E92 17" to 18" wheel handling impressions
E92 17" to 18" wheel handling impressions
Author
Discussion

SoupAnxiety

Original Poster:

309 posts

141 months

Thursday 10th December 2015
quotequote all
I've got an itch for 18" staggered wheels (ideally MV3 off the M Sport) for my E92 330i SE, my logic being the ~10mm drop in sidewall height will instantly make things "better" by reduce sidewall flex.

It's an itch rather than a necessity, I'm really happy with the square setup and neutral behaviour on 17" wheels. I'm running Eibach Pro springs and Bilstein shocks, I'm not into lowering but at 130k my suspension was shot and I wanted sporty rather than the SE boat setup. I've got Goodyear Eagle F1 AS3 go flats all round.

Has anybody switched from 17" to 18" wheels? Any opinions on handling changes would be welcome, especially with the wider rears and understeer. I think deep down I know the 17" setup is a good balance for all year round use but for some reason I can't stop eBay hunting. Ideally I'm looking for a grown up to talk me out of bigger wheels.

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Thursday 10th December 2015
quotequote all
The only "issue" is that the staggered 18" setup reduces the range of tyres available - I'd have liked to have tried the Goodyears but you can't get them in 255/35/18 size. Other than that it's difficult to say what it'll feel like without trying it.

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Thursday 10th December 2015
quotequote all
I've gone to a square 17 set up, for winters, on my 335i.

The smaller wheels do make the ride more comfortable (a bit) and the car feels lighter, but it doesn't improve handling. I'm talking about pushing it to the limit on the twisties.

My summers are a 19s staggered and with the MPSS' I can drive the car to the limits of the 3 series' chassis, in a way I couldn't with the dreadful run shats.

I had staggered 18s on my E46 and that was good.

As MP said, I think the bigger issues will be that it reduces your tyre choice and increases costs.

Maybe see if you can test drive and E92 M Sport on 18s to see if there's is an issue for you??





SoupAnxiety

Original Poster:

309 posts

141 months

Friday 11th December 2015
quotequote all
Thanks guys. It doesn't seem there's a night and day difference between 17s and 18s in terms of handling, I don't drive flat out on the roads and 19s would make me cry in terms of tyre expense and (further) pothole fear. My friend has a 320d M Sport so I'll try to compare. For reasons of vanity I would like the 18s though!

nickfrog

25,492 posts

248 months

Friday 11th December 2015
quotequote all
No one drives flat out on the road even if they think they do. Racing cars minimise the wheel size and run fat sidewalls. Things like sidewall stifness, pressure, suspension kinematics, minimising unsprung weight and secondary rotational inertia are far more important from a driving experience pov.

SoupAnxiety

Original Poster:

309 posts

141 months

Friday 11th December 2015
quotequote all
It's purely a vanity issue, I think 17s make sense for all year round use and tyre cost and there's no handling advantage to 18s. Talked myself out of my own question!

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 11th December 2015
quotequote all
nickfrog said:
No one drives flat out on the road even if they think they do. Racing cars minimise the wheel size and run fat sidewalls. Things like sidewall stifness, pressure, suspension kinematics, minimising unsprung weight and secondary rotational inertia are far more important from a driving experience pov.
This. All this talk of driving to the limits of the chassis etc is utter bks.

SoupAnxiety

Original Poster:

309 posts

141 months

Sunday 13th December 2015
quotequote all
I barely get the oil up to temperature on my commute, there's absolutely no scope for driving flat out even if I fancied my chances as a driving God. I had talked myself out of replacing my 17" wheels on my E92 until I spotted a Vauxhall Meriva 1.2 with 225/45R17!

SoupAnxiety

Original Poster:

309 posts

141 months

Tuesday 26th January 2016
quotequote all
Monty Python said:
The only "issue" is that the staggered 18" setup reduces the range of tyres available - I'd have liked to have tried the Goodyears but you can't get them in 255/35/18 size. Other than that it's difficult to say what it'll feel like without trying it.
Picked up a set of 18"s today and managed to get Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2 in 255/35R18. Just a heads up for next time you change your tyres.

Kawasicki

14,432 posts

266 months

Tuesday 26th January 2016
quotequote all
REALIST123 said:
nickfrog said:
No one drives flat out on the road even if they think they do. Racing cars minimise the wheel size and run fat sidewalls. Things like sidewall stifness, pressure, suspension kinematics, minimising unsprung weight and secondary rotational inertia are far more important from a driving experience pov.
This. All this talk of driving to the limits of the chassis etc is utter bks.
I disagree on that point. Occasionally people do drive to the limit, on the public road. Not often though, I do admit.

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Tuesday 26th January 2016
quotequote all
SoupAnxiety said:
Picked up a set of 18"s today and managed to get Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2 in 255/35R18. Just a heads up for next time you change your tyres.
I meant if you stick to RFTs.