335i/335d buying advise
Discussion
Hi guys,
Hope you can help me. I did a bit of a search about but can't find exactly what I need.
I have a budget of 10k, maybe a little over.
Currently I'm considering the 335i, 335d or something completely different, the EVO8
Anyway, it's more likely to be the 335i or d but I have some concerns.
From your experience is the d the more reliable car?
I'm also unsure about if I'd want paddleshift or manual, I guess only a test drive would tell me that right?
What should I look out for on a test drive?
I will end up modding either car for more power.
Thanks in advance
Hope you can help me. I did a bit of a search about but can't find exactly what I need.
I have a budget of 10k, maybe a little over.
Currently I'm considering the 335i, 335d or something completely different, the EVO8
Anyway, it's more likely to be the 335i or d but I have some concerns.
From your experience is the d the more reliable car?
I'm also unsure about if I'd want paddleshift or manual, I guess only a test drive would tell me that right?
What should I look out for on a test drive?
I will end up modding either car for more power.
Thanks in advance
teamshock nick said:
Hi guys,
Hope you can help me. I did a bit of a search about but can't find exactly what I need.
I have a budget of 10k, maybe a little over.
Currently I'm considering the 335i, 335d or something completely different, the EVO8
Anyway, it's more likely to be the 335i or d but I have some concerns.
From your experience is the d the more reliable car?
I'm also unsure about if I'd want paddleshift or manual, I guess only a test drive would tell me that right?
What should I look out for on a test drive?
I will end up modding either car for more power.
Thanks in advance
Unless your miles are high, I'd say minimum over 20k , pa, why would the d be a consideration?Hope you can help me. I did a bit of a search about but can't find exactly what I need.
I have a budget of 10k, maybe a little over.
Currently I'm considering the 335i, 335d or something completely different, the EVO8
Anyway, it's more likely to be the 335i or d but I have some concerns.
From your experience is the d the more reliable car?
I'm also unsure about if I'd want paddleshift or manual, I guess only a test drive would tell me that right?
What should I look out for on a test drive?
I will end up modding either car for more power.
Thanks in advance
I have a N54 engined 335i, 2009 (59) at 83k which has only had injectors replaced when the car was running rough so no actual breakdown
; from my research, prior to purchase, greater unreliability was on earlier cars. But consider that the internet can give a negative impression of these cars as people report problems more than good news. As my recent part ex offer was 10k, I'd say this was the sort or car within your budget if you bought privately, at least. So my tips for a trouble free 23.5k miles were.
check maintenance history and makes sure no major problems. Mine had none. Some people think it's better car has had problems and those problems fixed, but I know of cases where problems repeat.
Ideally it will have full BMW Main dealer history and / or good specialist.
Test drive several, I am a manual fan and in fact the first car I drove had a modified short shift box and it was delicious, but the cars hight torque meaning lots of thrust in higher gears doesn't allow the same involvement as a N/a manual. I was therefore alive to getting an auto BUT (and this is a key negative for 335d with only this option) hated the steptronic.
I have the DCT, available on cars from 2009 model year , so late 58 plate onwards. I'd say this is best of both worlds, as involving in manual mode as a two pedal car can be, and then in auto it feels less like an auto and more like you have a racing driver making changes for you, particularly in sport mode. NB:- if you test drive, make sure you engage sport mode, try manual mode and press sport button.
Cheers
No real reason for the d to be honest, i guess to keep running costs down and reliability up (if that is the case)
I work about 8 miles from home and im changing from a PD150 GT TDI golf to whatever i get next
Something more juicy is now an option as I dont have as far to travel for work.
No real reason for the d to be honest, i guess to keep running costs down and reliability up (if that is the case)
I work about 8 miles from home and im changing from a PD150 GT TDI golf to whatever i get next
Something more juicy is now an option as I dont have as far to travel for work.
teamshock nick said:
whats servicing like on them?
i don't have my invoices to hand, but what I pay now is on a par with what I have paid on a more ordinary BMW. Nothing particularly costly or major.The I drive flags up what's needed when, say for example an oil service or brake pads front or rear and then you attend to those items that's all. I have not found my 23k miles expensive. I do a lot of short journeys and average 23 mpg but I do make the most of the power and drive in sport mode or manual mode.
Not contradicting the above, but when buying one have a look at where it's at on I drive as if,say, there are services due you might get something off. Or as I did, I made sure everything was up to date and had a year without any such running costs

Not all have I drive, but computer would give info ; better CIC I drive came in during 2009. I drive means nav and a nice graphic for any parking sensors.
335D turbo hoses often give up but overall the 335D has a much better reliability reputation than the i. However the i is a bit quicker, sounds far better, can be had with a manual box and is a healthy 45 kilos lighter. 45kg doesn't sound much but the heavier block and auto box mean the extra weight is all over the front axle. 335i handles better.
Things to look for.........get one that's had its water pump changed. They go in the 60-80k miles region. Check wastegate rattle; rev the engine to 4k whilst in neutral, then release the throttle and let revs decay back to idle speed. There are several you tube vids to let you know what to listen out for. The wastegate wear has to be very severe before performance suffers.
Brake hydro units are a weak point on D and i its worth finding one that has this replaced or repaired. £2k= to have this done by main dealers.
High pressure fuel pumps are a weak area, this can have knock on effects for the injectors. Ignition coils can go intermittent giving occasional misfire.
VANOS solenoids can become sticky, can be cleaned easily but they're very cheap and easy to replace.
They're very quick with a good map, have had an Evolve map on mine for 5 years. They did the engine work on my old E36 M3 too, great maps and good guys to deal with.
Huge amount of info about N54/N55 here........... http://www.n54tech.com/forums/
Things to look for.........get one that's had its water pump changed. They go in the 60-80k miles region. Check wastegate rattle; rev the engine to 4k whilst in neutral, then release the throttle and let revs decay back to idle speed. There are several you tube vids to let you know what to listen out for. The wastegate wear has to be very severe before performance suffers.
Brake hydro units are a weak point on D and i its worth finding one that has this replaced or repaired. £2k= to have this done by main dealers.
High pressure fuel pumps are a weak area, this can have knock on effects for the injectors. Ignition coils can go intermittent giving occasional misfire.
VANOS solenoids can become sticky, can be cleaned easily but they're very cheap and easy to replace.
They're very quick with a good map, have had an Evolve map on mine for 5 years. They did the engine work on my old E36 M3 too, great maps and good guys to deal with.
Huge amount of info about N54/N55 here........... http://www.n54tech.com/forums/
Edited by Crackie on Thursday 7th April 22:27
teamshock nick said:
Hi guys,
Hope you can help me. I did a bit of a search about but can't find exactly what I need.
I have a budget of 10k, maybe a little over.
Currently I'm considering the 335i, 335d or something completely different, the EVO8
Anyway, it's more likely to be the 335i or d but I have some concerns.
From your experience is the d the more reliable car?
I'm also unsure about if I'd want paddleshift or manual, I guess only a test drive would tell me that right?
What should I look out for on a test drive?
I will end up modding either car for more power.
Thanks in advance
I have run a 57 Plate E90 335i M Sport Auto for aprox. 18 months. Picked the car up with aprox. 40k miles on it.Hope you can help me. I did a bit of a search about but can't find exactly what I need.
I have a budget of 10k, maybe a little over.
Currently I'm considering the 335i, 335d or something completely different, the EVO8
Anyway, it's more likely to be the 335i or d but I have some concerns.
From your experience is the d the more reliable car?
I'm also unsure about if I'd want paddleshift or manual, I guess only a test drive would tell me that right?
What should I look out for on a test drive?
I will end up modding either car for more power.
Thanks in advance
In that time (Car now has 53k) I have had done....
Injectors Replaced (under warranty)
Wastegate Actuators replaced
High Pressure Fuel Pump Replaced
Turbo Pressure regulators replaced
But.... now all that has been done (all under warranty apart from the HPFP which I am still in dispute with BMW over) the car is superb ;-)
So if you fancy a very high spec 335i M Sport saloon that's had the main issues sorted then give me a nudge as I need a bigger motor for the expanding family :-)
teamshock nick said:
ive heard the older N something number engine was less reliable than the newer one
Do you know what year the engine changed over?
2010, April same as the facelift for coupes it became N55 instead of N54. Do you know what year the engine changed over?
But I'd certainly say 2009 N54s as per mine and my first post are not necessarily unreliable and I still believe N54s are better for tuning which I think was in your plans.
What spec, colour, body style you after?
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


