BMW 5 Series F10 528i v 520D
BMW 5 Series F10 528i v 520D
Author
Discussion

Christian-fo2ke

Original Poster:

19 posts

136 months

Saturday 5th March 2016
quotequote all
Im looking for a daily run around for myself and partner, I'm considering the 520d 2012-2013 but also looking at the 6 cylinder 528i, apart from the obvious power difference and MPG is it worth going for the 6 cylinder , its actually cheaper to buy comparing around. Whats peoples views on the engines. Thanks in advance.

Mr E

23,110 posts

290 months

Saturday 5th March 2016
quotequote all
At some point the 28i became a turbo 4.
I don't know when though.

Christian-fo2ke

Original Poster:

19 posts

136 months

Saturday 5th March 2016
quotequote all
yes around 2012 so id have to go for a "old" f10 2010-2012 for the 528i.

northpolar

137 posts

167 months

Saturday 5th March 2016
quotequote all
If you aren't doing high mileage, the petrol engine sixes are turbine smooth. I'd take that every day over a four pot diesel.

Peter

Patrick Bateman

13,223 posts

205 months

Sunday 6th March 2016
quotequote all
I didn't realise the 528i was ever a 6 cylinder, thought it was a turbo 4 pot the whole time.

cerb4.5lee

45,361 posts

211 months

Sunday 6th March 2016
quotequote all
northpolar said:
If you aren't doing high mileage, the petrol engine sixes are turbine smooth. I'd take that every day over a four pot diesel.

Peter
Absolutely this and there just isn't any comparison and I have had both engines,with the four pot diesel you will just end up hating it but with the silky six petrol you will just love it.

It's like saying...which do you prefer...sleeping outside in a tent in winter or sleeping in a five star hotel and that's the difference between the two engines.

Christian-fo2ke

Original Poster:

19 posts

136 months

Sunday 6th March 2016
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies more less what i was thinking as MPG isn't a massive concern .

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Sunday 6th March 2016
quotequote all
The BMW straight six petrol is one of the best engines ever made, it is a complete joy, the 2 litre 4cyl diesel is.......not.

This is not a question that needs asking, I sort of get why some may ask 530d vs 528i, but 520d??

A question that could only come from someone who has not driven them both. wink

ChrisR99

453 posts

142 months

Sunday 6th March 2016
quotequote all
Christian-fo2ke said:
Thanks for the replies more less what i was thinking as MPG isn't a massive concern .
Petrol all the way then!

bmwmike

8,810 posts

139 months

Sunday 6th March 2016
quotequote all
I've got a 530i.. same engine pretty much as 528i and it's great. The revvy nature suits the car imo and it is very smooth and sounds great. If mpg is not a concern petrol all the way imo..

Edit surprised they are cheaper to but than the diesel as there are so many more diesels on the market

Christian-fo2ke

Original Poster:

19 posts

136 months

Friday 11th March 2016
quotequote all
Id rather a petrol and they seem to be cheaper i suppose most want low tax high MPG if doing the miles.