Roof bars and box for E91 335d (Touring) 2009
Roof bars and box for E91 335d (Touring) 2009
Author
Discussion

Freddy88FM

Original Poster:

474 posts

165 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2016
quotequote all
Hi all,

Just looking for a roof bar/box combination for my new car. I want it as low profile and as sleek looking as possible. I guess the first step is to find low profile, well fitting bars.

I have had an extensive google and read a few forums but can't seem to find much. So I thought I'd ask here if anyone has any recommendations!

Thanks in advance!

meduk1

29 posts

139 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2016
quotequote all
I used roofracks.co.uk to order mine. Thule are a very good make and do both bulky square bars (which I went with as I'm not leaving it on most of the time) and more low profile aero ones - worth a look.

Be mindful though that some of their aero bars require additional adapters or more complex fitting that the standard square bars. I'm presuming that as you're looking for something low profile you're planning on leaving it on most of the time so that might not be a big issue for you.

Freddy88FM

Original Poster:

474 posts

165 months

Thursday 24th March 2016
quotequote all
Thanks a lot. Have had a look. I think it's all about getting the right bars for me. Low profile and ones that dont stick out over the side. Tricky!

interstellar

5,132 posts

177 months

Thursday 24th March 2016
quotequote all
Thule wingbar edge would work then.

This website and company have very good reviews.

http://www.roofbox.co.uk/

I have just ordered the same plus 3 bike carriers for my F31. Their online chat and website is very good.

I placed my order yesterday so its not an old recommendation

FurryExocet

3,011 posts

212 months

Thursday 24th March 2016
quotequote all
The thule bars we have are quite poor quality. The end caps keep falling off and the locking clips have all broken, not very impressed, as they weren't cheap!
I have a genuine BMW one on mine, much better quality and was picked up on ebay

Freddy88FM

Original Poster:

474 posts

165 months

Thursday 24th March 2016
quotequote all
Thanks a lot, I'll have a look and see. Might nip over to Halfrauds too just to get an better idea of what they'll look like. Crikey, what's happened to me? The new car has put fashion on par with function?! Unlike me!

ladderino

728 posts

170 months

Thursday 24th March 2016
quotequote all
Take a look at Whispbars - they do a rail mounted cross bar which means the bars are flush with the rails (model number is S45W).

This is what I've got on my E91, along with a Thule Motion 800 - looks great as it hugs the roof.

I've not got a picture of the car with it on, but it looks quite similar to this: http://tinyurl.com/zq27q9l


twokcc

1,032 posts

208 months

Friday 25th March 2016
quotequote all
Used to have an E46 saloon and bar BMW crossbars and cycle racks from an Ebayer. Unfortunately had some parts missing which seller could not find, eventually found that BMW bars are made by Atera which roofbox co.uk sell They were extremely helpful and managed to find the missing parts which were a perfect fit in the BMW crossbar T grove. So highly recommended as a company to deal with and suggest you look at The Atera bars if you want BMW quality.

ladderino

728 posts

170 months

Friday 25th March 2016
quotequote all
I also recommend roofbox.co.uk - this is where I got my Whispbars from.

Bought my roof box itself from North East Roofracks - they were the cheapest I could find on Google at the time.

Both good to deal with - only issue I had was that the courier managed to lose the roof box.

blueST

4,910 posts

247 months

Saturday 26th March 2016
quotequote all
Just an unproven theory I have, I reckon that most the noise generated by roof bars comes from foot/mounting area. I have wing bars now and they still make noise. I wouldn't worry overly if you can't stretch to the wing/aero option of whatever brand you go for.

Freddy88FM

Original Poster:

474 posts

165 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
ladderino said:
Take a look at Whispbars - they do a rail mounted cross bar which means the bars are flush with the rails (model number is S45W).

This is what I've got on my E91, along with a Thule Motion 800 - looks great as it hugs the roof.

I've not got a picture of the car with it on, but it looks quite similar to this: http://tinyurl.com/zq27q9l
Damn damn damn damn damn damn damn. They are perfect. I ended up getting the thule 757 with black aero roof bars. I think i'll buy these and sell the Thule system on.

ladderino

728 posts

170 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
Yep - they are great. Don't make any wind noise as far as I can tell (I sometimes leave just the bars on if I'm feeling lazy).

I'd also suggest getting the Thule T-track mounting kit rather than using the 'claws' which come with their roof boxes now. The claws work better on square bars, and don't have as good a purchase on asymmetrical bars.

Freddy88FM

Original Poster:

474 posts

165 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
Ok, thanks. I'll have a look once it all arrives.

I currently have a thule touring 200 roof box, thule 757 footpads, 961b wings and the bars you suggested all on their way to me! Need to get the thule stuff back and refunded then will look in to the different attachment mechanism.

Really appreciate your comments by the way. Will report back on Sat when I'm home next and can fit it all.

Swervin_Mervin

5,016 posts

269 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
Just to hijack this thread a bit. I've an E91 as well so looking for the same setup.

But my wife has an F20 1-series, and I was wondering if there's a setup we can get where it could be swapped over between both cars, maybe just needing additional legs/feet for the F20.

Freddy88FM

Original Poster:

474 posts

165 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
Swervin_Mervin said:
Just to hijack this thread a bit. I've an E91 as well so looking for the same setup.

But my wife has an F20 1-series, and I was wondering if there's a setup we can get where it could be swapped over between both cars, maybe just needing additional legs/feet for the F20.
I don't have an answer for you buy that is the greatest username I've ever seen.

ladderino

728 posts

170 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
Best thing to do would be to head to roofbox.co.uk and search for bars that apply for the F20, and then do the same for the E91 - I don't think the Whispbar cross bars are going to work though, as they need a rail to attach to.

Neil-y0jlk

47 posts

134 months

Sunday 10th April 2016
quotequote all
I've just sold a 2008 325d touring and still have the whisbar(s) from that and haven't got around to ebaying them yet.

No idea what they are worth so if you are interested make me an offer.

I found them very good, whether they are actually much quieter than square bars I cant tell as these were the first bars I've ever used.

Swervin_Mervin

5,016 posts

269 months

Tuesday 12th April 2016
quotequote all
Neil-y0jlk said:
I've just sold a 2008 325d touring and still have the whisbar(s) from that and haven't got around to ebaying them yet.

No idea what they are worth so if you are interested make me an offer.

I found them very good, whether they are actually much quieter than square bars I cant tell as these were the first bars I've ever used.
I could be interested in those - how long have you had them?

Neil-y0jlk

47 posts

134 months

Thursday 14th April 2016
quotequote all
Swervin, sorry I overlooked your post, I've had them about 4 years they have been used about 6 times, I don't keep them on the car in between.

Drop me a pm if you want to discuss more

Freddy88FM

Original Poster:

474 posts

165 months

Friday 15th April 2016
quotequote all
Neil-y0jlk said:
Swervin, sorry I overlooked your post, I've had them about 4 years they have been used about 6 times, I don't keep them on the car in between.

Drop me a pm if you want to discuss more
Damn it. 2 weeks earlier and I'd have taken them from you! Paid full £160 price. From eBay they seem to go for about £80 used... none on there when I needed them.