My 2012 M135i engine needs totally replacing!
My 2012 M135i engine needs totally replacing!
Author
Discussion

Steveashley1990

Original Poster:

8 posts

127 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
I have just been told by BMW that my M135i engine needs totally replacing! I broke down in it a few weeks ago and managed to get it towed to the dealership. They've had a look at it and concluded that it is a major issue and that the engine will need replacing. They said that the crank shaft is damaged, damage to the Pistons, cylinders etc. I'm not too clued up on engines but none the less i have a major issue on my hands. The car is just over 3 years old. I have been the owner for 12 months. This problem occurred 10 days after the warranty had ended. Unbelievable! The price of a brand new engine I'm told is £16,000. BMW have said as a good will gesture they will cover 'most' of the cost but want a contribution from me for £2,500. So I could do with a little advice on; 1) is this a good deal considering how much I could of paid or a bad deal considering in my opinion something as catastrophic as this should not be happening on a car so young and with only 48,000 miles on the clock. And 2) would I have a case on my hands in getting my money back even though it is out of warranty?
Any advice at all would be a huge help. Thanks.

eybic

9,212 posts

205 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
Speak to BMW Customer Services.

Where did you buy the car from? You have better chance of getting a decent contribution if:

You bought it from a BMW dealer.

It has Full BMW (very important to them) service history.

You have owned BMW's in the past.

However, remember that they have no legal obligation to help you as the warranty has expired.

AndStilliRise

2,295 posts

147 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
Sorry to hear dude. How much is an engine from ebay out of interest? I would be putting pressure on BMW to contribute a little more.

Steveashley1990

Original Poster:

8 posts

127 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
eybic said:
Speak to BMW Customer Services.

Where did you buy the car from? You have better chance of getting a decent contribution if:

You bought it from a BMW dealer.

It has Full BMW (very important to them) service history.

You have owned BMW's in the past.

However, remember that they have no legal obligation to help you as the warranty has expired.
I bought the car from sytner BMW. So it is an AUC dealership.

It has been regularly serviced by BMW the most recent one in October last year as it had a service pack on it when I bought it.

I personally haven't owned a BMW in the past although at our house we do have 4 BMWs on finance bought from the same dealership.

eybic

9,212 posts

205 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
Having worked for a big manufacturer previously, please don't get shouty on the phone to them and never forget they don't HAVE to help you, their legal responsibility ended when the warranty expired and any contribution will be goodwill which will be reduced dramatically if you shout and scream at the person on the end of the phone.

ETA: If as you say BMW are covering most of it then perhaps the dealership could cover the remaining 15%. MAKE SURE YOU CONTRIBUTE SOMETHING THOUGH (even 1p) AS YOU CAN'T GET A WARRANTY ON SOMETHING YOU HAVEN'T PAID FOR!!!!

Edited by eybic on Monday 4th April 14:38

eybic

9,212 posts

205 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
OK, that makes things a lot simpler.

In my mind this should be sorted between Sytner and BMW. How did you pay for the car? Is it on finance?

Steveashley1990

Original Poster:

8 posts

127 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
eybic said:
OK, that makes things a lot simpler.

In my mind this should be sorted between Sytner and BMW. How did you pay for the car? Is it on finance?
The car is on finance yea.

eybic

9,212 posts

205 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
That makes it more likely the dealership will help as they will have made a bit more money on the car by you taking it on finance. My first call would be to BMW customer services explaining this is your first BMW but your family have had a few, you thought you were buying into a quality brand etc. etc. bought from a dealer doing the right thing etc. etc. of course the car must have been looked after as it was an AUC car so FSH etc. etc. etc.

As I said, don't get stty with them and you should have a good outcome, although they wanted you to pay £2.5k that's still an 85% discount but see if you can eek more out of them.

Alex

9,978 posts

315 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
Sounds like a good offer to me. A brand new engine for £2.5k fitted by BMW? I'd bite their hand off.

JNW1

9,541 posts

225 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
Steveashley1990 said:
I have just been told by BMW that my M135i engine needs totally replacing! I broke down in it a few weeks ago and managed to get it towed to the dealership. They've had a look at it and concluded that it is a major issue and that the engine will need replacing. They said that the crank shaft is damaged, damage to the Pistons, cylinders etc. I'm not too clued up on engines but none the less i have a major issue on my hands. The car is just over 3 years old. I have been the owner for 12 months. This problem occurred 10 days after the warranty had ended. Unbelievable! The price of a brand new engine I'm told is £16,000. BMW have said as a good will gesture they will cover 'most' of the cost but want a contribution from me for £2,500. So I could do with a little advice on; 1) is this a good deal considering how much I could of paid or a bad deal considering in my opinion something as catastrophic as this should not be happening on a car so young and with only 48,000 miles on the clock. And 2) would I have a case on my hands in getting my money back even though it is out of warranty?
Any advice at all would be a huge help. Thanks.
I agree you wouldn't expect a catastrophic engine failure on a relatively low mileage car that has been serviced from new by main dealers; however, it sounds like BMW have already said they'll cover most of the cost and you'd like to think a major dealership like Sytner will cover the rest (certainly hope so and hope you won't be left out of pocket). I guess this has bound to have soured your ownership experience to some extent but it would be interesting to know what has caused the failure? The N55 engine has a generally good reputation for reliability so hopefully BMW/Sytner will recognise this as a one-off and see you alright; good luck and let us know how you get on!

JNW1

9,541 posts

225 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
Alex said:
Sounds like a good offer to me. A brand new engine for £2.5k fitted by BMW? I'd bite their hand off.
Hmm, sounds like the OP is being asked to cough-up £2.5k (probably more than 10% of the price he paid for the car) when it's done less than 50k miles and has been maintained exclusively by the main dealer network; in those circumstances I think between them BMW and Sytners ought to be covering the cost in full unless they can show that owner negligence (e.g. running the car when it was short of oil) contributed to the failure. If it's a manufacturing defect I think it would be very disappointing if the OP was left nursing a four-figure bill although I know people like Porsche have been happy to walk away and leave owners in the lurch in similar circumstances....

bigfish

418 posts

218 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
I reckon you will be looked after. I had an issue on a 335i, and they helped. New engine was put in, I think I had to pay some labour, but engine was under goodwill

Keep us posted and good luck

JNW1

9,541 posts

225 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
bigfish said:
I reckon you will be looked after. I had an issue on a 335i, and they helped. New engine was put in, I think I had to pay some labour, but engine was under goodwill

Keep us posted and good luck
Was that the N55 engine as well? I know the N54 had its problems but I thought the N55 was pretty robust!

Steveashley1990

Original Poster:

8 posts

127 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
bigfish said:
I reckon you will be looked after. I had an issue on a 335i, and they helped. New engine was put in, I think I had to pay some labour, but engine was under goodwill

Keep us posted and good luck
What was the issue with your engine and how much were your labour costs?

MrBarry123

6,109 posts

152 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
It's good advice above regarding contributing something to ensure you can benefit from a warranty into the future.

If you get nowhere by saying "no, I won't be paying anything", I'd be sending correspondence to:

Graeme Grieve, BMW UK Managing Director - graeme.grieve@bmw.co.uk
BMW UK's Twitter account - https://twitter.com/BMW_UK?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%...

There's a lot of these cars currently in the AUC programme so BMW will want to avoid bad publicity such as this.

arcticfire

1,990 posts

150 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
If it's an inherent fault isn't there something like a 6 year cover available if you can prove it? Just throwing it out there!

nickpan

649 posts

220 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
How will this impact its used sale value?

I'd think twice about a car that had had its engine replace, for fear of negligence on behalf of its former owner, irrespective of the reason given to me by the seller.

You may find a way out of paying the £2.5k but get hit when you come to sell.

What do you think about demanding a new car?

I agree - engine failure is pretty catastrophic if you ask me.

Nick

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
nickpan said:
How will this impact its used sale value?

I'd think twice about a car that had had its engine replace, for fear of negligence on behalf of its former owner, irrespective of the reason given to me by the seller.

You may find a way out of paying the £2.5k but get hit when you come to sell.
i'd say the opposite. If the OP proceeds to get a new engine (even at £2.5k) if say he sells the car in 3 years time with 80k on the chassis but 30k on the engine with a BIG receipt from BMW showing an engine ought to have cost £16k.... i'd be quite happy with that.


DuraAce

4,272 posts

191 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
nickpan said:
How will this impact its used sale value?

I'd think twice about a car that had had its engine replace, for fear of negligence on behalf of its former owner, irrespective of the reason given to me by the seller.

You may find a way out of paying the £2.5k but get hit when you come to sell.

What do you think about demanding a new car?

I agree - engine failure is pretty catastrophic if you ask me.

Nick
Demanding a new car?! On what grounds? Have a day off will you! It's out of warranty, he's done well to get a good contribution from the manufacturer.

How would you even know the engine had been replaced? You wouldn't. IMHO it doesn't affect resale value at all.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 4th April 2016
quotequote all
He may have been 10 days out of warranty but he would most certainly have obtained a new one from BMW for not a lot. On the balance of probabilities would you expect an AUC car with a full BMWSH at 3 years old to go bang ! - no chance.

This £16K engine - trust me the dealership wont be shouldering a £13500 loss for 'goodwill' so smells of BS by them.

I'd create merry hell, calmly as others have mentioned.....no way should he be forking out £2500 under these circumstances, the goodwill should be extended to cover labour costs..if they dont I'd consider small claims.

However before then he needs the cause of the fault, the cost of replacement parts, full workshop history details and some serious negotiation.

These engines dont go kaput as a matter of routine and its probably of more interest to BMW than the dealership as to the reason why....