335d x drive touring v 535d touring, which would you go for?
Discussion
I currently have a 2014 E Class estate and will be looking to change in the next 2 months.
I like the E Class, the spec is sufficient for me in standard trim, it has lots of space, looks good (subjective but in my view it does), but the engine (220 diesel) is rubbish, coarse, unrefined and generally unpleasant.
I test drove a 335d x drive for 24 hours and thought it a very good car. Powerful, smooth, refined and with a most un-diesel like engine sound. The grip and traction was very good as was the ZF 8 speed box (much better than the slow 7 speed in the E Class). The car I drove had the adaptive chassis option and I would go for this if I ordered one. My only reservations are that it is quite noticeably smaller than the E Class (particularly the boot) and that some items that were standard on the Merc (e.g. heated front seats) are optional.
I've not driven the 535d but I like the look of them and it would certainly offer more space than the 335d. My reservation is will some of the aspects I like so much in the 335d be lost in the 535d? E.g. the grip, traction and all round pace. I think the 535d is still a quick car but I wonder if it would be able to put its power down as well as a 335d. The spec on the 5 vs 3 is better.
Either car would be leased and the better deals seem to be on the 335 rather than the 535d at present.
I expect my ultimate decision will be driven by how necessary I deem the extra space to be but I wondered if anyone had had similar deliberations?
I like the E Class, the spec is sufficient for me in standard trim, it has lots of space, looks good (subjective but in my view it does), but the engine (220 diesel) is rubbish, coarse, unrefined and generally unpleasant.
I test drove a 335d x drive for 24 hours and thought it a very good car. Powerful, smooth, refined and with a most un-diesel like engine sound. The grip and traction was very good as was the ZF 8 speed box (much better than the slow 7 speed in the E Class). The car I drove had the adaptive chassis option and I would go for this if I ordered one. My only reservations are that it is quite noticeably smaller than the E Class (particularly the boot) and that some items that were standard on the Merc (e.g. heated front seats) are optional.
I've not driven the 535d but I like the look of them and it would certainly offer more space than the 335d. My reservation is will some of the aspects I like so much in the 335d be lost in the 535d? E.g. the grip, traction and all round pace. I think the 535d is still a quick car but I wonder if it would be able to put its power down as well as a 335d. The spec on the 5 vs 3 is better.
Either car would be leased and the better deals seem to be on the 335 rather than the 535d at present.
I expect my ultimate decision will be driven by how necessary I deem the extra space to be but I wondered if anyone had had similar deliberations?
I'm fairly sure heated seats are still an option on the 5-series.
If you like the traction on the xDrive then I doubt the 535d will do it for you; even my 535i with less torque is quite capable of flashing the DSC light at me regularly. But BMWs are supposed to be rwd to me
The 5-series interior is a definite step up from the 3-series, but it doesn't feel as spacious as my old E61s, possibly because you sit lower in the F11.
If you like the traction on the xDrive then I doubt the 535d will do it for you; even my 535i with less torque is quite capable of flashing the DSC light at me regularly. But BMWs are supposed to be rwd to me
The 5-series interior is a definite step up from the 3-series, but it doesn't feel as spacious as my old E61s, possibly because you sit lower in the F11.Spuffington said:
If there's the choice, I would go with the 535d every time. Sure, maybe not as light handling as the 3er, but bucket loads of space, comfortable and refined. Plus I find the xDrive chassis in the F31 somewhat inert and prefer RWD.
Agree with this and I would go 535d for sure, the 4wd system just adds weight and I have a 640d and it has no issues whatsoever getting all of its power down.I saw a 535d touring yesterday and said to the mrs what a cracking car that would be(535i would be too) because I really liked my old 520d touring apart from the gutless and unrefined engine.
Mr_Yogi said:
AFAIK the 6 cylinder diesel 5's have front heated seats as standard, if fact maybe all 5's do?
I stand corrected - there's a fair bit of spec which has been made standard which was optional on mine in 2012. Heated front seats are standard on the 535i according to the configurator.I'd have the 5 - and put winters on it from Dec - March... RWD with winters will be fine whatever the weather, and outside of that, RWD won't be much of a disadvantage and as another poster has pointed out, will feel more BMW like...
I like the bigger wheelbase of the 5 - for practicality of course - but more for the way that it rides on our jittery roads.
But if a 535d drive was available i'd probably have that!
I like the bigger wheelbase of the 5 - for practicality of course - but more for the way that it rides on our jittery roads.
But if a 535d drive was available i'd probably have that!
I'd have the 535d unless traffic light GPs are your thing, the F11 is a world away from the F31 in terms of refinement/space/quality etc....
There is massive support on the 535d at the moment you can get over 13k off them so lease deals should be keen, a nice spec 535d M sport with pro nav/adaptive lights/HK should come it at around 42k and heated seats are standard.
There is massive support on the 535d at the moment you can get over 13k off them so lease deals should be keen, a nice spec 535d M sport with pro nav/adaptive lights/HK should come it at around 42k and heated seats are standard.
Edited by Wills2 on Friday 4th March 18:54
I've sort of driven both and currently own a facelift 335D Msport touring having come from a E91 325d touring, I had a loan 530D Msport touring for a couple of weeks about 2 years ago.
I think the answer to your dilema is what do you want? Space and luxobarge feel with some oomph or something practical and a bit more nimble, I am guessing having come from the E class you'll want the former.
For me I found the 530d's extra inches annoying around town, parking etc and pressing on felt a bit floaty. I find the 335D more agile and practical day to day and when pressing on and I have rarely found the space an issue (family of 4 camping etc), once or twice a year I strap a roof box on. I'd rather do that occasionally than live with the extra girth every day.
Also the 3 series was significantly cheaper than the 5 series ( you can get 9% ish off both 335d and 535d at the mo) .
Both are lovely cars whichever you choose, if you tell yourself that youve bought the right one , you will be correct.
I think the answer to your dilema is what do you want? Space and luxobarge feel with some oomph or something practical and a bit more nimble, I am guessing having come from the E class you'll want the former.
For me I found the 530d's extra inches annoying around town, parking etc and pressing on felt a bit floaty. I find the 335D more agile and practical day to day and when pressing on and I have rarely found the space an issue (family of 4 camping etc), once or twice a year I strap a roof box on. I'd rather do that occasionally than live with the extra girth every day.
Also the 3 series was significantly cheaper than the 5 series ( you can get 9% ish off both 335d and 535d at the mo) .
Both are lovely cars whichever you choose, if you tell yourself that youve bought the right one , you will be correct.
Wills my memory clearly isn't what it was, quick check on Broadspeed to remind me and you are of course correct 535d touring £38300, 335d touring £33,900, that's over 20%. I leased my 335d as, at the time the 2 year lease deals made it cheaper than a 320D, at the time the lease figures on the 535d were quite a bit higher but leasing deals come and go.
Neil-y0jlk said:
Wills my memory clearly isn't what it was, quick check on Broadspeed to remind me and you are of course correct 535d touring £38300, 335d touring £33,900, that's over 20%. I leased my 335d as, at the time the 2 year lease deals made it cheaper than a 320D, at the time the lease figures on the 535d were quite a bit higher but leasing deals come and go.
No worries, the lease deals can be brilliant and as you say the cheapest/best option. bmthnick1981 said:
Thanks guys, a strong lean towards the 5 then.
Point taken on the heated seats!
I think the thing to do is to get a drive in a 535d.
I agonised over this 3 Years ago well it was the 330d as 335dx drive had not been released at that time,I drove both for several days and it really was close but I went for the 535d touring. Yes it's got loads of space but it's huge to park/ drive, it's incredibly capable as a cruiser but it's also one of the most boring cars I ever owned. Given the choice again I'd go for the 3 series every time, much more a drivers car particularly with the benefit of the 35d engine and xdrivePoint taken on the heated seats!
I think the thing to do is to get a drive in a 535d.
The three series should be the more nimble car of the two but the perceived build quality in the five is quite a bit more impressive. I had a 530d and now have a 535d. In hindsight, two essential options for me would be the adaptive suspension which gives you a real choice between luxo-barge comfort and a much taughter feel on the twisties. The other option would be to make sure you have the sports auto box with paddle shifters. If I could sneak in a third it would be the large sunroof which I've had on both mine. The five definitely does not have a sports car chassis. Perhaps a consideration for you, it will be replaced in the next year - presumably with a lighter model.
The 35d engine is a technical masterpiece in terms of power, sound and fuel efficiency however, I don't think diesel engines lend themselves well to sports car characteristics. If that is a major consideration I would be inclined to point you in the direction of an M3 (or M4 if you need fold down seats).
Peter
The 35d engine is a technical masterpiece in terms of power, sound and fuel efficiency however, I don't think diesel engines lend themselves well to sports car characteristics. If that is a major consideration I would be inclined to point you in the direction of an M3 (or M4 if you need fold down seats).
Peter
F355GTS said:
Given the choice again I'd go for the 3 series every time, much more a drivers car particularly with the benefit of the 35d engine and xdrive
My old 335d xdrive was anything but a drivers car, I was shocked it was that bad. (very fast yes but awful to thread through a series of bends) boat like would be my description. Wills2 said:
F355GTS said:
Given the choice again I'd go for the 3 series every time, much more a drivers car particularly with the benefit of the 35d engine and xdrive
My old 335d xdrive was anything but a drivers car, I was shocked it was that bad. (very fast yes but awful to thread through a series of bends) boat like would be my description. kingofdbrits said:
saying it's awful is a bit strong, but i'll agree its not exactly a drivers car, but then who buys a heavy diesel estate unless you have to? So if you do need a heavy diesel estate and still want a bit of fun driving then i'd say the 3 is a better choice than the 5. I do find the xdrive quite impressive at times and have left an M4 squirming for grip when powering out of a damp corner, so again the 3 series has another pro over the 5, in my humble view anyway.
Just my opinion, driving's not about beating that M4 it's about enjoyment, that M4 can have fun at 20mph.... My experience of my 335d taught me on paper stats don't = fun, so if you want/need a large diesel estate with a bit of poke, you might as well get the 5 as it does all the things that matter so much better than the 3.
Edited by Wills2 on Saturday 5th March 23:52
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



)