Discussion
Hi all,
Currently have a '08 3.6 Touareg which has cr@p air con. I live in Dubai so poor AC is a big issue in the summer. I'm considering changing it so thought I'd move up to an X5 4.8 or 4.2 Q7. This car will be our family tank and as so many other cars are huge SUV's it makes sense to be in an equally hefty car for safety reasons.
Is the E70 X5 considered a reliable car? How expensive is servicing etc. I will use a specialist rather than BMW. I quite fancy one but have heard they go wrong a lot. Fuel isn't an issue in terms of cost as its cheap here. I've had quite a fair few things go wrong with the Touareg but all in all its not been too bad to run. Propshaft bearing, bushes, tailgate struts, fuel pump are the things I've done as I took the car from 60k miles to 100k. Servicing and tyres/brakes have been pretty cheap.
Thanks,
Matt
Currently have a '08 3.6 Touareg which has cr@p air con. I live in Dubai so poor AC is a big issue in the summer. I'm considering changing it so thought I'd move up to an X5 4.8 or 4.2 Q7. This car will be our family tank and as so many other cars are huge SUV's it makes sense to be in an equally hefty car for safety reasons.
Is the E70 X5 considered a reliable car? How expensive is servicing etc. I will use a specialist rather than BMW. I quite fancy one but have heard they go wrong a lot. Fuel isn't an issue in terms of cost as its cheap here. I've had quite a fair few things go wrong with the Touareg but all in all its not been too bad to run. Propshaft bearing, bushes, tailgate struts, fuel pump are the things I've done as I took the car from 60k miles to 100k. Servicing and tyres/brakes have been pretty cheap.
Thanks,
Matt
The Q7 may be fine, but with it being a FSI there is always the chance for carbon build up. Whether warmer climates affect this, I do not know. The X5 could may well be more reliable than the Q7, but the 4.8i lump can have issues with oil leaks. Run away from X5's with white smoke, the oil seals are going!
Bear in mind that the Q7 has significantly more space than the X5, but the X5 has a great drive. The Q7 may be less reliable in general than the X5, the Q7 can suffer from lots of minor niggles at times but the X5 only suffers from certain things such as DTC issues or XDrive issues. The 3.0si lump in the X5 may be more reliable...
Bear in mind that the Q7 has significantly more space than the X5, but the X5 has a great drive. The Q7 may be less reliable in general than the X5, the Q7 can suffer from lots of minor niggles at times but the X5 only suffers from certain things such as DTC issues or XDrive issues. The 3.0si lump in the X5 may be more reliable...
somynameiswhat said:
The Q7 may be fine, but with it being a FSI there is always the chance for carbon build up. Whether warmer climates affect this, I do not know. The X5 could may well be more reliable than the Q7, but the 4.8i lump can have issues with oil leaks. Run away from X5's with white smoke, the oil seals are going!
Bear in mind that the Q7 has significantly more space than the X5, but the X5 has a great drive. The Q7 may be less reliable in general than the X5, the Q7 can suffer from lots of minor niggles at times but the X5 only suffers from certain things such as DTC issues or XDrive issues. The 3.0si lump in the X5 may be more reliable...
Thanks. Would have to be a V8 though when petrol is this cheap. I have a Touareg now which has had a few minor faults but I'm familiar with how to sort them so this makes the Q7 attractive due to my familiarity with some of its foibles. Will prob go Q7 for the extra seats if I avoid being sensible and buying a Korean SUV with 7 yrs warranty, 5yts servicing, 0% finance, no vat and 1yrs free insurance. Hard not to be tempted!Bear in mind that the Q7 has significantly more space than the X5, but the X5 has a great drive. The Q7 may be less reliable in general than the X5, the Q7 can suffer from lots of minor niggles at times but the X5 only suffers from certain things such as DTC issues or XDrive issues. The 3.0si lump in the X5 may be more reliable...
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


