Looking for a straight 6 petrol - thoughts appreciated.
Looking for a straight 6 petrol - thoughts appreciated.
Author
Discussion

pointedstarman

Original Poster:

554 posts

177 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
I've decided to scratch an itch for a straight 6 petrol as a treat for my 50th. We have an F10 for family work so this will be a second car. Requirements are;
- £9k max price.
- 3 litre petrol preferred (would like a V8 but reliability worries me).
- 4 seats but rears for kids only.
- likely to be manual.
- reliability as must.

Top of my list is the 130i. There are a few LImited Editions around that really appeal. May consider a 330i coupe if price / condition / spec are right but concerned it'd be too similar day to day to the F10 (a 525d 3.0 six pot).

Anyone got any thoughts / advice / experience before I pull the trigger (probably next week whilst I'm not at work).

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
What age of car are you looking at?

junglie

2,052 posts

248 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
130i is a great car and the engine is a peach; more muscular at low revs than you may imagine and smooth all the way past the red line.

I have always had a soft spot for an E46 330i be it saloon, coupe or convertible. The facelift in Sport trim looks great still and has the benefit of the LED rear lights, 6 speed manual and MV2 alloys. You would get significant change if you bought the best possible example so perhaps an option.

The E9X are good cars but, dare I say, too clinical?




pointedstarman

Original Poster:

554 posts

177 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
I actually started out with a face lifted E46 in mind but that slowly morphed into the 1 series because they're newer and (I told myself though I may be wrong) more reliable. Considered a 125i but the 130i seems to be a serious bit of kit and is more of a "treat". As far as the age of the 130i is concerned I'm not really fussed as the face lift was fairly subtle though the newer / lower mileage/ best condition the better.

3 and 6 series have also been considered and not completely discarded but 130i is favourite.

Another consideration is a car that qualifies for a BMW insured warranty is a bonus (circa £800 comprehensive).

junglie

2,052 posts

248 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
Nothing you have said is in any way wtong.

I am always a fan of the biggest engine in the range but I do prefer the shape of the 1 series saloon but that means either a 125i or 135i for straight 6 thrills. The 125i is a nice engine and grunty enough at 215 bhp. The 135i is immense, more so if breathed on (DMS ir similar) but mist likely outside your budget. Twin turbo has its problems so a warranty could save you.

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
pointedstarman said:
I've decided to scratch an itch for a straight 6 petrol as a treat for my 50th. We have an F10 for family work so this will be a second car. Requirements are;
- £9k max price.
- 3 litre petrol preferred (would like a V8 but reliability worries me).
- 4 seats but rears for kids only.
- likely to be manual.
- reliability as must.

Top of my list is the 130i. There are a few LImited Editions around that really appeal. May consider a 330i coupe if price / condition / spec are right but concerned it'd be too similar day to day to the F10 (a 525d 3.0 six pot).

Anyone got any thoughts / advice / experience before I pull the trigger (probably next week whilst I'm not at work).
I've had a F10 loaner and it felt very different to my E92 335i, so don't see similarity being a reason to rule out, in your case, the E92 330i coupes.

BUT that said the difference is going to be even greater with a nippy, smaller, hatchback, so I think 130i is a good shout.

A quick nosey on A/T shows they can be got for less than 9k and with this ones' mileage (as the higher price threshold is 60k) you should meet your warranty price aim.

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...




helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
The 130 is a good bet and won't suffer from the rust and cracked floor issues of the 330. E46s are great but are of an age where they often need regular tlc.

Collectingbrass

3,020 posts

226 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
If it's to be a second car have you thought about a convertible? There are plenty around, they will be cheaper now than in 4 /5 months time and BMWs come with the four seats you need.

pointedstarman

Original Poster:

554 posts

177 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
Collectingbrass said:
If it's to be a second car have you thought about a convertible? There are plenty around, they will be cheaper now than in 4 /5 months time and BMWs come with the four seats you need.
Funnily enough I have looked at 125i convertible but have wondered if sacrificing performance is worth it for a few days with the roof down.

Sohlman

590 posts

285 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
What about something a lot older and cooler.

How about a 635csi. £9k is the upper end of their current prices and they are starting to go up.

Get a rust free one and they are reliable as very simple. Manuals are very rare. Also something like an 840csi which again is cool. Gives you a v8. Again very rare in manual form

dhutch

17,964 posts

228 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
I have just moved from a 4pot e36 to a e46 330ci sport and loving it, its less raw which is both a shame and the reason for the move, but its also not a 4yo 135 (freinds brother in law has one) so it does depend what you want.

Mines a Jan01 x-reg in Imola red with 120k on the clock, fairly high spec and in fact acquired clubsport badges and facelift rear clusters to go with the black electric leather, carbon cube, 3:4 satnav with '08 disk. Normal mild rust on the front arches and a touch at the back of the rears.
Gave £2650 for it, added £200 for a garage to diagnose and replace a failed alternator two weeks in, and will need a clutch and maybe dmf in early Jan but such is life! Drives very well, 32mpg on a motorway, 20mpg if thrapsed and bang in the middle on mixed miles.

So, depends what you want.

Daniel

dhutch

17,964 posts

228 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
I believe while serious money if found and well report, the e46 rear cracking issue is very rare and mainly only the very early cars and m3's.

For what it's worth, this is my car:
dhutch said:















LanceRS

2,235 posts

168 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
I spent nearly nine years in an e36 328 and I'm now six months into e46 330 ownership. I liked the 2.8 but the 3 litre is something else. It doesn't feel really any quicker but my god is it smooth and revs cleanly. I have on occasion stepped straight from behind the wheel of a V12 Jag and the engine still feels smooth.

speedster986

269 posts

237 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
E63 630Ci. £9000 would get a nice one.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Friday 25th December 2015
quotequote all
E46 M3.

An amazing car that is no longer really depreciating either.

pointedstarman

Original Poster:

554 posts

177 months

Saturday 26th December 2015
quotequote all
Have looked at the 6 series many times and really like them but am looking for something more chuckable if you know what I mean? It's a big car & based on the 5 so would be nearer the 5 than a 1?

M3 really is tempting but keeping it in the manner they deserve may prove ruinous?

Catatafish

1,532 posts

176 months

Saturday 26th December 2015
quotequote all
I have a 130i for the daily and love it although the rear end behaves a bit weird on certain surfaces.

I think the 125i and 128i can be remapped to the same output as the N52, so you could perhaps have the slightly better looking/newer 3 door hatch. Supposedly, the hydraulic power steering of pre face lift is better for feel though...

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Saturday 26th December 2015
quotequote all
pointedstarman said:
Have looked at the 6 series many times and really like them but am looking for something more chuckable if you know what I mean? It's a big car & based on the 5 so would be nearer the 5 than a 1?

M3 really is tempting but keeping it in the manner they deserve may prove ruinous?
Not at all.

They are all going to be 10-16 years old now, so independent servicing is all that is needed, so won't cost much more than a 330ci.
Brake discs and pads are all reasonable, and the biggest killer now is depreciation, and a £9k M3 will loose far less over the next few years than a £9k or even £6k 330ci.

The silly servicing costs for M3s was always the tappets, and if I am honest I never really got this, you can hear when they need to be adjusted so just adjust them at the time rather than taking it all apart and checking every other service. This was discussed at length on the old BM3W forum.

Plus you have a real occasion car, the 330ci, although nice, is just another 3 series, the M3 is on a whole other level.

dhutch

17,964 posts

228 months

Saturday 26th December 2015
quotequote all
Or just made multiple.

I have an e36 compact for autotesting and the like, the e46 330ci sport for everyday, and a 1900cvh Westfield for summer hooning.

You could buy the lot for 7grand.


Daniel

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Saturday 26th December 2015
quotequote all
E46 M3 seems a logical choice here. Special enough to be a second car.