E46 318i N42 engine noise
E46 318i N42 engine noise
Author
Discussion

LewG

Original Poster:

1,402 posts

177 months

Monday 15th February 2016
quotequote all
Hello guys, looking for a bit of advice on my brother's E46. It's done around 120k and sounds like it's being fueled with gravel. I took the cam cover off expecting engine carnage, but to my surprise everything looks fine. The timing chain does have normal wear but to be honest everything looked clean, not sludgey etc. so I can't see why it would make such a noise. Usually it doesn't make the noise on first start up, but comes in after a minute or two of running. The noise only seems to present itself below 2500-3000rpm, and is particularly bad at idle. Does this sound like a Valvetronic problem? Attached a YouTube link to demonstrate it, as you can see it's pretty terrible.
https://youtu.be/c6xFmeH7M9M

Any advice would be much appreciated.

Elliot2000

786 posts

207 months

Tuesday 16th February 2016
quotequote all
Not sure about the noise from the video, but u can rule out the valve tronic easily enough by disconnecting the round plug connector on top of the rocker cover, it will then use the throttle body instead of the valve tronic and run like a standard engine.

Doing that also cuts out vanos, just so u know. Does no harm to engine but will stick an engine light on

LewG

Original Poster:

1,402 posts

177 months

Sunday 21st February 2016
quotequote all
Cheers Elliot I'll have a play with it this week, I'm pretty sure when I had the cover off I tried running it with that plug removed and it made no difference. It's frustrating because my brother's looking at flogging it soon and obviously nobody's going to touch it with a barge pole with a death rattle like that.