NHS dentists and crowns - metal or ceramic (white)?
NHS dentists and crowns - metal or ceramic (white)?
Author
Discussion

daddy cool

Original Poster:

4,107 posts

258 months

Monday 14th March 2016
quotequote all
I need a crown on one of my teeth - 2nd from back, lower - and the dentist told me that it would be metal, and cost ~£230 (or whatever the top tier of NHS charges is) or if I wanted white it would be £500+.
The NHS website is a bit vague, and says white is available - but does that assume that they only offer white where it is very visible - ie front teeth?

I suppose I don't mind that much from a vanity point of view, but the practice is quite "money grabbing" - its mostly private, with one NHS dentist who refuses to do some of the things that are covered by the 1st tier NHS charge (eg scale & polish) and they try to strong-arm you into seeing the private hygienist - so I wondered if this is the same?
Are metal or ceramic crowns better or worse than the other?

As an aside, am I the only adult man that is absolutely terrified of dental procedure? I am bricking it about this appointment next week... just having a filling leaves me a sweaty hyperventilating wreck. cry

Emily's dad

277 posts

165 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
I've had a crown and an inlay done recently. My dentist suggested that metal was more durable than ceramic. I was offered the choice all at the same cost on NHS around the £230 mark.
She suggested that if metal, gold coloured (can't imagine there's much real gold in my crown) is actually less obvious than silver as it reflects less in the mouth.
Mine are lower jaw, a couple of teeth from the back of my mouth and not at all noticeable.

Can't comment on why your dentist wants to charge more for white, but my dentist offered all options at same cost.

As for jibbering wreck, can't say I enjoy the dentist but since changing practice I don't mind going. Maybe a different practice may be the answer.

Rollin

6,331 posts

274 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
daddy cool said:
I need a crown on one of my teeth - 2nd from back, lower - and the dentist told me that it would be metal, and cost ~£230 (or whatever the top tier of NHS charges is) or if I wanted white it would be £500+.
The NHS website is a bit vague, and says white is available - but does that assume that they only offer white where it is very visible - ie front teeth?

I suppose I don't mind that much from a vanity point of view, but the practice is quite "money grabbing" - its mostly private, with one NHS dentist who refuses to do some of the things that are covered by the 1st tier NHS charge (eg scale & polish) and they try to strong-arm you into seeing the private hygienist - so I wondered if this is the same?
Are metal or ceramic crowns better or worse than the other?

As an aside, am I the only adult man that is absolutely terrified of dental procedure? I am bricking it about this appointment next week... just having a filling leaves me a sweaty hyperventilating wreck. cry
Hmm. He can get the hygienist to do the S and P if he likes, but why should you pay privately for NHS treatment?

I do white NHS crowns. We are allowed to use any suitable material. An all metal crown is a suitable material too though.

MacGee

2,513 posts

259 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
An all metal crown is thinner which means less drilling and tooth destruction. Towards the back teh teeth are already quite flat and so this means less height for good retention(grip). So a good NHS option. A standard ceramic crown usually has a metal shell beneath thus making the crown twice as thick...meaning more tooth removal to allow the bite to be even. So sometimes not a good idea. Private white crowns can be made without metal at all but using a strong ceramic...expensive..so thats why some will have white on NHS and others privately. Hope this helps.

WinstonWolf

72,863 posts

268 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
You used to get gold crowns, now they're only silver which is a bit less piratey weeping 2nd from back, the only person who will see them is your dentist...

daddy cool

Original Poster:

4,107 posts

258 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
Cheers for the replies guys

Driller

8,310 posts

307 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
daddy cool said:
the practice is quite "money grabbing"
hehe

What on earth does that mean?

DragsterRR

367 posts

136 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
I had two crowns done privately at the back end of last year.
Ceramic crown was 380, gold crown was 300.
The ceramic was my smaller incisor and the gold one was my canine (Because Pirate)

Seems cheaper than your NHS dentist.

Composite Guru

2,501 posts

232 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
I've just recently had a gold crown fitted at my private dentist and was told it was the best way for less destruction of the existing tooth and also more durable.

I'm an engineer by trade so I appreciated the durability over the cosmetic side. Its on a No 6 molar so you can't see it when I smile so all good.

You can defo tell the difference using a private dentist to an NHS one as they take more time and do a better job. Ok so it costs more but hey ho!! Quality costs. biggrin

Mine cost £500 for the whole process from start to finish.

xx99xx

2,996 posts

102 months

Sunday 9th August 2020
quotequote all
I realise the thread is a few years old but just wondered if the situation with NHS crowns is the same.

I have a molar filling which falls out every 6 months so an onlay has been suggested. My NHS dentist is suggesting £700 for a 'white' one but I was expecting band 3 NHS charge. I forgot to question it at the time.

I have a temporary filling in my problem tooth which will last a few weeks, whilst I make up my mind about the onlay. Can you get ceramic on NHS? Also, can a dentist pick and choose which treatments to do on NHS and which they'll do privately?

ColuGav

156 posts

196 months

Tuesday 11th August 2020
quotequote all
I actually had a crown fitted on the Upper Left 6 molar last Wednesday following a root canal. I wasn't given a choice (other than pull or crown), but my dentist gave me a white ceramic crown (well it says Zirconia on the receipt).

All under band 3 NHS..

cringle

406 posts

215 months

Saturday 15th August 2020
quotequote all
Under the NHS dental contract, all the dentist needs to do is secure your oral health. Naturally that will be done in the most cost effective and tooth friendly manner. For example if you have a gap, a denture is likely to be provided rather than a bridge, as no additional tooth structure is damaged and it's quicker and cheaper. With regard to crowns, a silver non precious crown requires the minimal amount of tooth structure to be removed compared to say a metallo-ceramic crown. NHS dentistry is notoriously underfunded, google "NHS dentistry - The Big Lie". Having all the treatment you need for £269.30 - which covers your examination, all xrays, all the fillings you need, all the root canals you need, all the extractions you need, any cleaning you need, as well as labwork such as crowns, is a bargain. So if a dentist offers you a private option for something that looks prettier and requires more time to complete, yes the price will be higher. Lastly, the band 3 fee is a subsidised price, which is why the step up to a private treatment can seem quite big