320d Touring - Xdrive or not ?
320d Touring - Xdrive or not ?
Author
Discussion

justa1972

Original Poster:

342 posts

168 months

Tuesday 26th January 2016
quotequote all
Hello

Just after some advice please smile

My parents are looking at buying a 12 month old ish 320d M Sport Touring to replace their 5 year old Tiguan R Line 4motion.

They can't decide if its worth paying the extra to get an Xdrive - they are worried about snow as they live in the countryside.

My first thought was that having 19" wheels and summer tyres would make the xdrive pretty ineffective but I thought I'd check on here first !

So what do you think ?

thanks


cerb4.5lee

45,379 posts

211 months

Tuesday 26th January 2016
quotequote all
I wouldn't go x drive personally and whenever I took my old X5 off road it was pretty hopeless because as you suggest the big wheels and summer tyres don't do it any favours at all.

I would save on the extra weight and drag on the x drive 320d and throw some winter tyres on if required in the colder months and go for the RWD version instead.


Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Tuesday 26th January 2016
quotequote all
Get an ordinary 320d and buy winter tyres.

If car comes with 18s or 19s inch rims, then you could consider some 2nd hand 17s for the winter tyres; usually, as 17s tyres are cheaper, the cost of the winter rims is cancelled out.

RWD on winters, in a like for like car comparison, overall proves to be more effective than AWD on summer tyres.





MrBurt

162 posts

177 months

Tuesday 26th January 2016
quotequote all
Totally agree with the last two replies, winter tyres and forget X drive.
I currently have a 320d xdrive msport plus touring.
I could go on for a while about the pro's and con's of this car, but I will be brief.
Most disappointing aspect of this car is the engine. Yes it's punchy for a 2 litre and gives good economy but it's a noisy beast and kills the premium feel of the car. The X drive also removes any real feel of it being a rear driven vehicle, it comes over as a very secure neutral handling car but there ain't no fun to be had. The steering is also very light which adds to the remote feel. I have 19" wheels on mine as part of the plus pack and I think they do the car no favours on steering feel and are prone to tram lining on poor surfaces.
The 8 speed auto is excellent. Economy is approx 48 on a run and approx 44 on shorter journeys.. Without X drive
I reckon 10% extra would be achieved.
I have swapped the 19's for 18's with winter tyres and this has improved the steering feel and improves the grip in heavy rain and makes the car drive as normal in the snow, if your are sensible. Be mindful that if you pick up one with the plus pack the minimum wheel size you can have is 18 so that they clear the upgraded calipers. Brakes are excellent with the upgrade.
Sorry I said I would be brief. No X drive, make sure you do enough miles for a diesel and shop around there's loads out there. Petrol for me next time with rear drive. Roll on 2017. Good luck

justa1972

Original Poster:

342 posts

168 months

Tuesday 26th January 2016
quotequote all
Thanks folks

Mr burt - which petrol engine ? Guessing not the 320i ?

MrBurt

162 posts

177 months

Tuesday 26th January 2016
quotequote all
Would like a 340, but my man maths might not be able to justify it, so it may come down to a 330i.
There are just so few of them about and no decent reviews. I know it's a turbo 4, but on paper the stats look good. Will have to do some serious research nearer the time. Cannot understand for private buyers like me why these petrol motors are not more popular.
It feels like the manufacturer and the press are still diesel crazy when unless doing 15 k plus a year they make much less sense than a modern petrol. I have got my commute down considerably since purchasing the BM.
Eyes wide open next time but cannot see me putting up with the 320d for much longer than another year.
On a separate non BMW note. My previous was a Mazda 6 sport with the 185 diesel and it was such a sweet engine, just as powerful as the BM but so much more refined. Cannot understand why BMW 4 pot diesels are so vocal and harsh, given the volume they sell and the investment that must have been bestowed on them?
Hope I've been of some help and not just confused the issue for you.

scz4

2,858 posts

272 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
MrBurt said:
Would like a 340, but my man maths might not be able to justify it, so it may come down to a 330i.
Only £1200 difference after discount, both Auto and M Sport, is it really even worth debating? See http://www.coast2coastcars.co.uk

cerb4.5lee

45,379 posts

211 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
MrBurt said:
Would like a 340, but my man maths might not be able to justify it, so it may come down to a 330i.
There are just so few of them about and no decent reviews. I know it's a turbo 4, but on paper the stats look good. Will have to do some serious research nearer the time. Cannot understand for private buyers like me why these petrol motors are not more popular.
BMW car magazine did a bit of a review of the current 330i in Australia of all places because the 4pot 328i sold incredibly well over there and they expect the 330i to do the same and they basically said they would plump for the 330i over the 340i and they said the obsession we have with diesel in the UK is massive but buyers should really take the blinkers off and go petrol.

I agree entirely with you regards the 2.0d engine and I had it in a 520d and I just hated the noisy and annoying thing, I also have experience of a 640d(cover around 35k miles a year in it) and while I have no arguments with its performance/economy mix I still find it harsh and noisy and a petrol wins for me everyday of the week.

I still have a vintage 2006 330i to help remind me that diesel can never get close to a petrol for smoothness and delivering a nice noise, in the future I would seriously consider the current 330i because I think it seems a really good package.

Maracus

4,553 posts

199 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
I've got a 2013 F31 328i auto.

I've currently got a set of 17" wheels on with winter tyres, it normally has the 403M 19" wheels. These are susceptible to pitting around the centre bore, possibly caused by salt...who knows, so I use the winter set that are from an E90 and are a bit kerbed/scraped anyway.

As for economy, I see low 40s on my 50 mile commute into work sat at 70. On the way home it's probably around 33/34, but I'm in more of a hurry driving


MrBurt

162 posts

177 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
scz4 said:
Only £1200 difference after discount, both Auto and M Sport, is it really even worth debating? See http://www.coast2coastcars.co.uk
Well that's a user friendly site that may speed up my decision making. Over 10k off a well specced 340! Need to shop around come the time, I guess BMW would be discounting to a degree if a third party offering their products can do the same on a bespoke build. The difference between 340 & 330 is indeed to small to make the 330 viable.

scz4

2,858 posts

272 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
MrBurt said:
scz4 said:
Only £1200 difference after discount, both Auto and M Sport, is it really even worth debating? See http://www.coast2coastcars.co.uk
Well that's a user friendly site that may speed up my decision making. Over 10k off a well specced 340! Need to shop around come the time, I guess BMW would be discounting to a degree if a third party offering their products can do the same on a bespoke build. The difference between 340 & 330 is indeed to small to make the 330 viable.
Good website isn't it.

I initially made contact with Coast2Coast on a 340i, they then put you in touch with a BMW dealership and dealt with them directly (Sytner). Couldn't reach an agreement on my trade-in value, not surprising I guess given the discounts on offer.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Friday 29th January 2016
quotequote all
I live in the countryside amongst single track lanes that aren't cleared or treated and have a standard two wheel drive 320d. I use winter tyres and it's no real issue. My parents are the same. I do 35k miles a year and my Dad about 25-30k. I'd avoid really steep hills at low speeds, but that's probably good advice for any car in the snow!

Don't forget that 4WD is only to get you going and you're in the same boat as 2WD when it comes to cornering and stopping (ok, not quite the same, but jolly similar). The worst bit is that 4WD is unnecessary for the whole rest of the year (especially with a 320d) and you have to live with extra weight, lower mpg and drivetrain power losses that whole time.

The only downside is having to change your wheels and tyres, but to be honest they really are a very noticeable difference in grip in any cold and/or wet winters day.

I would certainly go 4WD if I lived in a mountainous region with very steep hills and more than a month of thick snow, but for the majority of the UK, a 2WD 3 series with winter tyres will be fine.

Proper off roaders (Toureg, Range Rover, Land Cruiser etc) do of course have other USPs such as proper rough ground off road ability, very high towing limits etc, but there's a school of thought that 4WD in an ordinary saloon car is as much about marketing as it is grip.

Edit since the post below this one: Whilst RWD is ok on snow with winter tyres, RWD is a worry on slippery mud. In the AWD car that I owned once I could happily drive into fields or onto wet grass and be confident that I'd get out again. I wouldn't perform the same feats with RWD.

I also didn't realise that XDrive was only available with SE suspension. I did a back to back last year and M Sport seems to be where standard suspension was with the E90 generation of BMWs, with SE giving a much more understeerey and inferior ride and handling balance.

Edited by RobM77 on Friday 29th January 14:10

JNW1

9,571 posts

225 months

Friday 29th January 2016
quotequote all
My F31 335d is my first AWD car and I didn't have a choice on the drivetrain as the 335d is obviously X-Drive only in the UK. Part of the attraction was if we were out with the dogs we'd be less likely to get stuck on a wet or muddy field but even in normal road use the traction is nice to have when pulling out of side roads in greasy conditions. However, the fact you only get SE suspension on the X-Drives (even in M-Sport trim) is a negative IMO and even though my car has the optional adaptive suspension there are times when even in the sport setting it feels like it could do with being a bit better tied-down. From what I've read I daresay a set of AC Schnitzer springs would help but given the relatively high initial purchase price it shouldn't be necessary to spend more on after market modifications to sort-out the suspension in my view. The flip side is the SE suspension does offer a more compliant ride so I suppose much depends on how you drive; if you generally take it steady away you may be fine with X-Drive and if you live somewhere remote I can see it being useful to have in bad weather (albeit if you're worried about frequent snow falls I think winter tyres make more of a difference than AWD).

Overall, however, given the experience with my F31 I'd say if you've got the choice go with RWD and fit winters if you're worried about bad weather. There are certainly times when the AWD is nice to have but I've always found RWD to be absolutely fine most of the time and therefore the permanent downsides associated with X-Drive (extra weight, compromised suspension, inferior fuel consumption, etc) aren't worth it IMHO.

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Friday 29th January 2016
quotequote all
winter tyres.

JNW1

9,571 posts

225 months

Friday 29th January 2016
quotequote all
RobM77 said:
Whilst RWD is ok on snow with winter tyres, RWD is a worry on slippery mud. In the AWD car that I owned once I could happily drive into fields or onto wet grass and be confident that I'd get out again. I wouldn't perform the same feats with RWD.

Edited by RobM77 on Friday 29th January 14:10
Don't disagree, think the choice you make all comes down to where you drive and how often you're likely to encounter really slippery conditions. For some people I can see that AWD is borderline essential but I suspect those same people may also value things like the higher ride height and greater ground clearance that comes with a genuine 4x4 (like an X5 or a Range Rover) and hence for them AWD on a "normal" car may still not quite do the job? However, for most people in the UK I'd say RWD is fine.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Friday 29th January 2016
quotequote all
JNW1 said:
RobM77 said:
Whilst RWD is ok on snow with winter tyres, RWD is a worry on slippery mud. In the AWD car that I owned once I could happily drive into fields or onto wet grass and be confident that I'd get out again. I wouldn't perform the same feats with RWD.

Edited by RobM77 on Friday 29th January 14:10
Don't disagree, think the choice you make all comes down to where you drive and how often you're likely to encounter really slippery conditions. For some people I can see that AWD is borderline essential but I suspect those same people may also value things like the higher ride height and greater ground clearance that comes with a genuine 4x4 (like an X5 or a Range Rover) and hence for them AWD on a "normal" car may still not quite do the job? However, for most people in the UK I'd say RWD is fine.
yes As I think I hinted at in my post above, the majority of people who need proper off road will just buy one of the myriad of road friendly off roaders currently available. I've lived in the countryside for most of my life (as in proper countryside without drainage, road clearing, gritting etc) and found that winter tyres are just fine in snow and to be honest before I knew about winter tyres I used to just tiptoe around and got on just fine - I've not been stuck in over 20 years of driving. With my AWD car that I owned for a year I did drive into the odd field etc, but I don't really miss that ability now and I much prefer the handling of the RWD cars I've had since.

Mr Tidy

31,949 posts

158 months

Saturday 30th January 2016
quotequote all
I would agree with what has been posted above!

I had a 123d for over 6 years and when it struggled to find grip to get moving I was glad in a way because I knew it would also struggle to stop!

When we did have some serious snow in my part of the UK (Berkshire) in 2008/9 I think, most of the cars I saw ditched off the road were upmarket 4x4s on big rims with summer tyres but my 1 Series on summers got me to where I was going!

Last year I bought a set of Michelin Alpins for my 325ti but we have had no snow yet, although they do seem good when it is cold/wet!

But Michelin now do a cross-climate tyre which is supposedly good in all weathers, so I would be tempted to go for 2WD with those, or 2WD with a set of winters for most conditions. But if you live in the wilds of Scotland or similar Xdrive with cross-climate or a set of winters might be the best option.

Xdrive with ordinary (as in summer) tyres is probably a waste of time! (As in a marketing success)!

ryallm

114 posts

259 months

Saturday 30th January 2016
quotequote all
I feel well qualified to comment on this as I had an extended test drive at a BMW dealer last summer in an F31 320d Msport x drive back to back with an F31 Msport s drive (I bought the latter), and I have literally just got back from drive in snow in my car on Goodyear Ultragrip winter types - plenty of snow in the Scottish Borders today. The car felt invincible - great traction on steep hills and amazing braking on snow. Reasons for buying the 2 wheel drive car:

1) It handles better - the x drive, even the msport variant, has a higher ride height and softer suspension. If you are a keen driver this is very noticeable, and the BMW forums are awash with people who have fitted ACS or Eibach springs to x dive cars to try and fix this

2) Fuel economy - in real world driving at least a 4 to 5 mpg hit for the 4wd car - worse than the official figures suggest.

3) Snow - anyone who thinks they are safer in a 4wd car on summer tyres in snow than a 2wd car on winters is simply not acquainted with the facts. 4wd drive gives more traction, but it makes didly squat difference to braking or cornering on ice and snow. You are far, far safer in a 2wd car on winter tyres.

The 320 d xdrive is still a good car, and it you lived in the alps a 4wd car on winters would be the ultimate poor weather choice, but for the vast majority of British buyers the 2wd car with set of winters is the better, and more cost effective option.

Edited by ryallm on Saturday 30th January 09:56

JNW1

9,571 posts

225 months

Saturday 30th January 2016
quotequote all
ryallm said:
I feel well qualified to comment on this as I had an extended test drive at a BMW dealer last summer in an F31 320d Msport x drive back to back with an F31 Msport s drive (I bought the latter), and I have literally just got back from drive in snow in my car on Goodyear Ultragrip winter types - plenty of snow in the Scottish Borders today. The car felt invincible - great traction on steep hills and amazing braking on snow. Reasons for buying the 2 wheel drive car:

1) It handles better - the x drive, even the msport variant, has a higher ride height and softer suspension. If you are a keen driver this is very noticeable, and the BMW forums are awash with people who have fitted ACS or Eibach springs to x dive cars to try and fix this

2) Fuel economy - in real world driving at least a 4 to 5 mpg hit for the 4wd car - worse than the official figures suggest.

3) Snow - anyone who thinks they are safer in a 4wd car on summer tyres in snow than a 2wd car on winters is simply not acquainted with the facts. 4wd drive gives more traction, but it makes didly squat difference to braking or cornering on ice and snow. You are far, far safer in a 2wd car on winter tyres.

The 320 d xdrive is still a good car, and it you lived in the alps a 4wd car on winters would be the ultimate poor weather choice, but for the vast majority of British buyers the 2wd car with set of winters is the better, and more cost effective option.

Edited by ryallm on Saturday 30th January 09:56
Agree with pretty much all of this and if the 335d was available as RWD I'd buy that in preference to an X-Drive (well actually I wouldn't, I'd buy a 340i but that's another topic entirely!).