M5 for pootling around in?
M5 for pootling around in?
Author
Discussion

Higgs boson

Original Poster:

1,105 posts

184 months

Friday 19th February 2016
quotequote all
Some input please guys ...

I have been driving BMs for the last 16, or so, years. e30 petrol, e36 325 TDS, and e39 525d. All manuals, I don't like autos.
I've covered close to 400k miles in them, the vast majority being in the two diesels. I can't see myself driving anything other than BMW.

I keep my cars for a long time. (That might be obvious from the previous paragraph biggrin ).
I also do 99% of the work on the cars, only farming it out when a special tool is required.

Now, I've taken early retirement, and have a hankering for a V8. I've had a drive in a friends e60 M5. It's a fantastic car, but I wouldn't have the balls to buy one for fear of a huge bill. Just in case a pedant, like me, is reading this, I know an e60 M5 isn't a V8.

I really like my e39. I'm fairly sure that I don't want a 535i or 540i. So, what do we think? I suspect my annual mileage will be around 9 to 10k. I don't drive quickly, and track days aren't my thing (I got rid of all that on motorcycles). Would you buy an e39 M5 to tootle about in?

I have up to £15k set aside, if required.

TIA

minimatan

17,967 posts

232 months

Friday 19th February 2016
quotequote all
£15k is a good budget to buy a private well maintained example with long ownership. You have to watch and wait and be ready to pounce however!

Kawasicki

14,428 posts

266 months

Friday 19th February 2016
quotequote all
I couldn't imagine pootling in an m5. Sorry.

cocobongo

665 posts

155 months

Friday 19th February 2016
quotequote all
Have you considered a B10 V8/V8S? Great cars and not much difference in power from the M5 and a better mannered road car to pootle around in.

Higgs boson

Original Poster:

1,105 posts

184 months

Friday 19th February 2016
quotequote all
Thanks for the responses so far.

Wasn't the B10 auto only gearbox?

Patrick Bateman

13,223 posts

205 months

Saturday 20th February 2016
quotequote all
If you're really not going to drive it hard now and again I'd buy another car, otherwise you're paying a lot of M tax for what a 540i could do.

That and it's just not doing it justice.

The V8 B10's are auto only. What about a manual 545/550 or 645/650 if you're set on a BMW V8? If you're patient enough to find one that is.

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...


Edited by Patrick Bateman on Saturday 20th February 11:56

minimatan

17,967 posts

232 months

Saturday 20th February 2016
quotequote all
Higgs boson said:
Thanks for the responses so far.

Wasn't the B10 auto only gearbox?
An Alpina B10 is a good shout and £10k would get you a cherised example

http://www.millenniumheroes.com/cars/alpina-b10-v8...


4rephill

5,172 posts

209 months

Saturday 20th February 2016
quotequote all
Don't take this the wrong way but buying an E39 M5 to just "pootle" around in and never drive quickly is just a waste of a good car TBH.

For that type of driving you'd be better off with a E39 540i (if you really want a V8), or a 530i (you could also look for a 535i but it is a bit of a strange car in that it's no quicker than a 530i [but slightly more expensive to run], and it's no more economical than a 540i).

For 15K you'll find a nice, good condition E39 M5, but for a lot less money you'll find a pristine 530i,535i, 540i, and just "pootling around", you're not going to notice any difference between them.

Pickled Piper

6,452 posts

266 months

Saturday 20th February 2016
quotequote all
Definitely do it. You are handy with the spanners and have the time to work on it. This will cut your ownership costs significantly.


mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Saturday 20th February 2016
quotequote all
You will NOT just Poole around, trust me 😈😈

Higgs boson

Original Poster:

1,105 posts

184 months

Saturday 20th February 2016
quotequote all
Ah! Good. Conflicting views.

When I say pootling, obviously I don't mean 100% of the time. Maybe 95% thumbup
I think anyone made of flesh and blood, would, as has been suggested above, have great difficulty in not succumbing to that temptation.

I mentioned that the 535/540 were, probably, out of the equation. I stated that it had to be a manual, which means the B10 can't feature. I'm not too sure about the looks of the 6 series, although there is the (very) odd manual about.

All this has a funnelling effect! Me -----> e39 M5.

I can sense an inevitability about this!

Patrick Bateman

13,223 posts

205 months

Saturday 20th February 2016
quotequote all
Well I can only encourage it now but you have to give the thing a proper thrash now and again otherwise it just isn't cricket.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dqikbKcS6_4

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-KZLPAEHOaY

minimatan

17,967 posts

232 months

Saturday 20th February 2016
quotequote all
Higgs boson said:
Ah! Good. Conflicting views.

When I say pootling, obviously I don't mean 100% of the time. Maybe 95% thumbup
I think anyone made of flesh and blood, would, as has been suggested above, have great difficulty in not succumbing to that temptation.

I mentioned that the 535/540 were, probably, out of the equation. I stated that it had to be a manual, which means the B10 can't feature. I'm not too sure about the looks of the 6 series, although there is the (very) odd manual about.

All this has a funnelling effect! Me -----> e39 M5.

I can sense an inevitability about this!
If at all relevant, my long and focused search for an E39 M5, led me to a manual 645Ci entirely without planning!

Higgs boson

Original Poster:

1,105 posts

184 months

Saturday 20th February 2016
quotequote all
Are (were) you too fussy?
Dearth of decent ones at time of search?
Had to wait too long, and just gave up the search?
Decided the 6 series was a "better" car for you?

danj3000

37 posts

205 months

Saturday 20th February 2016
quotequote all
Definitely worth getting the E39 M5. Yes you may be paying a little more for having an M car but then it's never going to depreciate much if at all from now on.

minimatan

17,967 posts

232 months

Sunday 21st February 2016
quotequote all
Higgs boson said:
Are (were) you too fussy?
Dearth of decent ones at time of search?
Had to wait too long, and just gave up the search?
Decided the 6 series was a "better" car for you?
Fussy - only in so far as I couldn't find an example under / around £15k that was honest. Every example was priced at what it should have been in tip top condition. So many examples where the owners wore rose tinted glasses and I didn't want to own a puppy. The best examples are the immaculate and warranties ones from Hexagon.

Dearth - All including the decent ones were over priced. In reality, my 10k odd mileage per annum would have pushed them closer to the mileage where the value drops off. Additionally, the more you study them, the issues stand out like a sore thumb. I'd spend at least an hour going over the body of each one before even starting the engine and driving it. There are so many chancers out there, whose vehicles are not as described.

Wait- I knew a good deal when I saw one and a modern, clean, low mileage, manual, large capacity V8 coupe for around half the price of the a similar mileage M5 made too much sense, even if it wouldn't be a full 'M' experience. Additionally in the case of the M5, the previous owners would have enjoyed the full M experience too, as the comments on here testify, so there would always be a costs to keeping it in tip top condition, as I insist my vehicles are. The sellers rarely would acknowledge these costs in their asking price.

Better - The 6 series was a good enough car and I feel has been a better decision. It just made sense when I saw it - it chose me as much as I chose it. Sometimes serendipity strikes. It also looks better for me in a professional capacity and has aged elegantly.