BMW dealer being deliberately dishonest?
BMW dealer being deliberately dishonest?
Author
Discussion

MrOrange

Original Poster:

2,039 posts

284 months

Tuesday 23rd February 2016
quotequote all
I'm struggling to get my head around how a BMW dealer has dealt with my new car purchase. I really can't believe they they could be so incompetent and, after a few vinos, I'm wandering if this is the kind of sharp practice I need to expect.

Short version of story:

Interested in a new BMW, arrange a test drive and all is good. I'm going to purchase it through my company and ask for a quote. Said PCP quote is acceptable and I sign the order - it includes an advantageous APR plus some BMW UK support with the deposit. All good. So I think.

Car is a factory build so off I go into the waiting period, regular updates and my advised pickup date falls at the start of March and all is good. It's a week before my factory built-to-my-spec car is due to be picked up and the final finance paperwork comes through "if you could sign in before the day it will speed up collection".

Except, the monthly figures seems to be different. I double check back on the original quote and the new payments are £100 a month more. WTF! It also seems the deposit support is also now missing so I'm been asked to stump up an additional £4K for the deposit. There has to be a mistake.

A couple of calls to said dealer and I initially get the brush off. Some vagueness and waffle. Then it's gets all gnarly. It seems the quote, and the order I signed was based "on a retail sale" - despite no mention of that on the quote or order and making clear it was a company purchase.

And as this is a company purchase the supported APR is not available, nor is the deposit support.

The salesperson has apologised for the confusion, but for the moment the situation is that I'm being asked to stump up an extra £7k over the 36 month period. That is nearly £200 extra per month and I'm feeling a little violated.

I am told that they are working hard to resolve the issue but I'm not confident that I'll get the car I ordered for the price I agreed. This cannot be normal, surely?

Olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Tuesday 23rd February 2016
quotequote all
Well someone hasn't spoken loudly enough. PCP is not available to business users. That's a given. So one of you has misunderstood the other.

Wombat3

15,126 posts

237 months

Tuesday 23rd February 2016
quotequote all
The clue is in the name - PCP - Personal Contract Plan. These (AFAIK) are not available to companies/business users.

There are similar things for businesses but don't think they are usually as generous.

If I had to guess I'd say you got a green salesman who simply didn't know what he was doing.

.....which isn't to say it should now be your problem.

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Tuesday 23rd February 2016
quotequote all
Hi

Sounds nasty. Steps appropriate to take:

1. Gather up all written correspondence to dealership
2. Write up timeline to also include your visits and telephone calls to dealership (if from mobile network provider can get these to you)
3. Recover bank statements that identify payment flow to dealer
4. If you did deposit on a credit card, invoke section 75 - this can also work on a debit card too
5. Verbal contract applies although this can end up in 50:50 split of monies challenged.
6. Ensure timeline is scrupulously written up from herein; e-mail trace far better than telephone conversations. if you visit dealership, download a recording app and ensure its on when you are discussing issue.





Wombat3

15,126 posts

237 months

Tuesday 23rd February 2016
quotequote all
If BMW won't provide the pricing support (or rather if its only available to individuals) then there probably isn't much that can be done unless the dealer wants to eat it & he'd probably rather cancel your order & just sell the car to someone else.

Is there any way you could do it on PCP yourself & then charge it back to your company? Might be worth having a word with your accountant because you may find that, in the end, that ends up being a more economic way of dealing with things if you can't match the BMW pricing support & PCP rates....

....and then you squeeze the dealer for some more via a discount on the OTR charges & some free servicing for getting him out of jail & letting him off the hook.smile

MrOrange

Original Poster:

2,039 posts

284 months

Tuesday 23rd February 2016
quotequote all
Wombat3 said:
The clue is in the name - PCP - Personal Contract Plan. These (AFAIK) are not available to companies/business users.

There are similar things for businesses but don't think they are usually as generous.

If I had to guess I'd say you got a green salesman who simply didn't know what he was doing.

.....which isn't to say it should now be your problem.
My bad. It doesn't say PCP. It says BMW Select, involves a deposit, some payments and an option to purchase with a biggish ballon (hence why I called it a PCP)

Thanks for other comments. I've got a solid trail of emails, I'd go with "green salesbod" but, as you say, no need for me to be out of pocket.

I guess I might have the option to cancel, deposit is only £1k so not the end of the world - just a bit fricking crap as I I've planned disposal of my current car separately so could end up carless.

Olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Wednesday 24th February 2016
quotequote all
Select is BMW's PCP scheme.

Wombat3

15,126 posts

237 months

Wednesday 24th February 2016
quotequote all
MrOrange said:
Wombat3 said:
The clue is in the name - PCP - Personal Contract Plan. These (AFAIK) are not available to companies/business users.

There are similar things for businesses but don't think they are usually as generous.

If I had to guess I'd say you got a green salesman who simply didn't know what he was doing.

.....which isn't to say it should now be your problem.
My bad. It doesn't say PCP. It says BMW Select, involves a deposit, some payments and an option to purchase with a biggish ballon (hence why I called it a PCP)

Thanks for other comments. I've got a solid trail of emails, I'd go with "green salesbod" but, as you say, no need for me to be out of pocket.

I guess I might have the option to cancel, deposit is only £1k so not the end of the world - just a bit fricking crap as I I've planned disposal of my current car separately so could end up carless.
As above, suggest speak to your accountant first - you could do not too badly out of this in the end....

MrOrange

Original Poster:

2,039 posts

284 months

Wednesday 24th February 2016
quotequote all
Wombat3 said:
As above, suggest speak to your accountant first - you could do not too badly out of this in the end....
Done already, it's a no-go. To make it work, car must be on company balance sheet (low emissions, tax write-off). BMW Select paperwork is definitely in the name of my company, not personal. Curiouser and curiouser.

It's with "the corporate finance dept" (whatever that means) and I'm due a call back. Thanks for listening, back to the vino now smile

Wombat3

15,126 posts

237 months

Wednesday 24th February 2016
quotequote all
MrOrange said:
Wombat3 said:
As above, suggest speak to your accountant first - you could do not too badly out of this in the end....
Done already, it's a no-go. To make it work, car must be on company balance sheet (low emissions, tax write-off). BMW Select paperwork is definitely in the name of my company, not personal. Curiouser and curiouser.

It's with "the corporate finance dept" (whatever that means) and I'm due a call back. Thanks for listening, back to the vino now smile
I guess the point is that in all likelihood you aren't going to get that car for the money you were expecting to pay on a business lease/finance plan. So is the premium you have to pay to buy it via the business (because there will be one) worth the additional cost in terms of the tax write off etc?

Basically you've ended up having your expectations set at entirely the wrong level & unless you are a very good customer I'd think its unlikely the dealer is going to want to eat much of the difference between where they have been set & where they should have been set!

Good luck.

Edited by Wombat3 on Wednesday 24th February 09:02

iluvkefalonia

25 posts

202 months

Wednesday 24th February 2016
quotequote all
I never realised that a private customer had a financial advantage over a business buyer, in fact I always assumed it was the other way around, I would have thought that a lot of business's had potential to buy more vehicles in the future and were therefore more attractive as a customer.

JMBMWM5

2,410 posts

229 months

Wednesday 24th February 2016
quotequote all
kurt535 said:
Hi

Sounds nasty. Steps appropriate to take:

1. Gather up all written correspondence to dealership
2. Write up timeline to also include your visits and telephone calls to dealership (if from mobile network provider can get these to you)
3. Recover bank statements that identify payment flow to dealer
4. If you did deposit on a credit card, invoke section 75 - this can also work on a debit card too
5. Verbal contract applies although this can end up in 50:50 split of monies challenged.
6. Ensure timeline is scrupulously written up from herein; e-mail trace far better than telephone conversations. if you visit dealership, download a recording app and ensure its on when you are discussing issue.
This advise is "Spot on" follow it.
BMW are artful for sure but will cave in under duress.

Marcellus

7,210 posts

250 months

Wednesday 24th February 2016
quotequote all
If your company name is on their "New Vehicle contract" surely the offer was made by the dealer to your company which you accepted on behalf of your company.

If so how can they vary the contract?

I'd be inclined to really push this one.



Olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Wednesday 24th February 2016
quotequote all
kurt535 said:
Hi

Sounds nasty. Steps appropriate to take:

1. Gather up all written correspondence to dealership
2. Write up timeline to also include your visits and telephone calls to dealership (if from mobile network provider can get these to you)
3. Recover bank statements that identify payment flow to dealer
4. If you did deposit on a credit card, invoke section 75 - this can also work on a debit card too
5. Verbal contract applies although this can end up in 50:50 split of monies challenged.
6. Ensure timeline is scrupulously written up from herein; e-mail trace far better than telephone conversations. if you visit dealership, download a recording app and ensure its on when you are discussing issue.
Good stuff. Does this advice work for a private individual and business or just or just the former?

MrOrange

Original Poster:

2,039 posts

284 months

Wednesday 24th February 2016
quotequote all
UPDATE: I got a surreal call today from the "contract hire" side of the business suggesting it might be cheaper to CH the car. The CH deposit is an awful lot less and the monthlies, too, are lower. But it's a crazy nuts 20+35 CH deal.

I was polite. I smell rat.

I didn't want to CH the car, I don't get the same tax benefits, it simply doesn't work for me.

Still waiting for the promised "call back". Car is due to be handed over next Tuesday.

dartissimus

954 posts

205 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
I'm just buying a special order 3 series touring, ordered before Christmas, delivery March 1st, the difference in trade in value on my Volvo after 2 months plus was £500 less than their December valuation. That's reasonable to me.

I'd been worried that they were going to try and clip me a couple of thousand, but the gentlest mention of walking and leaving them with £35 grands worth of unsold car on their books seemed to concentrate their minds wonderfully.

We're all best friends now.

The customer is king, and car finance is a thing of beauty and infinitely adjustable

Sir_Dave

1,506 posts

241 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
MrOrange said:
UPDATE: I got a surreal call today from the "contract hire" side of the business suggesting it might be cheaper to CH the car. The CH deposit is an awful lot less and the monthlies, too, are lower. But it's a crazy nuts 20+35 CH deal.

I was polite. I smell rat.

I didn't want to CH the car, I don't get the same tax benefits, it simply doesn't work for me.

Still waiting for the promised "call back". Car is due to be handed over next Tuesday.
Ignoring the original issue, i assume you want a HP with balloon in order to claim to plonk it on your balance sheet & claim the WDA's? If you're not that bothered about ownership at the end of the 3 year period, a lease/contract hire might not be a terrible way to go, as you can expense 100% of the rentals through your P&L instead?

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
MrOrange said:
UPDATE: I got a surreal call today from the "contract hire" side of the business suggesting it might be cheaper to CH the car. The CH deposit is an awful lot less and the monthlies, too, are lower. But it's a crazy nuts 20+35 CH deal.

I was polite. I smell rat.

I didn't want to CH the car, I don't get the same tax benefits, it simply doesn't work for me.

Still waiting for the promised "call back". Car is due to be handed over next Tuesday.
Do the maths very carefully, CH may be just as good but written off in a different way.

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
Olf said:
kurt535 said:
Hi

Sounds nasty. Steps appropriate to take:

1. Gather up all written correspondence to dealership
2. Write up timeline to also include your visits and telephone calls to dealership (if from mobile network provider can get these to you)
3. Recover bank statements that identify payment flow to dealer
4. If you did deposit on a credit card, invoke section 75 - this can also work on a debit card too
5. Verbal contract applies although this can end up in 50:50 split of monies challenged.
6. Ensure timeline is scrupulously written up from herein; e-mail trace far better than telephone conversations. if you visit dealership, download a recording app and ensure its on when you are discussing issue.

Yup it sure does!
Good stuff. Does this advice work for a private individual and business or just or just the former?

nickfrog

25,491 posts

248 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
How can a car be on the "balance sheet" if it is PCPed? I fail to understand the benefit of a car going through the business - not saying there isn't one but what is it ? It also means it will be a Company car : can't be good fiscally.
Secondly, I think it is important to totally separate the discount from the finance. Get the first one and then sort finance, either with the dealer or somewhere elae. BMW FS contribution is only a small part of the overall discount. Although it might be too late for that.