BMW Z3M Roadster or TVR chimaera
BMW Z3M Roadster or TVR chimaera
Author
Discussion

Chinski

Original Poster:

205 posts

184 months

Tuesday 7th June 2016
quotequote all
Which one? I've owned a chimaera in the past and enjoyed the whole experience. However I'm a huge BMW fan especially the Z3M roadster. Maybe I'm looking for the courage to take a chance on the BMW.

I'm love the idea of the every day use of the BMW and its power. Where as the TVR is move of a weekend car limiting the pleasure?

Any thoughts? I would also welcome any tips when looking at a Z3.

Thanks

citizen smith

817 posts

212 months

Wednesday 8th June 2016
quotequote all
Hi,

I can see where your coming from since a Z3M Roadster would make a very usable every day car.

Like yourself, I was in the same position way back in 2002 when the appeal of the car was more prolific. I traded in my 5 ltr Griff for a Z3M Roadster, since the appeal of the simplicity of the folding roof and the get up and go was a huge draw to me.

After less than a month of ownership, I realized that I had made a huge mistake and the "M,s" appeal had diminished. Then I just longed to be back behind the wheel of my old Griff, with it's intoxicating V8 burble and sheer GRUNT.

O.K., the "M Roadster" ticked all of it's boxes, but it was boring to me, plus it felt as though you did not sit in the car but purely sat on it!

The other problem with the "M" was the ride (especially on Motorways with ridges) and wind noise echoed through the soft top.

At the end of the day it's Horses for Courses, but have you consider a Z4M Roadster as an everyday car.

Regards,

Bill





cerb4.5lee

45,342 posts

211 months

Thursday 9th June 2016
quotequote all
I've had a TVR Cerbera and a Z4M Roadster and for me the TVR is the far more enjoyable/engaging car, the TVR sounds better and looks better(to my eyes) and has a far more sense of occasion and specialness about it.

The only thing the BMW does do better is reliability and everyday ease of use and for most that's good enough, the TVR will elicit smiles from others and will spark a conversation in petrol stations etc, the BMW won't.

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Thursday 9th June 2016
quotequote all
If this is to be your only car I would go for the BMW. If you have an 'every day driver' the TVR is perfect for weekends & summer.

JoyceyBoy

102 posts

155 months

Thursday 9th June 2016
quotequote all
Interesting dilemma. I sold my Z3M last summer to buy my first TVR so I can only really comment on the BMW.

The sound of the TVR wins hands down every time. Although I did get close when fitting a Hayward and Scott exhaust system to the Z3M. (Very deep burble)

The reliability of the BMW is fantastic and I did 30,000 miles in the two years, This included track days trip to Le'mans playing on the pod strip. I also found servicing the car very reasonably priced and easy to do at home.

I did make some tweaks to its setup in my ownership like changing the shocks and springs, fitting stiffer bushes and a strut brace to reduce the scuttle shake and found this made the car a real weapon.

The biggest things to look out for in these Z3M's is the Rear Diff hanger and Vanos. Both items can be sorted for sub 1K. The diff hanger has a tendency to break from its spot welds in the boot floor but there's various kits out there to fix this issue. The Vanos on the particular model I had (S50 Engine) develops a bag of marbles rattle which can be sorted by a visit from Dr/Mr Vanos.

Comparing it against the Cerbera I had, The TVR was an incredibly raw driving experience and an event every time I went out. Make the car a bit more reliable and sturdier add some driving aids and your at the Z3M.

I would strongly suggest to test drive a Z3M first because they are not your normal M car.

Image of my Z3M before I sold it.

Just my 2 pence worth smile


tonymor

1,554 posts

203 months

Thursday 9th June 2016
quotequote all
I've not driven a zed 3 m or otherwise and although I have a e 89 zed 4 I've not driven a zed4 m either .
I only know that people that have got them love them and also they're values are rising so albeit I've no experience of t v r it's food for thought