Which Car: E61 530D vs F11 520D
Discussion
Long time lurker/non-visitor to PH here. I am looking to change cars soon and thought I would seek the PH guru's thoughs.
I have decided I want to go for a 5 series estate. I have a 100 mile round trip commute approx 3-4 days a week along the M25, so an auto is a must. Ideally I want a few toys such as adaptive cruise control, xenon headlights, bluetooth and USB. Pro nav and memory seats would be nice. My budget is around 10k but I would stretch to 13k at a push.
I'm bored of 4-pot diesels, so an LCI E61 530D was top of my list. I'd probably pay extra to fuel an E61 530i, but there aren't many out there. The LCI E61 530D's with a good spec seem to be fetching decent money still, so I got looking at F11's which is where my dilema sets in.
F11 530D's are out of budget without very high mileages. F11 520D's are just in budget, but often with a few of the optional extras missing. So, I am unsure whether to be sensible and get the more modern F11 520D which from what I hear is smoother over the bumps or an older more characterful 6-pot diesel E61.
I know they are a bit of a marmite car, but I prefer the E61 looks to the F11. The F11 looks a bit boring/safe whereas the E61 has a bit more presence. I do a bit of spannering myself, so I imagine the E61 would be more spanner friendly than the F11.
I have seen a nice E61 that ticked all the boxes. I couldn't test drive due to the wheels being refurbished. I am hoping to test drive in the next few days. I have not driven an E61 and my primary concern is that I don't find ride quality too firm as it is on run flats.
One last option is the early 6-pot F11 525D's (before the 525D was a 4 cyclinder). I have seen a couple in budget but they seem pretty rare. So, the options are high-spec E61 530D / 4-pot F11 520D / 6-pot F11 525D.
I have decided I want to go for a 5 series estate. I have a 100 mile round trip commute approx 3-4 days a week along the M25, so an auto is a must. Ideally I want a few toys such as adaptive cruise control, xenon headlights, bluetooth and USB. Pro nav and memory seats would be nice. My budget is around 10k but I would stretch to 13k at a push.
I'm bored of 4-pot diesels, so an LCI E61 530D was top of my list. I'd probably pay extra to fuel an E61 530i, but there aren't many out there. The LCI E61 530D's with a good spec seem to be fetching decent money still, so I got looking at F11's which is where my dilema sets in.
F11 530D's are out of budget without very high mileages. F11 520D's are just in budget, but often with a few of the optional extras missing. So, I am unsure whether to be sensible and get the more modern F11 520D which from what I hear is smoother over the bumps or an older more characterful 6-pot diesel E61.
I know they are a bit of a marmite car, but I prefer the E61 looks to the F11. The F11 looks a bit boring/safe whereas the E61 has a bit more presence. I do a bit of spannering myself, so I imagine the E61 would be more spanner friendly than the F11.
I have seen a nice E61 that ticked all the boxes. I couldn't test drive due to the wheels being refurbished. I am hoping to test drive in the next few days. I have not driven an E61 and my primary concern is that I don't find ride quality too firm as it is on run flats.
One last option is the early 6-pot F11 525D's (before the 525D was a 4 cyclinder). I have seen a couple in budget but they seem pretty rare. So, the options are high-spec E61 530D / 4-pot F11 520D / 6-pot F11 525D.
At that budget I'd rather have a nice e60/1 530d with trimmings than a boggo F10/1 520d personally, the e6* is a sporty drive in the BMW tradition the standard F10/1 isn't, the F11 530d with adaptive drive would be nice though but I would imagine they are still lots of money if you can find one.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


