess and obesity in America. They just sell cars to whomever will buy them.
SUVs will fade from memory, eventually, as their consequences become more and more apparent -- as oil prices rise, the environment falls apart, and the soccer moms learn what it means to flip their 8-ton Excursion, crushing the life out of them and their children.
Of course you could be right. I'm sure that if American punters take a look at the Mini and don't like it that much, then BMW will take great delight in flogging them an X5 instead...
Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





