SOTW £2-2.5K
SOTW £2-2.5K
Author
Discussion

android

Original Poster:

979 posts

200 months

Tuesday 7th June 2016
quotequote all
Well the company barge (3 series F30) goes back in a few weeks - after 4 years at the tiller. Wish I had got the chance of a test drive before committing to 4 years of uninspiring blandness and electric power steering.
This is a compromise choice down to health and as I'm back on car allowance with a shorter term view on employment,looking for a waft able big-ish Auto Herman the G that's a bit more engaging and able to put a smile on your face.
So,is it e39 530i sport or 2004ish A4 2.5Tdi ?
Lunar mileage almost certainly part of the deal (not necessarily a bad thing).
Would appreciate your guidance and any case histories and potential money pit findings.

E-bmw

13,657 posts

183 months

Tuesday 7th June 2016
quotequote all
You will get as many opinions as posters on here, but for my 2p, having had one for 3 years e39 5301 Sport all day every day.

Get the manual, use only 2 gears, you have the ultimate driving machine (it is the car where the phrase was originally coined) you will get just under 30mpg all day every day, 6 sec to 60, whatever you want as a cruising speed, excellent comfort & superb handling.

Just either budget for or get one that has had all suspension bushes changed you will not regret it.

Had mine LPG converted & it then £/£ equated to 54mpg.

Maracus

4,553 posts

199 months

Tuesday 7th June 2016
quotequote all
The A4 2.5 TDI isn't the most frugal (according to the internet), and if it's a FWD it'll have the Multitronic CVT Auto which is a ticking time bomb.

530i all the way!

335d

758 posts

149 months

Tuesday 7th June 2016
quotequote all
While the E39 was a good car in its day (and I had a couple), if you are looking for something more fun to drive than an F30, I don't think either of your two suggested options could be considered entertaining. Competent certainly, but really not fun. I would aim for a smaller car if you want something that handles. Perhaps an E46, an old Golf GTI or even a quicker Ford Fiesta.