M135i xdrive - any experience?
M135i xdrive - any experience?
Author
Discussion

Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Saturday 11th June 2016
quotequote all
I know this is a bit of a longshot, given BMW never brought the xdrive M135 over here to the UK, but I never cease to be amazed at the breadth and depth of PHer knowledge... so here goes:

I need a one-size-fits-all car solution that will do the job in snowier European climates. I want fun (by which I suppose I mean quick and nimble) but it also needs 4/5 doors and a reasonable ability to get the power down in all conditions. The M135i xdrive seems, on paper, to tick many of the boxes. It will of course have winter tyres for the colder months.

But still being in the UK at the moment, test-driving is difficult. So can anyone tell me:

a. does the xdrive set up significantly compromise the handling and balance? Is there still a rearward bias? Any chance of a little tail out fun?

b. I've read lots of criticism on here of the suspension on 3-series xdrives. Does the 1er have the same issues?

c. is the drivetrain pretty robust? Are there any particular reliability issues inherent in the xdrive set-up?

Any thoughts / advice would be greatly appreciated.

Sohlman

590 posts

285 months

Sunday 12th June 2016
quotequote all
Sounds to me that what you want is a Golf R. Similar power 4wd.

Amazing reviews

Plenty coming up for sale at the end of leases.

Reliable

Quick

My mate has one and rates it better than his Aston v8 vantage prodrive for cross country pace and involvement. Is not as pretty or sounds as good.

It's also bigger inside then 135i

Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Sunday 12th June 2016
quotequote all
Sohlman said:
Sounds to me that what you want is a Golf R.
Not really, but thanks for the reply. The Golf R doesn't particularly appeal to me - although I appreciate that on paper it looks to tick the boxes. I don't really like the styling and I prefer the 6-cylinder BMW engine to the VW 4-pot. All personal preference, of course. And there's little in it in terms of price.




Sohlman

590 posts

285 months

Sunday 12th June 2016
quotequote all
There is something very appealing about a 6 cylinder.

I have just ordered a m235i and these in Europe are available in xdrive. Same performance, slightly bigger cabin. Might be worth a look

nickfrog

25,478 posts

248 months

Sunday 12th June 2016
quotequote all
OP. Where would you be based ? Unless quite high in the Alps, I am not sure 4wd is such a great asset when already on winters.
Bear in mind the car is set up to understeer and even push understeer under a moderate throttle. The only way to neutralise it is to fit M4 lower control arms (£300) which also add some (much needed) steering feel, improves turn in and even out tyre wear (the std set up chews outside front shoulders). This upgrade is compulsory on this chassis IMO. So xDrive will probably increase understeer but the M4 LCAs are not compatible with it either...

Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Sunday 12th June 2016
quotequote all
Sohlman said:
There is something very appealing about a 6 cylinder.

I have just ordered a m235i and these in Europe are available in xdrive. Same performance, slightly bigger cabin. Might be worth a look
The 2er would indeed be a good bet, were it not that I'd really like rear doors. Getting our (nearly) 2-year old into the back of a 2-door is a hassle we could probably do without.

Nick - thanks for the thoughts on handling. Have you driven the xdrive? Have you read any useful reviews that back up your thoughts? I'd be grateful for any links. thumbup

nickfrog

25,478 posts

248 months

Sunday 12th June 2016
quotequote all
Gruber said:
Nick - thanks for the thoughts on handling. Have you driven the xdrive? Have you read any useful reviews that back up your thoughts? I'd be grateful for any links. thumbup
No not driven - but the impossibility to fit the M4 LCAs would be a non-starter for me, the car absolutely needs it irrespective of number of wheels driven - you will find plenty of reviews on that on babybmw and bimmerpost.

As for 4wd per se, it really hinges on how crucial easier traction management is for you (ie where you will be driving the car) as it necessarily implies the usual downsides (extra weight, tranny losses, more maintenance, even more understeer usually, corrupted steering, etc etc).

You could probably even have a LSD for the extra cost of xdrive. No brainer for me but we all have different needs.

tenfour

26,140 posts

245 months

Sunday 12th June 2016
quotequote all
Gruber said:
I know this is a bit of a longshot, given BMW never brought the xdrive M135 over here to the UK, but I never cease to be amazed at the breadth and depth of PHer knowledge... so here goes:

I need a one-size-fits-all car solution that will do the job in snowier European climates. I want fun (by which I suppose I mean quick and nimble) but it also needs 4/5 doors and a reasonable ability to get the power down in all conditions. The M135i xdrive seems, on paper, to tick many of the boxes. It will of course have winter tyres for the colder months.

But still being in the UK at the moment, test-driving is difficult. So can anyone tell me:

a. does the xdrive set up significantly compromise the handling and balance? Is there still a rearward bias? Any chance of a little tail out fun?

b. I've read lots of criticism on here of the suspension on 3-series xdrives. Does the 1er have the same issues?

c. is the drivetrain pretty robust? Are there any particular reliability issues inherent in the xdrive set-up?

Any thoughts / advice would be greatly appreciated.
Assuming you don't plan to actually plough any of the ski slopes you intend on visiting, what do you really need the 4WD for? And bear in mind, that if you answer, "#becausesnow", with a decent set of winter rubber, the limitations of your ride height will defeat you long before any extra mechanical grip afforded by part-time driven front wheels (or vice versa as the case may be).

In my humble opinion, the whole 4WD executive car thing is a marketing ploy and really only makes a difference if you're chasing stage times, where grip on corner exit is paramount (i.e. in rallying and the homologation specials which spawned it). Don't get me wrong, I occasionally found my old Golf R32 useful in low grip conditions, but not to the extent that its part-time use of the rear wheels merited lugging round that extra weight, all of the time. Ergo, 4WD in a lunatic turbo-nutter mobile is worth it; arguably not so much in your daily driver (unless we're talking bog-crawling Land Rovers, but you've got one of them).

For this scenario, I like to look o'er the water to our Scandinavian neighbours. Now the Noggies have been forced for years to switch rubber come November and back again (optionally) in April each year, so it's no surprise to see just about every car on the road wearing steel wheels in the colder months. What might surprise you though, is just how few of those cars are actually 4WD. In Norway (where I used to live incidentally), you'd assume that any sane person would opt for the 4WD variant of anything at all costs. And so it may seem odd to discover that even the local back-and-beyond coppers tool around in 2WD motors, but crucially, they're fitted with appropriate rubber.

"Madness!", I hear you say. Well, if there's any place on earth that's likely to snap up anything with at least two differentials, it's the land what produced Mr. Blomqvist. But alas, it's not to be. Instead you'll find no end of FWD Golf TDIs and no shortage of RWD Beemers either.

So that's my reasoning: if 2WD is good enough for the Scandi-flickers in the deep mid winter, it's good enough for anyone. And for what it's worth, I used to take my snow-tyred C2 skiing of a weekend and only whence the fresh powder reached the headlights, did I need to dig out the chains. That's not a euphemism, by the way.

The moral of this long-winded anecdote? Buy what you want and let the rubber sort you out (as it were).

Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Sunday 12th June 2016
quotequote all
tenfour said:
So that's my reasoning: if 2WD is good enough for the Scandi-flickers in the deep mid winter, it's good enough for anyone. And for what it's worth, I used to take my snow-tyred C2 skiing of a weekend and only whence the fresh powder reached the headlights, did I need to dig out the chains. That's not a euphemism, by the way.

The moral of this long-winded anecdote? Buy what you want and let the rubber sort you out (as it were).
Evening squire.

All understood and I get the point. Still no closer to working out what to buy though.


nickfrog

25,478 posts

248 months

Monday 13th June 2016
quotequote all
M140i 2wd + M4 LCAs + LSD ?

Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Monday 13th June 2016
quotequote all
nickfrog said:
M140i 2wd + M4 LCAs + LSD ?
We might have to swap in "135" for "140" in that equation. In the land of the cuckoo clock, the budget won't stretch to the newer model. And now I'm looking at Golf Rs and S3s again. And B7 RS4s.

tenfour

26,140 posts

245 months

Monday 13th June 2016
quotequote all
Gruber said:
We might have to swap in "135" for "140" in that equation. In the land of the cuckoo clock, the budget won't stretch to the newer model. And now I'm looking at Golf Rs and S3s again. And B7 RS4s.
Y'see, perversely, I'd rather have the Golf R, if we're talking mega-hatches; purely because the idea of a 4WD Beemer (God, that sounds so incredibly 90s, doesn't it?!), sits very uneasy with me.

Or, what about the Focus RS? That's a car I'd kill puppies to own. If its Focus ST little brother is anything to go by, the RS will be a hooligan. I realise I've now done a complete 180 on my reasoning in the post above... hehe


Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Monday 13th June 2016
quotequote all
tenfour said:
Y'see, perversely, I'd rather have the Golf R, if we're talking mega-hatches; purely because the idea of a 4WD Beemer (God, that sounds so incredibly 90s, doesn't it?!), sits very uneasy with me.

Or, what about the Focus RS? That's a car I'd kill puppies to own. If its Focus ST little brother is anything to go by, the RS will be a hooligan. I realise I've now done a complete 180 on my reasoning in the post above... hehe
I spent last night looking at ads for Golf Rs. I think I've decided they work better in red...

I don't think the Focus RS is really "me".

And secretly I quite fancy an RS3, with its quirky 5-pot. But the first gen cars were panned and the latest ones are too expensive (and have tiddly little boots).

Just when I thought I'd finally arrived at my perfect garage (e46 M3, Land Rover and a moped) our needs change and I need to start all over again. A nice problem to have, but it's not proving an easy nut to crack.

S3_Graham

12,835 posts

230 months

Monday 13th June 2016
quotequote all
Gruber said:
nickfrog said:
M140i 2wd + M4 LCAs + LSD ?
We might have to swap in "135" for "140" in that equation. In the land of the cuckoo clock, the budget won't stretch to the newer model. And now I'm looking at Golf Rs and S3s again. And B7 RS4s.
Do you have to be a cash buyer? M140 is no more expensive new than a 135. I'm told it may even come out cheaper due to lower Tax and better GFV. There are significant discounts around. For a 5dr auto My Local dealer could get to 28k but I managed cheaper still through an online contact. 16th of June is apparently when the official figures are released and I assume the configurator will go live.

Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Monday 13th June 2016
quotequote all
S3_Graham said:
Do you have to be a cash buyer? M140 is no more expensive new than a 135. I'm told it may even come out cheaper due to lower Tax and better GFV. There are significant discounts around. For a 5dr auto My Local dealer could get to 28k but I managed cheaper still through an online contact.
Sadly, the Swiss market doesn't seem to be anywhere near as generous in its deals and discounting as the UK market.