E70 X5 strange steering judder - help!
E70 X5 strange steering judder - help!
Author
Discussion

bluepony

Original Poster:

171 posts

222 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
The car is 5 yrs old and 90,000. I collected it from the dealer (independent) last week. I noticed when I made tight maneuvers that there was a vibration/ judder and mentioned this to the seller. He said it was a normal feature of X drive.

However I am convinced it is NOT! I had the previous generation X5 and it didn't do it. I have driven the new generation and it doesn't either.

It "feels" like the front diff is locked - like when you leave an old 4x4 in 4WD and then try and steer tight on tarmac - they don't like it and it feels like one of the wheels is being 'dragged".

I sent it to an independent BMW garage and they can't find anything wrong and say it is normal. I don't accept that. I've driven hundreds of cars and dozens of BMWs and none has felt like this.

Has anyone got experience of this?

As an aside, the garage I bought it from are happy to try to resolve the situation!

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
Never heard of it before, but if it's on lock, I would suspect diff related.

eniacs

208 posts

171 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
Mine does this as well, on slow speed turns on high/full lock. I've seen it called cupping befor as it wears the tyres on their edge badly. Normal as far as I am aware, or at least I'm not going to spend money fixing it as mine has been doing it harmlessly (aside from the tyre wear) for 20k miles.

bluepony

Original Poster:

171 posts

222 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
eniacs said:
Mine does this as well, on slow speed turns on high/full lock. I've seen it called cupping befor as it wears the tyres on their edge badly. Normal as far as I am aware, or at least I'm not going to spend money fixing it as mine has been doing it harmlessly (aside from the tyre wear) for 20k miles.
How odd. Surely it shouldn't? I saw a US forum which indicated old oil in the transfer box and/or transfer box problems...