Advice on a used 3-Series estate - budget of £4,000.00.
Advice on a used 3-Series estate - budget of £4,000.00.
Author
Discussion

elsmandino

Original Poster:

30 posts

139 months

Wednesday 13th April 2016
quotequote all
Hello,

I am on the lookout for a BMW 3-series estate (up to £4,000) and would be really grateful for what to consider (mileage, engine size, fuel type, age, transmission type etc.).

Ideally, it needs to not be too thirsty (I have a young son now, so my ragging days are behind me) and is going to be doing around 10,000 miles per year, mainly in town.

Any pointers would be much appreciated.

Thanks

pattyg

1,385 posts

258 months

Wednesday 13th April 2016
quotequote all
I like this

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/BMW-320I-SE-TOURING-ESTA...

Wee bit leggy but seems decent for the money

JakeT

6,002 posts

151 months

Wednesday 13th April 2016
quotequote all
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...

Smooth 6 cyl, and £750 left over for a good going over at some point.

The E91 has an EML, and an intermittent misfire according to the advert.

Mr Tidy

31,941 posts

158 months

Thursday 14th April 2016
quotequote all
For your budget I would avoid E91 models and look for a good E46!

E91s have run-flat tyres (expensive) and the 4 cylinder diesels have the N47 engines with potential cam-chain issues. 6 cylinder petrols are great fun, but use N52 engines which have electric water pumps that cost about £340 from ECP (+ fitting).

Only downside is that E46 models can have rust issues, particularly in the wheel-arches!

Good luck finding one that fits your needs.

jayemm89

4,475 posts

161 months

Thursday 14th April 2016
quotequote all
I would also advise E46, any six pot should be good, petrol is best. Rust can be an issue. I prefer the look of the sport models but truth be told the regular car is probably a smoother ride and maybe better for purpose

Edited by jayemm89 on Thursday 14th April 14:01

MikeGoodwin

3,917 posts

148 months

Thursday 14th April 2016
quotequote all
Mate had an E46 (estate) 320d manual SE. 230,000 miles on it. Brilliant car. Was a bit of a snotter as it was a company pool car and had seen better days, nice healthy dollop of torque, did 60 mpg on a run IIRC and was great fun really. Handling was good despite the body roll and was a nice barge the rest of the time. They were good enough to let me drive it for a few weeks while my car was fixed and frankly I really liked the thing. Happily have one now.

Id be after an E46 of some sort rather than the E9* models for that money.

elsmandino

Original Poster:

30 posts

139 months

Thursday 14th April 2016
quotequote all
Thanks to everyone for your comments - really helpful.

Does seem that an E46 is the way to go.

What sort of age and mileage do you think I should be looking for? As long as it has evidence of regular servicing, I would imagine a newer model with higher mileage would be the preference.

One other quick issue - sorry if this is a stupid question but when looking at used car sites, how can I tell that an estate is an E46? Seems that you cannot just rely on the registration date.

jayemm89

4,475 posts

161 months

Thursday 14th April 2016
quotequote all
elsmandino said:
Thanks to everyone for your comments - really helpful.

Does seem that an E46 is the way to go.

What sort of age and mileage do you think I should be looking for? As long as it has evidence of regular servicing, I would imagine a newer model with higher mileage would be the preference.

One other quick issue - sorry if this is a stupid question but when looking at used car sites, how can I tell that an estate is an E46? Seems that you cannot just rely on the registration date.
The shape - if you look up E36 and E92 estates, you'll see they're quite different. The E36 is much more closely related, but anything post 2000 is pretty much guaranteed to be an E46 at least (or newer)

The interior is the most heavily changed aspect of the cars from a modern perspective. The E36 feels very old, the 46 is reasonably modern, in my opinion anyway.

Mr Tidy

31,941 posts

158 months

Friday 15th April 2016
quotequote all
Hope you find one you like OP.

As has been said, E9* models look very different to E46s - just search for images!

If you do go E46 be aware that there was a facelift some time in 2003 when manual gearboxes changed from 5 speed to 6 speed, as the latter is way better if you do much motorway mileage. Obviously if you want an auto this is irrelevant!

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 15th April 2016
quotequote all
If you're going for an E46 look out for:

1. Weak cooling system.
2. Radiator bowed/sagging at the bottom.
2. Sticky front calipers.
3. Noisy DISA valve.

All the above were issues with my 330.

alistair267

218 posts

179 months

Friday 15th April 2016
quotequote all
I have an E46 330i Touring on a 53 plate, which is post-facelift and so has the 6 speed rather than 5 speed gearbox. Check the build date which is on a plate on top of one of the wheel arches under the bonnet. Mine IIRC is October 2003.

I get 35ish mpg on a steady motorway cruise, 15-20 around London where I live, mainly stuck in a traffic jam.

As has been said before, check:

(1) rust especially in wheel arches
(2) cooling system especially radiator bowing at the bottom
(3) check rear wiper/washer work
(4) if looking at a petrol 6 cylinder, ask the seller how much oil it uses. From what I've read they do tend to use oil which in itself is not worrying unless seller looks shifty when asked - either it's a lot or he (she) never checks it

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Friday 15th April 2016
quotequote all
£4000 will buy a really decent E91 320d estate. Avoid the 320i as they're a waste of time, horrid N46 bks plus coil pack issues. The E91 drives superbly, doesn't rust and looks modern. They have a few issues - ECU's can drown if the E box fills with rain water (make drilling a big hole in the base your first task), the odd door lock etc but they're a good car.

E46's need caution. As well as the rust, the tailgate glass hatch hinges can snap if they aren't lubricated with WD40 on a regular basis. 6 cyl petrols are nice, 320d's okay if they're aren't shagged. Avoid the 318i N42/46 like the plague. A good E46 is a nice car - it's finding a nice one that can be a problem. That bluey green 320i looks sweet enough.

stevesuk

1,377 posts

213 months

Friday 15th April 2016
quotequote all
My advice would be to go for an E90 (well, E91) if you can stretch your budget - and also steer clear of the 4 cylinder petrol engines (I understand they're more problematic than the 6 cylinder).

Our 11 year old E91 is still on its original water pump, thermostat, radiator etc. (although I've probably jinxed it now!). In fact, in nearly 7 years of our ownership, the only non-routine repair its needed was a rear wheel bearing.. Still drives fine, everything still working inside and out, and no rust.

Having owned a couple of E46 coupes, the E91 feels like a newer more modern car - for better or worse of course smile

However, the problem might be finding a good one within your budget...

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Friday 15th April 2016
quotequote all
I love my BMWs, I have had loads of tourings, E30 325i, E36 328i, E46 320d, 330d, 330i, E39 528i, 530d, 530i, 530i, E61 535d, E91 335i and 320d.

They are great every day cars that can be quite fun too.

However, with a £4k budget, I would also consider a Merc, they have much stronger suspension parts and tend to age better. I bought a C320 Sport Edition Estate recently and it feels superb still. I looked at loads of E91s and E61s and all up to £7k were feeling really tired.

I bought an Audi first, but christ it was horrible!!

Don't write off a C Class estate, they are very good.


This is pretty much identical to what I bought, but with some scuffed wheels, and a couple of small dings for £4500.
100k with Full Merc history, 2006, with the sweet 3 litre engine and 7g gearbox.
Better MPG then the pre Efficient Dynamics 3 series as well, they came around the 57 plate by the way.
I see 37mpg average and 43/44 on longer journeys.