Drainage - worth a moan to BMW?
Discussion
Hi all,
My 2004 645ci recently started giving me crackly audio at higher volumes and pitches and on one occasion as blasted the cabin with a deafening static. After a bit of reading, it seemed that the amplifier for the Logic 7 system was the likely culprit, so I duly took the car to my local BMW service centre to get it checked over.
They came back to me today to say that water ingress has caused it to short out and as such is not covered by the BMW Insured Warranty; they didn't bother adding it to another claim for a knackered vacuum pump they're sorting. I had a read over my comprehensive policy docs and whilst there is nothing that specifically excludes water damage, it does exclude worn weather strips and seals and 'channels and guides.' Seems fair enough, if it was a leaking boot seal then it'd be my own fault for not sorting something pretty darn obvious.
However, I'm certain it isn't the boot seal. I'm of the opinion it's a blocked sunroof drainage channel, a common design fault of BMWs of this vintage. In which instance, is it an improperly serviced channel rather than a worn one? On a car that has a full BMW main dealer service history, maintained at all the correct intervals, I don't believe that this is a user serviceable part and thus shouldn't be construed as negligent maintenance on my part.
Rather than piss £140 against the wall for my garage to do their investigation (see: rip out boot lining, suck teeth, write up on service sheet), my service adviser was kind enough to suggest flushing the drainage channels with an air line. Now, to my mind if they do that and it blows out a load of crud that was causing a blockage then it isn't a failed seal or drainage channel, but a manufacturing fault (let alone the fact that this is a well-documented problem on practically every BMW forum I've visited). Would this be grounds to take the issue further with BMW?
If it was just a case of a musty boot and no harm done then I wouldn't really be bothered about fixing it. What's irritating is that there is no clear damp or signs of water ingress in the boot beyond the result of BMW's infinite wisdom of installing a £1,000 amplifier and god-knows-how-expensive other electronics under a bloody drainage pipe. Needless to say, I'm not happy about being stung for a grand if it turns out that my suspicions are true!
Be interested to know if anybody's had any similar uphill battles with BMW over their warranty in the past and how they got on. If it's likely to be a case of going to Mordor over it I'll just capitulate and pick up a reconditioned amp off eBay for a few hundred sheets, grumble and replace it myself. Of course, if you thinking I'm overreacting don't hesitate to say so. Will probably save me the arse ache of trying to fight the man.
My 2004 645ci recently started giving me crackly audio at higher volumes and pitches and on one occasion as blasted the cabin with a deafening static. After a bit of reading, it seemed that the amplifier for the Logic 7 system was the likely culprit, so I duly took the car to my local BMW service centre to get it checked over.
They came back to me today to say that water ingress has caused it to short out and as such is not covered by the BMW Insured Warranty; they didn't bother adding it to another claim for a knackered vacuum pump they're sorting. I had a read over my comprehensive policy docs and whilst there is nothing that specifically excludes water damage, it does exclude worn weather strips and seals and 'channels and guides.' Seems fair enough, if it was a leaking boot seal then it'd be my own fault for not sorting something pretty darn obvious.
However, I'm certain it isn't the boot seal. I'm of the opinion it's a blocked sunroof drainage channel, a common design fault of BMWs of this vintage. In which instance, is it an improperly serviced channel rather than a worn one? On a car that has a full BMW main dealer service history, maintained at all the correct intervals, I don't believe that this is a user serviceable part and thus shouldn't be construed as negligent maintenance on my part.
Rather than piss £140 against the wall for my garage to do their investigation (see: rip out boot lining, suck teeth, write up on service sheet), my service adviser was kind enough to suggest flushing the drainage channels with an air line. Now, to my mind if they do that and it blows out a load of crud that was causing a blockage then it isn't a failed seal or drainage channel, but a manufacturing fault (let alone the fact that this is a well-documented problem on practically every BMW forum I've visited). Would this be grounds to take the issue further with BMW?
If it was just a case of a musty boot and no harm done then I wouldn't really be bothered about fixing it. What's irritating is that there is no clear damp or signs of water ingress in the boot beyond the result of BMW's infinite wisdom of installing a £1,000 amplifier and god-knows-how-expensive other electronics under a bloody drainage pipe. Needless to say, I'm not happy about being stung for a grand if it turns out that my suspicions are true!
Be interested to know if anybody's had any similar uphill battles with BMW over their warranty in the past and how they got on. If it's likely to be a case of going to Mordor over it I'll just capitulate and pick up a reconditioned amp off eBay for a few hundred sheets, grumble and replace it myself. Of course, if you thinking I'm overreacting don't hesitate to say so. Will probably save me the arse ache of trying to fight the man.

Can you assign responsibility for clearing the sunroof drains? Is it a service time line item or is it something that the manual says you have to do yourself?
I'm used to clearing leaves from the inner wing top drains myself on our Beemers but, like you, was annoyed beyond belief that they stuck a load of electronic items in the rear wheel well, forgot to put a spare wheel in there and then laughed all the way to the bank as I paid for new modules and relays ruined by their leaky seals.
I have since moved the PDC and air sus ECU's as well as the 3 relays to a dry place of safety. This exact same thing just happened to a Jag owning mate too. PUT ELECTRICS SOPMEWHERE SAFE YOU MUPPETS! >thanks for the rant and go get them<
I'm used to clearing leaves from the inner wing top drains myself on our Beemers but, like you, was annoyed beyond belief that they stuck a load of electronic items in the rear wheel well, forgot to put a spare wheel in there and then laughed all the way to the bank as I paid for new modules and relays ruined by their leaky seals.
I have since moved the PDC and air sus ECU's as well as the 3 relays to a dry place of safety. This exact same thing just happened to a Jag owning mate too. PUT ELECTRICS SOPMEWHERE SAFE YOU MUPPETS! >thanks for the rant and go get them<
Haha!
I can't see how they can expect owners to dismantle the arch liners in the boot and siphon through the channels and can find no mention of responsibility for doing so in any of my ownership docs. The cynic in me suggests BMW know it's a fault as it is a design they changed to address this in the LCI models of the E60/61 as well as the E63/64...
Regardless of the outcome, I reckon you're probably on to the smart move of relocating a load of the electrical systems. I've read of a few independents around town who come recommended for this work. Might be worth the investment as I've no intention of ditching the car.
I can't see how they can expect owners to dismantle the arch liners in the boot and siphon through the channels and can find no mention of responsibility for doing so in any of my ownership docs. The cynic in me suggests BMW know it's a fault as it is a design they changed to address this in the LCI models of the E60/61 as well as the E63/64...
Regardless of the outcome, I reckon you're probably on to the smart move of relocating a load of the electrical systems. I've read of a few independents around town who come recommended for this work. Might be worth the investment as I've no intention of ditching the car.
I was lucky as the drain holes from the scuttle on the o/s front were blocked and it happened last August whilst sat at the dealers for a month whilst I was away during very heavy rainfall - probably on a slight incline.
The service manager thought that it was due to the window being left open after washing, which transpired to have been pre-emptive and incorrect, so BMW took the carpets out, dried them in the workshop, cleaned the scuttles and re-fitted everything FOC. I got away with that one and admitted as much to them once the pictures were shown and they said that they can cover it with their profit and yes, I got lucky!
I wouldn't expect that to be covered by warranty unfortunately.
The service manager thought that it was due to the window being left open after washing, which transpired to have been pre-emptive and incorrect, so BMW took the carpets out, dried them in the workshop, cleaned the scuttles and re-fitted everything FOC. I got away with that one and admitted as much to them once the pictures were shown and they said that they can cover it with their profit and yes, I got lucky!
I wouldn't expect that to be covered by warranty unfortunately.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





