Bmw n47- should I buy one
Discussion
Hi Pistonheads - hope you can help me a little.
For the past 7 years I've had 2 bmws, both x20ds and both have reached mileage well in to 100k with no major issues. Both have been the previous m47 engine. I'm now in a position where I could really do with an estate. Ideally I really want another 320d m sport, but I would now like to move up to the lci which includes the n47 engine. My last purchase I talked my self in to having a pre lci m sport saloon, as I wanted to avoid the timing chain issues and having no dpfs to have to worry about. I now find myself in a situation where I can no longer avoid modern diesels with dpfs. I now really want to take the next step and get a 58 plate onwards e91 m sport. But the dreaded timing chain issues still really concerns me. My budget would get me something with 80k +. High mileage doesn't concern me too much as my cars usually go well over 100k+. I expect things like turbos, clutches etc to need replacing. But a failed timing chain is a whole new league of expense.
I would really like to hear from people who have first hand experiences of these engines good or bad. Now being pistonheads I'm sure I will get comments from people who have absolutely no first hand experiences of these engines, but will still feel the need to post some useless comment, please don't!. There is already enough internet scare mongering available with out this post contributing un factually.
Please let me here of your experiences.
Thanks
For the past 7 years I've had 2 bmws, both x20ds and both have reached mileage well in to 100k with no major issues. Both have been the previous m47 engine. I'm now in a position where I could really do with an estate. Ideally I really want another 320d m sport, but I would now like to move up to the lci which includes the n47 engine. My last purchase I talked my self in to having a pre lci m sport saloon, as I wanted to avoid the timing chain issues and having no dpfs to have to worry about. I now find myself in a situation where I can no longer avoid modern diesels with dpfs. I now really want to take the next step and get a 58 plate onwards e91 m sport. But the dreaded timing chain issues still really concerns me. My budget would get me something with 80k +. High mileage doesn't concern me too much as my cars usually go well over 100k+. I expect things like turbos, clutches etc to need replacing. But a failed timing chain is a whole new league of expense.
I would really like to hear from people who have first hand experiences of these engines good or bad. Now being pistonheads I'm sure I will get comments from people who have absolutely no first hand experiences of these engines, but will still feel the need to post some useless comment, please don't!. There is already enough internet scare mongering available with out this post contributing un factually.
Please let me here of your experiences.
Thanks
My 120d auto 57 plate was scrapped in oct 14 7 years old 115000 miles timing chain went.18 months before at 90k the Turbo went.Both needed Towing 100 miles from home.A sevice manager at a group BMW dealership told me he would never buy one unless it was a 2013 /2014 model that had been updated,,,,mind you that conversation took place before the 57/59 updates took place( bmw said later models didnt need any recall which is crazy because even new shape 2012 models were having issues with noisy chains)
Edited by smashy on Saturday 14th May 22:58
Dpfs are quite reliable on the N47, often probs with them are caused by failing thermostats. The dreaded timing chain.....afraid they are problematic. Even some engines that have had new timing chains fitted by main dealers come back from the repair with free bonus oil leaks. If you can stretch to a 6 cylinder I would recommend it, if you go for an N47 perhaps a good warranty would be worthwhile. My comments are based on owning and fixing BMWs. I drive an old straight 6 petrol. Happy hunting.
I hope this helps - I bought an N47-engined 123d in January 2008 that was pre-registered in September 2007, so when I collected it the recorded mileage was 17!
I bought the Service Pack so it was serviced at approx. 18K intervals (I was doing enough mileage for time to not be a factor).
It needed a new battery (AGM so about £300!!) at 54K miles and a new starter motor at 77K (£600 at a main agent) but those are probably a result of the CO2 emission "enhancing" stop/start regime/b*llocks! Turned it off every time I used it after that!
I sold it with 81K miles on original brake pads, discs, wiper blades - great car!
But at that time BMW weren't being realistic/sensible with their reaction to cam-chain issues (see post above) plus I was out of warranty and not feeling lucky - and I was bored after 6+ years in a tractor!
If you can find one with full (and I mean full, not what traders call "full") BMW Service History you should be OK now as BMW seem to picking up the tab for religiously serviced ones.
Having said that I would recommend test driving a 130i before you commit - had I done that I would never have bought a diseasal!
I bought the Service Pack so it was serviced at approx. 18K intervals (I was doing enough mileage for time to not be a factor).
It needed a new battery (AGM so about £300!!) at 54K miles and a new starter motor at 77K (£600 at a main agent) but those are probably a result of the CO2 emission "enhancing" stop/start regime/b*llocks! Turned it off every time I used it after that!
I sold it with 81K miles on original brake pads, discs, wiper blades - great car!
But at that time BMW weren't being realistic/sensible with their reaction to cam-chain issues (see post above) plus I was out of warranty and not feeling lucky - and I was bored after 6+ years in a tractor!

If you can find one with full (and I mean full, not what traders call "full") BMW Service History you should be OK now as BMW seem to picking up the tab for religiously serviced ones.
Having said that I would recommend test driving a 130i before you commit - had I done that I would never have bought a diseasal!
We have had quite a few N47's in the family.
I ran a 118d for 120k miles with no problem.
I then ran a 123d for 100k miles with no problem.
My dad had a 320d for about 50k (taking it up to 150k) and that was fine.
My sister current has a 118d and that is fine too.
I don't think they are as unreliable as people say, the trouble is they have sold many of them that you are always going to get some issues.
I ran a 118d for 120k miles with no problem.
I then ran a 123d for 100k miles with no problem.
My dad had a 320d for about 50k (taking it up to 150k) and that was fine.
My sister current has a 118d and that is fine too.
I don't think they are as unreliable as people say, the trouble is they have sold many of them that you are always going to get some issues.
Thanks for the replys everyone. This is the sort of information that I need to know.
I'm sure the percentage of engines going bang compared to the amount sold is very tiny. Any engine can go pop at any time, it just seems that there was such big talk about the n47 it was just too hard to ignore.
If anyone else has any other experiences, it would be good to hear.
Thanks
I'm sure the percentage of engines going bang compared to the amount sold is very tiny. Any engine can go pop at any time, it just seems that there was such big talk about the n47 it was just too hard to ignore.
If anyone else has any other experiences, it would be good to hear.
Thanks
Wheatley173 said:
Thanks for the replys everyone. This is the sort of information that I need to know.
I'm sure the percentage of engines going bang compared to the amount sold is very tiny. Any engine can go pop at any time, it just seems that there was such big talk about the n47 it was just too hard to ignore.
If anyone else has any other experiences, it would be good to hear.
Thanks
According to BMW's own Service Info bulletin dated 15/01/2015,I'm sure the percentage of engines going bang compared to the amount sold is very tiny. Any engine can go pop at any time, it just seems that there was such big talk about the n47 it was just too hard to ignore.
If anyone else has any other experiences, it would be good to hear.
Thanks
http://www.e90post.com/forums/attachment.php?attac...
the first thing they say is to put the blame squarely on "exceeding maintenance intervals" and "deviations in oil quality" for the extended/stretched timing chains.
If that is to be believed, then why are so many cars with full main dealer service histories still needing the 'fix'?
If I were you, I would want cast iron proof that the rectification work had been done or I would simply walk away. As they have subsequently redesigned the faulty components, there was clearly an inherent weakness with ALL the original items, and imo, all owners without the modifications are simply playing Russian roulette. ;-)
It seems a bit Clint Eastwood "are you feeling lucky" - I didn't so I sold my 123d and bought a Z4 Coupe which then decided to have a shagged electric water pump - how much?!! Ouch!
Still it's less painful than a potential N47 cam-chain/crankshaft replacement, at least before BMW started picking up the tab (when it suited them)!....
Still it's less painful than a potential N47 cam-chain/crankshaft replacement, at least before BMW started picking up the tab (when it suited them)!....
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


