Pre 2007 N47 cam chain - problem?
Discussion
N47 came a bit earlier than that IIRC - I was invited to drive one in early (March?) 2007 at BMW in Crapnell(!)
Great car, but over time it proved to be a poorly-engineered lash-up - as confirmed by the "Quality Enhancements"! (And my 81+K miles in an N47 123d before BMW decided to start coughing up for fundamental inadequacies in their original "design")!
Mind you my N52 engine has just had a new electric water pump that cost £500 just for the part!
Will just have to keep my E46 a long time to try to compensate...that seems to be the sweet spot age-wise - everything later is just grief on a sliding scale!......
Great car, but over time it proved to be a poorly-engineered lash-up - as confirmed by the "Quality Enhancements"! (And my 81+K miles in an N47 123d before BMW decided to start coughing up for fundamental inadequacies in their original "design")!
Mind you my N52 engine has just had a new electric water pump that cost £500 just for the part!
Will just have to keep my E46 a long time to try to compensate...that seems to be the sweet spot age-wise - everything later is just grief on a sliding scale!......
Mr Tidy said:
Great car, but over time it proved to be a poorly-engineered lash-up - as confirmed by the "Quality Enhancements"! (And my 81+K miles in an N47 123d before BMW decided to start coughing up for fundamental inadequacies in their original "design")!
Will just have to keep my E46 a long time to try to compensate...that seems to be the sweet spot age-wise - everything later is just grief on a sliding scale!......
+1, Correct statement in every respect.Will just have to keep my E46 a long time to try to compensate...that seems to be the sweet spot age-wise - everything later is just grief on a sliding scale!......
Mr Tidy said:
Mind you my N52 engine has just had a new electric water pump that cost £500 just for the part!
Will just have to keep my E46 a long time to try to compensate...that seems to be the sweet spot age-wise - everything later is just grief on a sliding scale!......
Swings and roundabouts though.Will just have to keep my E46 a long time to try to compensate...that seems to be the sweet spot age-wise - everything later is just grief on a sliding scale!......
In the last decade, I've owned a 2005 E91 touring with the N52 engine (for the last 6 years), and previously/during that time also a couple of E46 coupes.
I wouldn't buy another E46 mainly due to personal experience with poor rust-proofing. Both my E46 were well looked after, yet both had rust - mainly cosmetic (wings, rear valance etc.), but pretty unsightly. It may cost 5 times as much to replace the waterpump on an E90, but on the plus side, ours has no visible rust at all after nearly 11 years of being on the road.
In my experience, bolt on parts are fairly easy to replace compared to chasing/curing rust properly on an E46

I guess it depends on how long you plan to keep the car, and how bothered you are about cosmetics.
stevesuk said:
Swings and roundabouts though.
In the last decade, I've owned a 2005 E91 touring with the N52 engine (for the last 6 years), and previously/during that time also a couple of E46 coupes.
I wouldn't buy another E46 mainly due to personal experience with poor rust-proofing. Both my E46 were well looked after, yet both had rust - mainly cosmetic (wings, rear valance etc.), but pretty unsightly. It may cost 5 times as much to replace the waterpump on an E90, but on the plus side, ours has no visible rust at all after nearly 11 years of being on the road.
In my experience, bolt on parts are fairly easy to replace compared to chasing/curing rust properly on an E46
I guess it depends on how long you plan to keep the car, and how bothered you are about cosmetics.
I think you may have chosen the wrong E46 - Compacts don't seem to rot, unlike all the other model variations! Just a shame there was never a factory offering of a 330i Compact - would have been fantastic!In the last decade, I've owned a 2005 E91 touring with the N52 engine (for the last 6 years), and previously/during that time also a couple of E46 coupes.
I wouldn't buy another E46 mainly due to personal experience with poor rust-proofing. Both my E46 were well looked after, yet both had rust - mainly cosmetic (wings, rear valance etc.), but pretty unsightly. It may cost 5 times as much to replace the waterpump on an E90, but on the plus side, ours has no visible rust at all after nearly 11 years of being on the road.
In my experience, bolt on parts are fairly easy to replace compared to chasing/curing rust properly on an E46

I guess it depends on how long you plan to keep the car, and how bothered you are about cosmetics.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


