Anybody know where I can get a good ride!
Anybody know where I can get a good ride!
Author
Discussion

ROLFSSEN

Original Poster:

96 posts

171 months

Wednesday 24th February 2016
quotequote all
Hi,

I'm after a BMW that actually rides well.

I've had loads of them over the years, currently in an Alpina D3 - BUT I have never found one that has good ride.

The best I had was a 535D SE on 17" wheels, the worst is probably my current D3 (despite all the magazines saying they're comfortable).

The problem is that, as you may well agree;

a) the roads are in a very poor state.
b) sometimes the only place you can "extend" the car is on the B-roads which are often VERY bumpy.

I was in a new E-class the other day, and the potholes I'd driven around, my driver just drove over them.

But I don't want a bloody E-class!

Cue accusations of "wanting my cake and eating it" - but anybody got any BMW ideas - what rides well??

Ta,

Tim


Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
With RFTs - none of them.


anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
ROLFSSEN said:
Hi,

I'm after a BMW that actually rides well.

I've had loads of them over the years, currently in an Alpina D3 - BUT I have never found one that has good ride.

The best I had was a 535D SE on 17" wheels, the worst is probably my current D3 (despite all the magazines saying they're comfortable).

The problem is that, as you may well agree;

a) the roads are in a very poor state.
b) sometimes the only place you can "extend" the car is on the B-roads which are often VERY bumpy.

I was in a new E-class the other day, and the potholes I'd driven around, my driver just drove over them.

But I don't want a bloody E-class!

Cue accusations of "wanting my cake and eating it" - but anybody got any BMW ideas - what rides well??

Ta,

Tim
The 5 series with adaptive suspension is streets ahead of a CLS, which is based on the e class. I never got to try a CLS with air suspension but the 5 series was much better than the regular Merc ride. Can't speak for the E itself, having similar views to yourself.

For me the 5 with adaptive is an excellent compromise between ride and control, even with RFTs. And with 5 suspension/driving modes it covers most bases.

You're right about our roads though; I'm driving down to Geneva next week, looking forward to driving on decent, uncluttered roads for a change.





jayemm89

4,475 posts

161 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
My 645 was a reasonably nice place to spend time, I have yet to be in a BMW that had the "magic carpet effect" but I would imagine a 7 series would probably be the closest you're going to get?

You could always investigate aftermarket damper options, get a soft road setup?

S1MMA

2,451 posts

250 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
jayemm89 said:
My 645 was a reasonably nice place to spend time, I have yet to be in a BMW that had the "magic carpet effect" but I would imagine a 7 series would probably be the closest you're going to get?

You could always investigate aftermarket damper options, get a soft road setup?
My 7 series is an M sport with 20" wheels, and whilst it rides ok - it's not great.

if you want the look of the big wheels then you need to compromise on ride, drop the wheel size down (therefor increase the tyre sidewall) and you will see a massive difference. I would be tempted to get 18" wheels if I could store the original wheels, not really an option for me tho.

Monkeylegend

29,597 posts

262 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
E Class Mercedes rides well, non AMG /sport version.

Mr Tidy

31,949 posts

158 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
From my (albeit limited) experience I would have to agree with Monty Python!

Had a 123d "Dynamic" so M-sport suspension but 17inch wheels rather than 18inch M-sport ones, but it came on RFT's and the ride was still pretty poor.

My current daily is a 325ti that has 17inch non-RFT's and it is much better (actually at the moment it is on 16inch winters but they don't seem any different).

My "playtime" car is a Z4Coupe on 18inch RFT Bridgestones, and you definitely don't want one of those!

Do the newer models with different driving modes help? I had a 118i Sport courtesy car a couple of years ago and that was pretty good, even on RFT's.

ROLFSSEN

Original Poster:

96 posts

171 months

Friday 26th February 2016
quotequote all
Monty Python said:
With RFTs - none of them.
Yeah, I took my RFTs off my 5 series - made a big difference

ROLFSSEN

Original Poster:

96 posts

171 months

Friday 26th February 2016
quotequote all
So a 5 series with adaptive suspension is the way to go. On smallish wheels, and no RFTs.

aeropilot

40,922 posts

258 months

Friday 26th February 2016
quotequote all
ROLFSSEN said:
So a 5 series with adaptive suspension is the way to go. On smallish wheels, and no RFTs.
.....and comfort seat option smile

_rubinho_

1,237 posts

214 months

Friday 26th February 2016
quotequote all
ROLFSSEN said:
Monty Python said:
With RFTs - none of them.
Yeah, I took my RFTs off my 5 series - made a big difference
Alpina don't fit runflats as standard.

Not sure what the ride in a D3 is like but my B5 is pretty good.

Edit: For a car on 19s with a sports-biased suspension setup so probably nothing like one on 17s on comfort settings.

Edited by _rubinho_ on Friday 26th February 14:22

likesachange

2,666 posts

225 months

Friday 26th February 2016
quotequote all
Pauper spec X5 with those horrible small wheels??

ROLFSSEN

Original Poster:

96 posts

171 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
_rubinho_ said:
Alpina don't fit runflats as standard.

Not sure what the ride in a D3 is like but my B5 is pretty good.

Edit: For a car on 19s with a sports-biased suspension setup so probably nothing like one on 17s on comfort settings.

Edited by _rubinho_ on Friday 26th February 14:22
No it's not very good. It's best described as "jolty". It's the ridges/bumps in the road hit at speed that causes the problems. The suspension is particularly stiff at the rear - the lack of compliance making the car skip rather than absorbing things. It's particularly poor under medium to hard acceleration.

In motorsport terms I think they call it the "high-speed bump" - or the spring rates are simply too high.

aeropilot

40,922 posts

258 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
ROLFSSEN said:
In motorsport terms I think they call it the "high-speed bump" - or the spring rates are simply too high.
Too high rear spring rates are a common BMW issue for UK roads.....fine for smooth well kept roads....but, not our rubbish.

That's why I took mine to Birds - massive improvement.


Mr E

23,110 posts

290 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
Monkeylegend said:
E Class Mercedes rides well, non AMG /sport version.
Rides very well on 18" with air suspension.

ROLFSSEN

Original Poster:

96 posts

171 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
aeropilot said:
Too high rear spring rates are a common BMW issue for UK roads.....fine for smooth well kept roads....but, not our rubbish.

That's why I took mine to Birds - massive improvement.
Please tell me more about what you had done at Birds Aeropilot

aeropilot

40,922 posts

258 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
ROLFSSEN said:
aeropilot said:
Too high rear spring rates are a common BMW issue for UK roads.....fine for smooth well kept roads....but, not our rubbish.

That's why I took mine to Birds - massive improvement.
Please tell me more about what you had done at Birds Aeropilot
Had Birds B1 springs and dampers fitted in place of the standard M-Sport on my 135i. Night and day difference in control and comfort. It's still a little jerky at slow (sub-25mph) speeds on rough roads, but once over 25mph, it smooths out wonderfully. My back doesn't suffer either.



anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 28th February 2016
quotequote all
Wife's BM was transformed by fitting Goidtear Eagle F1 RFTs. Ride like proper tyres, while retaining the benefits of Run flats . Wheaper than the awful Potenzas too ...

mikeyscott

1,200 posts

239 months

Sunday 28th February 2016
quotequote all
aeropilot said:
ROLFSSEN said:
aeropilot said:
Too high rear spring rates are a common BMW issue for UK roads.....fine for smooth well kept roads....but, not our rubbish.

That's why I took mine to Birds - massive improvement.
Please tell me more about what you had done at Birds Aeropilot
Had Birds B1 springs and dampers fitted in place of the standard M-Sport on my 135i. Night and day difference in control and comfort. It's still a little jerky at slow (sub-25mph) speeds on rough roads, but once over 25mph, it smooths out wonderfully. My back doesn't suffer either.
Interesting that you say sub 25mph as yes I agree as I have Birds B1 suspension on my 135i and it feels skittish, so off to Birds next Saturday for them to check. Am on MPSS so will prob get told off for not running CSC5. Did get tempted to fit M Sport back on, sell B1 and just run MPSS tyres. (Come on Continetal get the 6s out in 18s).

In reality I need a 335i with Birds B1 I expect, longer chassis with nice balance. I had a lone C220 15 and loved it for it's effortless mile munching, chassis balance lovely. It did he me questioning what car I want and NEED for dreaded UK roads.

My biggest regret, not taking the uber spec 10 plate DCT over my high spec 11 plate manual.


Edited by mikeyscott on Sunday 28th February 08:23

aeropilot

40,922 posts

258 months

Sunday 28th February 2016
quotequote all
mikeyscott said:
In reality I need a 335i with Birds B1 I expect, longer chassis with nice balance.
I was looking to get a 335i before I got the 135i..........until I drove both.

Unless you need the extra space, the 135i is way more fun to drive. If fun isn't what your after, you may as well skip the 3er and buy a 5 series for comfort?

And, as for still being skittish, why are you taking it back to Birds....what do you expect them to do?

Binning the MPSS would be better.

My summers are P Zero's and it's not ideal for the B1 setup, as the sidewalls are very stiff (probably like the MPSS) but I like the front end with them. Car does ride nicer on the winter Conti's though.
So I will be fitting Conti CS5's next on the summer rims.

Edited by aeropilot on Sunday 28th February 11:49