E36 track pads, recommendations based on experience only
Discussion
I am after peoples experience in the use of track pads for a E36 328 running standard calipers. Ive searched and the majority of posts and information states "you need to upgrade to e46 disc and pads mate" or "my wife's cousins dogs friend runs EBC yellows and they are great"! I am just after honest opinions from experiences not stories about how good the brakes are on your 1.2 nova.
so far I have found:
EBC yellows - some people say great some people say pants. I had them on my road car years ago and thought they were ok what are they really like on track?
DS2500 or DS300 - liking the look of these and are fairly priced, but do they last with track driving
mintex 1155 - not read great things but anyone used them
hawk range - USA forums seem to rate them
PFC - had these on my evo but only did a couple of track days do they last well
carbone Lorraine - had these on the evo also and squealed constantly even on track
any other recommendations would be good
thanks
so far I have found:
EBC yellows - some people say great some people say pants. I had them on my road car years ago and thought they were ok what are they really like on track?
DS2500 or DS300 - liking the look of these and are fairly priced, but do they last with track driving
mintex 1155 - not read great things but anyone used them
hawk range - USA forums seem to rate them
PFC - had these on my evo but only did a couple of track days do they last well
carbone Lorraine - had these on the evo also and squealed constantly even on track
any other recommendations would be good
thanks
I use either Pagid RS29 or Ferodo DS Uno, but I am on 4-pot AP calipers 0n e46 330 discs.
I understand what you say about opinions wanted from standard calipers & discs, but either way we are both braking the same car of the same weight.
On a car that (relatively) heavy as compared to a Caterfield/small hatch etc DO NOT USE EBC UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES on track, they will not last a full day at any circuit with heavy braking zones, and they cost over £100/set for the fronts.
DS2500 are OK, but only last 2 days at same track.
DS3000 are better but DO need warming up.
Having tried everything except CL I keep coming back to the above as they last 2 years of track days for me.
Yes they cost £230+vat for the fronts, but you do the maths.
EBC yellow £115/track day if you are lucky, + 1 hour under the car every track day + new discs every year.
Pagid RS 29 £250 for 12 - 20 days on the same discs.
I understand what you say about opinions wanted from standard calipers & discs, but either way we are both braking the same car of the same weight.
On a car that (relatively) heavy as compared to a Caterfield/small hatch etc DO NOT USE EBC UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES on track, they will not last a full day at any circuit with heavy braking zones, and they cost over £100/set for the fronts.
DS2500 are OK, but only last 2 days at same track.
DS3000 are better but DO need warming up.
Having tried everything except CL I keep coming back to the above as they last 2 years of track days for me.
Yes they cost £230+vat for the fronts, but you do the maths.
EBC yellow £115/track day if you are lucky, + 1 hour under the car every track day + new discs every year.
Pagid RS 29 £250 for 12 - 20 days on the same discs.
I run Brembo OE discs and Mintex 1155 pads up front and 1144 at the rear and they are great.
I should qualify this though as I have re-read your OP. These are on a BMW Compact Cup car so 150ish bhp and it weighs in somewhere around 1100kgs with me and fuel on board.
I should qualify this though as I have re-read your OP. These are on a BMW Compact Cup car so 150ish bhp and it weighs in somewhere around 1100kgs with me and fuel on board.
Edited by geeks on Monday 18th April 12:51
Used Carbone Lorraine RC5+, RC6 and DS3000 in the past. All on M3 discs/calipers, with a decent amount of cooling provided. No ABS.
DS3000 and RC5+ were about the same, more dust from the DS3000 but not really an issue. I don't get any noise from RC5+, have in the past but it seems the noise comes back when they are not heat cycled correctly.
RC6 were worse from the off (as expected being a harder compound), but slightly better once hot. Made noise when cold, fine when hot. Cost more overall... in the end I'm now back on RC5+ all round and they do the job for the setup of the car, I've never thought "I need better brakes" with any of the three pads.
DS3000 and RC5+ were about the same, more dust from the DS3000 but not really an issue. I don't get any noise from RC5+, have in the past but it seems the noise comes back when they are not heat cycled correctly.
RC6 were worse from the off (as expected being a harder compound), but slightly better once hot. Made noise when cold, fine when hot. Cost more overall... in the end I'm now back on RC5+ all round and they do the job for the setup of the car, I've never thought "I need better brakes" with any of the three pads.
Much depends on price, I'm a fan of the much berated yellows on e36 simply as if you get them at the race price which was something like £100 fronts & rears delivered last set I got and sort out proper brake cooling they cope OK on a stripped car even on slicks- Sub 8 'ring & 3min spa pace anyway oh & are v kind to discs, are they the best? No not close, but for the budget I can cope, I wouldn't pay full whack retail for them tho.
Far more expensive offerings are better yes, but a set of rs29 are huge money in comparison at over £400
Midrange I've tried the rc6 & mintex 1155, I liked both.
I don't think you have to upgrade from stock 328 sizes either, you can & would help but it's not utterly imperative, just use good discs ATE, Bosch etc not some crappy drilled rubbish off eBay.
Far more expensive offerings are better yes, but a set of rs29 are huge money in comparison at over £400
Midrange I've tried the rc6 & mintex 1155, I liked both.
I don't think you have to upgrade from stock 328 sizes either, you can & would help but it's not utterly imperative, just use good discs ATE, Bosch etc not some crappy drilled rubbish off eBay.
On standard calipers I have personally used:
EBC Yellow (Race car E36 and E36 Daily)
EBC Blue (Race car)
DS 2500 (Daily)
DS 3000 (Race car AP 4 pots E46 M3 Floating discs)
If used for trackdays all pads need brake cooling, the more the merrier.
Having gone through many sets of EBCs I wish i would have used the DS range sooner.
It really is the more they cost the better they are.
Standard pads (£30ish), aren't as good as EBCs (£80ish), which aren't as good as Ferodo DS (£140) which arent as good as the Pagid RS Range (not that i have used them though).
If you are flush get Pagid RS Range, if you are less so get the Ferodo DS range, now that I have used them, all my dailys in the future will be getting DS 2500 and keep the DS 3000 for the race & Trackdays, EBCs feel like micky mouse pads in comparison.
EBC Yellow (Race car E36 and E36 Daily)
EBC Blue (Race car)
DS 2500 (Daily)
DS 3000 (Race car AP 4 pots E46 M3 Floating discs)
If used for trackdays all pads need brake cooling, the more the merrier.
Having gone through many sets of EBCs I wish i would have used the DS range sooner.
It really is the more they cost the better they are.
Standard pads (£30ish), aren't as good as EBCs (£80ish), which aren't as good as Ferodo DS (£140) which arent as good as the Pagid RS Range (not that i have used them though).
If you are flush get Pagid RS Range, if you are less so get the Ferodo DS range, now that I have used them, all my dailys in the future will be getting DS 2500 and keep the DS 3000 for the race & Trackdays, EBCs feel like micky mouse pads in comparison.
I'd agree pretty much with what has been said already by some knowledgeable E36 owners.
Cooling will give you endurance and should be no.1 priority, no matter the pads.
Personally I have used on a stripped E36, no cage + std. calipers/disks:
EBC Blue NDX (front + rear) - reasonable feel, no fade (used with cooling in the front) 10+ laps of Bedford GT, no squeal, wear rate within 1K track miles. Rears last up to 1.2K track miles with a bit of cooling.
EBC Orange (front + blue rear) - feel is noticeably more wooden, more abrasive to discs, no fade (as above) 10+ laps as above, no squeal, wear rate TBC, currently above 1K track miles.
Personally I feel EBC are ok on a budget. The wear rate is pretty high if you are aggressive on the stoppers, or don't use cooling, but with cooling do not feel inadequate at arresting the car from 130Mph+.
If budget is higher, no question RC's Pagid's PF's, etc. are worth exploring imo.
Cooling will give you endurance and should be no.1 priority, no matter the pads.
Personally I have used on a stripped E36, no cage + std. calipers/disks:
EBC Blue NDX (front + rear) - reasonable feel, no fade (used with cooling in the front) 10+ laps of Bedford GT, no squeal, wear rate within 1K track miles. Rears last up to 1.2K track miles with a bit of cooling.
EBC Orange (front + blue rear) - feel is noticeably more wooden, more abrasive to discs, no fade (as above) 10+ laps as above, no squeal, wear rate TBC, currently above 1K track miles.
Personally I feel EBC are ok on a budget. The wear rate is pretty high if you are aggressive on the stoppers, or don't use cooling, but with cooling do not feel inadequate at arresting the car from 130Mph+.
If budget is higher, no question RC's Pagid's PF's, etc. are worth exploring imo.
Edited by Humour on Thursday 5th May 14:49
I have used EBC yellows for the last 10 years on two E36 track cars on various circuits, 'Ring included, and they've always been fine. Admittedly I'm not that heavy on brakes but they work nicely when you can feel a standard road pad going off. They also work well from cold.
I've only ever run 318iS cars btw.
I've only ever run 318iS cars btw.
Edited by iSore on Thursday 5th May 18:08
BullyB said:
E-bmw said:
You really should try the Pagids Bully, they last me up to 2 years of track days (around 20) and are kind to the discs too, yes they make dust, and cost 2 x the EBCs, but they are massively superior.
cheers, I'm thinking of trying these nextHumour
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



