E30 M3 or leggy CSL or Approved Used 1M
E30 M3 or leggy CSL or Approved Used 1M
Author
Discussion

jmcc500

Original Poster:

680 posts

249 months

Monday 22nd February 2016
quotequote all
Hello all,

I am thinking about rationalising the fleet and started to look at 1Ms as a sensible place to put all my eggs. However, for the price of a 1M I could get a leggy (90k miles) E46 CSL, a good condition E30 M3 or (for a chunk less money) a low mileage E46 CS.

Having nearly gone the E30 route about 12 years ago when you could pick one up for about £10k, I am not sure I now want to spend 3-4 times as much now, but it is an unscratched itch. However, having bought a one of my hero cars previously (968CS) and not got on with it, I wonder if I would be better of leaving it alone.

I have had an E46 3 series (only a 330ci), and am not sure about the CSL gearbox (I like autos but feel they suit more 'bargey' cars than the E46). Not sure I really get the CSL thing, but then I haven't driven one. Are they as good as the (slightly crazy) prices would suggest? Is the CS a significantly poorer cousin?

I love the look of the 1M and there is something attractive about still (just about) being able to get an approved used one with a warranty. Not sure where values will go long term, but assume it would be a step up in real world performance from my Cayman and probably has less chance of landing me a big bill.

If I pull the trigger, the car would replace both my 987 Cayman S and my old VW camper (saving me storage fees on that), and would be expected to live outside. It would be regularly exercised though I would probably try to keep down to 5k miles per year or so. Would be nice to have minimal depreciation. Anyone got any thoughts on this? Or should I be looking elsewhere (Z4M coupe? 997 Porsche?)

Thanks,

James

mark.c

1,090 posts

211 months

Monday 22nd February 2016
quotequote all
Only you can really decide what will tick the box for you....if you can ,the only sensible thing would be to try and grab a drive in each one before you plunge in.... I have an E30 M3 and absolutely love it to bits, I hope to never have to sell it, however I am realistic that it isn't for everyone ( not exactly fast, can rust for fun, dogleg box and of course LHD) for me these things ( except the rust bit) allure me even more to the car.

My CSL in my opinion is a huge achievement, it's just very good at what it is capable of doing. I love it too and used it as my daily for half of the time I've owned it. I really hope to never have to sell it but if push came to shove the CSL would go before the E30. This is all just my view of course.

Some points tho, the CSL has some very delicate carbon fibre bits that are ruinously expensive and in some cases NLA, the roof panel for example. Something to consider if it must be kept outside.
The same can be said for an E30, whilst they can be protected with modern products etc, keeping them outside is doable, but do you really want to ?

I can't comment on the 1M as I've never driven one but it's probably the more modern and least fragile of the three for what you have in mind for it......the only other thing I would say is, if you can don't focus on current or future values, just buy what you want to drive...if it makes a few quid then great, if not then you have a car you love.

Gruber

6,313 posts

245 months

Monday 22nd February 2016
quotequote all
I've just sold my 1M. Great little bruiser of a car. Agile and quick, but lacked something of the character of the normally aspirated M cars with their bespoke power plants. I owned it for a year and, aside from fuel, it barely cost me a penny in net terms.

I've just put down a deposit on an e46 CS. I had one back in 2008 and I've often said it was the best allrounder I've owned. I'm properly excited about getting another. Interlagos blue with SMG.

For me a CSL is just a bit too focussed right now. I want something Mrs G, Baby G and I can go on holiday in - I don't think they'd thank me if I tried to bundle them into a CSL. If I were young, free and single, I think I'd choose a CSL in a shot... but beware that they need proper care, so if you're buying a leggy one then make sure it has been very thoroughly checked out.

My perfect 10 car garage would probably include an e30 M3, but the prices just seem a bit nuts to me for what you get in objective terms. They are legendary, but I'm not sure they're THAT legendary.

jmcc500

Original Poster:

680 posts

249 months

Monday 22nd February 2016
quotequote all
Thanks chaps - good to hear some real experiences. I get the point about buying the car you want and to hell with residuals, but I think all of these options have the potential to at the very least minimise losses and I am afraid I have to factor it in.

I think the fact that I can't pamper the car probably rules out the E30 and (surprisingly for me) the CSL. Will give some thought to the CS and 1M, and see if I can get a test drive in them.

Cheers,

James

david hockney

1,404 posts

184 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
Definitely go for a test drive in a 1M-
Mine has been a revelation to me and is
without doubt the most fun car I've ever driven.

Kawasicki

14,428 posts

266 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
What was it about the 968cs that you didn't enjoy?

As drivers cars I think the boxster and cayman are great value.

jmcc500

Original Poster:

680 posts

249 months

Monday 29th February 2016
quotequote all
Kawasicki said:
What was it about the 968cs that you didn't enjoy?

As drivers cars I think the boxster and cayman are great value.
I think I found the performance of the 968CS underwhelming and didn't find the rest of the experience made up for it. I think I expected too much somehow, one of those things! I much prefer my Cayman S - fast enough and so good at everything else.

Will look at 1Ms in earnest I think. The other option would be to stay with Porsche and go 911, but that feels a little defeatist!

Thanks for the all the advice.