High mileage 130i
Discussion
Afternoon all,
Running a 2006 130i 98k on the clock and owned for just over a year and has been perfect up until now. In only the last 3 months have had some rather rotten luck in that I have had the following repairs -
Vanos issues / Camshaft correlation fault - £800
Timing chain checked and within limits, New Chain tensioner.
New DMF and Clutch - £1,000
New Alternator - £500-600
Question is shall I get rid asap before it costs me anymore cash or stick with it knowing that some major issues have now been replaced and I have spent so much money on it..?
Are there any other major issues to be wary of at this age and mileage?
All your thoughts appreciated, don't want this great little car to turn into a money pit!
Thanks
Running a 2006 130i 98k on the clock and owned for just over a year and has been perfect up until now. In only the last 3 months have had some rather rotten luck in that I have had the following repairs -
Vanos issues / Camshaft correlation fault - £800
Timing chain checked and within limits, New Chain tensioner.
New DMF and Clutch - £1,000
New Alternator - £500-600
Question is shall I get rid asap before it costs me anymore cash or stick with it knowing that some major issues have now been replaced and I have spent so much money on it..?
Are there any other major issues to be wary of at this age and mileage?
All your thoughts appreciated, don't want this great little car to turn into a money pit!
Thanks
briantherobot said:
Afternoon all,
Running a 2006 130i 98k on the clock and owned for just over a year and has been perfect up until now. In only the last 3 months have had some rather rotten luck in that I have had the following repairs -
Vanos issues / Camshaft correlation fault - £800
Timing chain checked and within limits, New Chain tensioner.
New DMF and Clutch - £1,000
New Alternator - £500-600
Question is shall I get rid asap before it costs me anymore cash or stick with it knowing that some major issues have now been replaced and I have spent so much money on it..?
Are there any other major issues to be wary of at this age and mileage?
All your thoughts appreciated, don't want this great little car to turn into a money pit!
Thanks
In my experience it only gets worse and by virtue of the fact you've posted on here it would appear you're starting to lose faith. On one hand you want to keep the car because you feel you've invested in its upkeep and want a return on that, but you're scared the investment will be endless. For me it just becomes a worry every time you drive it. You start thinking of the worst all the time and it just ruins the experience of owning something you once loved. Running a 2006 130i 98k on the clock and owned for just over a year and has been perfect up until now. In only the last 3 months have had some rather rotten luck in that I have had the following repairs -
Vanos issues / Camshaft correlation fault - £800
Timing chain checked and within limits, New Chain tensioner.
New DMF and Clutch - £1,000
New Alternator - £500-600
Question is shall I get rid asap before it costs me anymore cash or stick with it knowing that some major issues have now been replaced and I have spent so much money on it..?
Are there any other major issues to be wary of at this age and mileage?
All your thoughts appreciated, don't want this great little car to turn into a money pit!
Thanks
I would advise selling it while you can and with a clear conscience rather than selling it with further faults that may occur which are not in your interest to repair.
The problem is that your next car may be one as I've described above and you are inheriting someone else's unloved problem child. A bit of a catch 22 really. You could always lease or PCP with the safety net of warranty and a brand new car if it's affordable/ appropriate for your current circumstances.
Another month, another thread.
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
This suggests you've decided you want out. In which case, sell it.
Personally, having spent the money on it, I'd keep it unless I felt I was ready for a change. The 130i does what it does very well indeed.
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
This suggests you've decided you want out. In which case, sell it.
Personally, having spent the money on it, I'd keep it unless I felt I was ready for a change. The 130i does what it does very well indeed.
I do find that we are very forgiving of the German brands when it comes to reliability and serious faults. Don't know how they've earned so much goodwill credit from us.
We have a Toyota and Mazda in our family, yes they're not as dynamic, but repair bills are almost non existant. It shouldn't be that hard for the German's to follow suit, but you know these companies have entire teams dedicated to "Perceived Quality" and it seems to be working. The gap between perceived and actual quality is bigger than ever right now. My mate has a 1 series coupe that's less than 4 years old and it's been sitting on his drive for a few weeks awaiting repairs. It was a good daily for 3 years and now one thing after another fails. It's not even for 70k miles on it (our Toyota and Mazda are 158k and 120k in comparison).
Statistics don't lie: http://www.reliabilityindex.com/manufacturer
BMW placed 28/38, Audi Merc 31 and 33, Porsche bottom 3 (i thought it was more reliable than this!).
With the death of naturally aspirated engines, none of these cars will manage over 100k reliably. They're just too complicated.
We have a Toyota and Mazda in our family, yes they're not as dynamic, but repair bills are almost non existant. It shouldn't be that hard for the German's to follow suit, but you know these companies have entire teams dedicated to "Perceived Quality" and it seems to be working. The gap between perceived and actual quality is bigger than ever right now. My mate has a 1 series coupe that's less than 4 years old and it's been sitting on his drive for a few weeks awaiting repairs. It was a good daily for 3 years and now one thing after another fails. It's not even for 70k miles on it (our Toyota and Mazda are 158k and 120k in comparison).
Statistics don't lie: http://www.reliabilityindex.com/manufacturer
BMW placed 28/38, Audi Merc 31 and 33, Porsche bottom 3 (i thought it was more reliable than this!).
With the death of naturally aspirated engines, none of these cars will manage over 100k reliably. They're just too complicated.
Edited by silent ninja on Sunday 17th April 12:38
Thanks guys all helpful,
The trade in values are absolutely horrific -went to see a bog standard focus zetec 55 plate today and he offered a swap deal and only 600 quid my way!
These cars do certainly have a hold over us because even now I can't help thinking what an amazing little car, but head has ruled heart and it it definitely got to go. Such a shame but these things happen!
Let's just hope I can get rid before something else catostrophic goes wrong.
Back to ford or something Japanese.
The trade in values are absolutely horrific -went to see a bog standard focus zetec 55 plate today and he offered a swap deal and only 600 quid my way!
These cars do certainly have a hold over us because even now I can't help thinking what an amazing little car, but head has ruled heart and it it definitely got to go. Such a shame but these things happen!
Let's just hope I can get rid before something else catostrophic goes wrong.
Back to ford or something Japanese.
Personally I would keep hold of it for longer as you have just spent out on some costly items, 98k is not high miles for that engine providing it has been looked after. You obviously bought the 130i wanting a more sporty drive otherwise you wouldn't have gone for the 3 litre straight 6.
Changing the car for bog standard hatch back will make you miss a the drive of the 130 for sure!
Changing the car for bog standard hatch back will make you miss a the drive of the 130 for sure!
briantherobot said:
The trade in values are absolutely horrific -went to see a bog standard focus zetec 55 plate today and he offered a swap deal and only 600 quid my way!
Let's just hope I can get rid before something else catostrophic goes wrong.
With respect:Let's just hope I can get rid before something else catostrophic goes wrong.
(a) you're never going to get a decent price for it by trading it in for a cheaper car; and
(b) none of the things you list in your OP are "catastrophic". It's mostly just routine stuff and / or known issues.
Is 98k really high mileage? It's a 10 year old car, so I'd say it's probably average isn't it? And at an age where it's going to need more maintenance... I'd put up with the cost for the rwd and the straight six engine!!
If you want to see high mileage, take a look at how many miles the A2 I bought a couple of weeks ago has done!!

If you want to see high mileage, take a look at how many miles the A2 I bought a couple of weeks ago has done!!

Sorry to hear of your problems OP. 
And I can see why you are torn between keeping it to get some benefit from the work done, and shifting it before something else goes wrong.
Without wanting to make things worse, I have a Z4 Coupe with the same N52 engine and last December the electric water pump died (at 9 years old and 60K miles, which seems to be typical lifespan for them). The OEM part is £500! (ECP quote £340) but then there is fitting too, so I am starting to feel like you as it is now due a service and brake fluid change!
Shame, as when it is in good health the N52 engine is just fantastic!
Hope it works out for you whatever you decide.

And I can see why you are torn between keeping it to get some benefit from the work done, and shifting it before something else goes wrong.
Without wanting to make things worse, I have a Z4 Coupe with the same N52 engine and last December the electric water pump died (at 9 years old and 60K miles, which seems to be typical lifespan for them). The OEM part is £500! (ECP quote £340) but then there is fitting too, so I am starting to feel like you as it is now due a service and brake fluid change!
Shame, as when it is in good health the N52 engine is just fantastic!
Hope it works out for you whatever you decide.
silent ninja said:
I do find that we are very forgiving of the German brands when it comes to reliability and serious faults. Don't know how they've earned so much goodwill credit from us.
Because so many people lease them from new so don't have to put up with the reality of mechanical failures on older cars?OP: It's a 10 year-old car and it's done 98k miles. I'd be expecting to replace everything you've listed around that point in time - they're not indestructible and will break at some point. It's unfortunate that they've all gone in a relatively short space of time, no doubt, but that's luck more than anything else. I got stung for £800 a couple of weeks back for a new water pump on my 12 year-old, 76k miles BMW - but I was impressed more than anything that it had lasted that long without the bearings or gasket going south (not impressed it blew up whilst I was driving and went full bukkake with the coolant, but c'est la vie).
Too often people seem to forget that premium cars at bargain prices still need premium price maintenance. I'm no expert on the 130i of that vintage, but I'd check the Internet for the major, commonly known faults of the car and get an idea of prices. If they're too rich for your blood, be rid of the car now. If they're not (or better yet, have already been addressed) keep the car, don't stress and get back to enjoying it.

I get what people are saying about getting rid however you've had, as I understand it, the big pieces of work now done i.e. VANOS and ensuring the chain isn't about to kill itself. So the theory would be that you shouldn't have any further large expenses for a significant period of time.
Theophany said:
Because so many people lease them from new so don't have to put up with the reality of mechanical failures on older cars?
That doesn't really say anything. Most of the cars on the road are NOT new or within the 3 year warranty period. You shoukd be looking at the average lifespan of a car, which is probably around 10-12 years, then asking why some brands are so far ahead of the pack whilst others regularly fail especially in key mechanical areas, yet are put on a pedestal. I think badge power on marketing have brainwashed us.silent ninja said:
That doesn't really say anything. Most of the cars on the road are NOT new or within the 3 year warranty period. You shoukd be looking at the average lifespan of a car, which is probably around 10-12 years, then asking why some brands are so far ahead of the pack whilst others regularly fail especially in key mechanical areas, yet are put on a pedestal. I think badge power on marketing have brainwashed us.
I don't disagree with you, just suggesting a possible reason as to why people are conditioned into believing such things. 
OP - I'd think long and hard about what you might find to replace it. I've said it a few times but I can't think of anything I'd rather have for £15k let alone what you likely paid for yours.
Mine is 9 years old and has just gone past 125k miles, it's been very cheap to run and I reckon they are almost depreciation proof now. Touch wood but it's still on original clutch/water pump/suspension, no VANOS issues and no sqeeks/rattles. It's only had a DSC unit, a couple of Xenon issues and a seized rear caliper outside of normal servicing/consumables.
Going to renew the shocks soon since they will need doing eventually and I'd rather gain the benefit for as long as possible rather than waiting for them to fail.
Great cars with bags of character in a world full of fast but dull 4 pot turbo hatches.
Mine is 9 years old and has just gone past 125k miles, it's been very cheap to run and I reckon they are almost depreciation proof now. Touch wood but it's still on original clutch/water pump/suspension, no VANOS issues and no sqeeks/rattles. It's only had a DSC unit, a couple of Xenon issues and a seized rear caliper outside of normal servicing/consumables.
Going to renew the shocks soon since they will need doing eventually and I'd rather gain the benefit for as long as possible rather than waiting for them to fail.
Great cars with bags of character in a world full of fast but dull 4 pot turbo hatches.
Thanks all for the comments.
As many have said the items I have repaired are all wear and tear issues just bad luck it was in small space of time.
At time of writing the car is running absolutely perfectly, no rattles, knocking, buzzing, nothing at all... Confidence slowly returning!
My eyes are peeled for possible replacements however as mentioned not much out there that can match the character and performance for the price!
As many have said the items I have repaired are all wear and tear issues just bad luck it was in small space of time.
At time of writing the car is running absolutely perfectly, no rattles, knocking, buzzing, nothing at all... Confidence slowly returning!
My eyes are peeled for possible replacements however as mentioned not much out there that can match the character and performance for the price!
I think sometimes you just get a perfect storm of failures when loads of things break or wear out at once. I found with my old 3 series a lot of things went tits up or wore out at around 100k miles - handbrake assembly rusted through and collapsed, front bushes/ball joints wore out, discs/pads on both axles, exhaust down pipe cracked, 2 broken rear springs, all within the space of about 18 months. Cost quite a bit at the time, but thereafter it ran happily until 180k when I sold it. Provided the rest of the car is sound I'd hang onto it - a lot of the expensive bits should now be safe and there's no guarantee you won't be buying something similarly problematic after unless you buy new.
silent ninja said:
I do find that we are very forgiving of the German brands when it comes to reliability and serious faults. Don't know how they've earned so much goodwill credit from us.
We have a Toyota and Mazda in our family, yes they're not as dynamic, but repair bills are almost non existant. It shouldn't be that hard for the German's to follow suit, but you know these companies have entire teams dedicated to "Perceived Quality" and it seems to be working. The gap between perceived and actual quality is bigger than ever right now. My mate has a 1 series coupe that's less than 4 years old and it's been sitting on his drive for a few weeks awaiting repairs. It was a good daily for 3 years and now one thing after another fails. It's not even for 70k miles on it (our Toyota and Mazda are 158k and 120k in comparison).
Statistics don't lie: http://www.reliabilityindex.com/manufacturer
BMW placed 28/38, Audi Merc 31 and 33, Porsche bottom 3 (i thought it was more reliable than this!).
With the death of naturally aspirated engines, none of these cars will manage over 100k reliably. They're just too complicated.
Spot on We have a Toyota and Mazda in our family, yes they're not as dynamic, but repair bills are almost non existant. It shouldn't be that hard for the German's to follow suit, but you know these companies have entire teams dedicated to "Perceived Quality" and it seems to be working. The gap between perceived and actual quality is bigger than ever right now. My mate has a 1 series coupe that's less than 4 years old and it's been sitting on his drive for a few weeks awaiting repairs. It was a good daily for 3 years and now one thing after another fails. It's not even for 70k miles on it (our Toyota and Mazda are 158k and 120k in comparison).
Statistics don't lie: http://www.reliabilityindex.com/manufacturer
BMW placed 28/38, Audi Merc 31 and 33, Porsche bottom 3 (i thought it was more reliable than this!).
With the death of naturally aspirated engines, none of these cars will manage over 100k reliably. They're just too complicated.
Edited by silent ninja on Sunday 17th April 12:38
its why the majority of my close family own Jap Honda & Toyota I am currently on my 1st Beemer a 2002 325 touring with 160k but I cherry picked this one and 18 months in its been fantastic but as you can imagine my cars get more than your average attention and service, the cars service folder mirrors this reliability history too but its clearly been cosseted, I am ex Honda so you can see why I have always swerved BMW's trouble is they offer so much for so little when they get older this was the attraction for me
however the pattern of me seeing many of the later cars with problems as not changed in fact its worse than ever .... fragile suspension and electrical woes generally
and with the tons of gadgets they install but we dont need that's unlikely to get any better 
Edited by Sardonicus on Monday 25th April 12:46
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




