120d? Sorry it's a boring question...
Discussion
Hi
Not been to the BMW area before, so treat me nicely please*.
Thinking about a 120d for around £5k - so expecting a 05-07 with around 100k on the clock. Anything nasty to look out for apart from the usual checks for something that age/mileage? Not having driven one and only going on the published figures, they look like a decent compromise between economy and performance. It'll be used for an 80 mile round trip commute - B, A and motorway - and lugging 3 kids around, although a Ford Galaxy does main family duties.
Not been to the BMW area before, so treat me nicely please*.
Thinking about a 120d for around £5k - so expecting a 05-07 with around 100k on the clock. Anything nasty to look out for apart from the usual checks for something that age/mileage? Not having driven one and only going on the published figures, they look like a decent compromise between economy and performance. It'll be used for an 80 mile round trip commute - B, A and motorway - and lugging 3 kids around, although a Ford Galaxy does main family duties.
- To establish some credentials, I had a post-PGCE summer job in 1994 with Cooper Reading dealership doing service collection and delivery and got to drive some very nice M5s, E30 M3s, 635s, 2002s and 323s (those are the ones I recall, although I seem to remember enjoying driving stock 520is most at the time - lovely smooth revvy engine that seemed to respond better than the longer stroked 525s) around the Thames Valley. Also the wife had a 318ti Compact when they first came out (95?) so probably about time I returned to the BMW fold.
It depends on which engine the car will have. Early 120d use the m47 engine which can suffer from swirl flap failure and kill the engine. If it's the later n47 engine then they suffer from cam chain problems which can kill the engine. The change over was 2008 I think.
The swirl flaps are an easy fix and are usually removed and blanked off.
The cam chain issues were fixed by an enhancement recall where it was checked and fixed if required.
Apart from the engine issues they can suffer from the usuall bmw weak cooling, stats failing etc, DMF issues and there is a sensor in the ABS pump that can fail and disable the dsc.
I think they are the major things, otherwise they are a pretty solid car.
You may be better off looking on the baby bmw forum as they will know more.
The swirl flaps are an easy fix and are usually removed and blanked off.
The cam chain issues were fixed by an enhancement recall where it was checked and fixed if required.
Apart from the engine issues they can suffer from the usuall bmw weak cooling, stats failing etc, DMF issues and there is a sensor in the ABS pump that can fail and disable the dsc.
I think they are the major things, otherwise they are a pretty solid car.
You may be better off looking on the baby bmw forum as they will know more.
I have a 2005 120d sport so an M47 engine. I use it for a 60 miles round trip commute and for that it is fine. The reason I went for the sport it it didn't have the price of the M-sport but has the better seats in my view. I think the N47 offers much great MPG over the M47. My comments are on the M47 engine.
I'm not 100% sure but believe the swirl flaps are not a problem on thew 163 bhp version of the m47. Yes on the earlier version they where an issue but I think it was fixed for the 1 series launch.
As above, if the thermostats have not been replaced (with evidence) then assume they both need doing and before I brought my car the ABS had failed and been replaced.
Make sure the DMF is not juddering to much. On my car DMF does judder a bit but the clutch does not slip.
Check everything works. AC, lights, etc and see how much smoke there is on cold starting. Do expect some. Also change the crankcase breather if not changed.
Try to find a car with an arm rest. The rubbish business radio can be replaced with a professional radio cheaply.
Not sure what else to comment on but they seem good cars to me.
I'm not 100% sure but believe the swirl flaps are not a problem on thew 163 bhp version of the m47. Yes on the earlier version they where an issue but I think it was fixed for the 1 series launch.
As above, if the thermostats have not been replaced (with evidence) then assume they both need doing and before I brought my car the ABS had failed and been replaced.
Make sure the DMF is not juddering to much. On my car DMF does judder a bit but the clutch does not slip.
Check everything works. AC, lights, etc and see how much smoke there is on cold starting. Do expect some. Also change the crankcase breather if not changed.
Try to find a car with an arm rest. The rubbish business radio can be replaced with a professional radio cheaply.
Not sure what else to comment on but they seem good cars to me.
bracken78 said:
As above, if the thermostats have not been replaced (with evidence) then assume they both need doing and before I brought my car the ABS had failed and been replaced.
We had a 2004 120d a few years back. The ABS/DSC unit/pump failed at relatively low miles (but outside the warranty period of course). Set us back £1,500 to have it replaced, which was eye watering at the time. But these days, I think there is a repair kit available, which is much cheaper?At around the time it happened, it seemed to be a common fault - my wife worked with someone who had a similar age 116i, and her's needed replacing too. So I guess many cars will have had it replaced by now?
I had a 320td from 2005 to 2008 with no problems in 42K miles, but potential swirl-flap issues would be much cheaper to resolve than the N47 cam-chain issues that my 123d may have suffered (so I sold it after 81K miles)!
Stick to the pre-facelift models and you hopefully won't get disastrous issues - or just man-up and get a petrol engine! My 325ti Compact is better than either of it's predecessors! And there is always the 130i option.....
Stick to the pre-facelift models and you hopefully won't get disastrous issues - or just man-up and get a petrol engine! My 325ti Compact is better than either of it's predecessors! And there is always the 130i option.....
Mr Tidy said:
I had a 320td from 2005 to 2008 with no problems in 42K miles, but potential swirl-flap issues would be much cheaper to resolve than the N47 cam-chain issues that my 123d may have suffered (so I sold it after 81K miles)!
Stick to the pre-facelift models and you hopefully won't get disastrous issues - or just man-up and get a petrol engine! My 325ti Compact is better than either of it's predecessors! And there is always the 130i option.....
I went from a 320Td to a 330Ci. I sometimes forget how much of a revelation it was to experience a 6 cylinder petrol after a 4 cylinder diesel.Stick to the pre-facelift models and you hopefully won't get disastrous issues - or just man-up and get a petrol engine! My 325ti Compact is better than either of it's predecessors! And there is always the 130i option.....
Patrick Bateman said:
I went from a 320Td to a 330Ci. I sometimes forget how much of a revelation it was to experience a 6 cylinder petrol after a 4 cylinder diesel.
I don't - I remember every day when I get into the Z4 Coupe that replaced my 123d
And I still remember whenever I use my 325ti daily - what was I thinking?
BTW OP, there are a lot of options out there!
Pre-facelift 120ds potentially have swirl-flap issues, post facelift have cam-chain issues which BMW may be amenable to help with - bit of a minefield really! Unless the work has already been done of course!
FWIW even post-facelift I would look for a 120d as they had much better gearing than the 123d I had, and a 20bhp uplift was a BMW option for the 120d.
Good luck with your search OP!
Pre-facelift 120ds potentially have swirl-flap issues, post facelift have cam-chain issues which BMW may be amenable to help with - bit of a minefield really! Unless the work has already been done of course!
FWIW even post-facelift I would look for a 120d as they had much better gearing than the 123d I had, and a 20bhp uplift was a BMW option for the 120d.
Good luck with your search OP!
14-7 said:
harleywilma said:
Dont buy one 1 series are terrible crap and riddled with gremlins !!!!!
Wow, care to elaborate?But if you are selective (or maybe lucky!) they can be fine!
I had my 123d for 6 and a half years and did over 81K miles - all I ever replaced were tyres (3 times), one battery and one starter motor (I think the stop/start killed that) but it was still on original wiper blades and front and rear brake pads!
Very capable car, but it did lack excitement!
So I bought a Z4 Coupe to replace it and got plenty of excitement, but it did make my eyes water when it needed a new electric water pump!
So OP, if a 120d would work for you don't be put off - just make sure you know their weaknesses and get the right one.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


