HELP ME CHOOSE - BMW 550i (2008/9) or 535D (2012/13)
HELP ME CHOOSE - BMW 550i (2008/9) or 535D (2012/13)
Author
Discussion

sailingsmith

Original Poster:

21 posts

282 months

Sunday 12th June 2016
quotequote all
OK, so I know these are pretty different cars but over a realistic period they will give a similar cost of ownership, 17k miles per year, so I'm interested in opinions, real world experience of ownership/driving etc.

The reason for this is that I've just sold my kit car, I need to have the family size car and want something that isn't dull to drive. I know I'm not going to get the same sort of enjoyment or connection as I did with my kit and already have an E60 530D but only in SE spec.

Unfortunately I think M5 is a step too far with my wife and also costs in general.

Let me have it smile


Mr E

23,108 posts

290 months

Sunday 12th June 2016
quotequote all
For 17k a year I'd probably buy the diesel.

philmots

4,666 posts

291 months

Sunday 12th June 2016
quotequote all
I had a 550, great car, better than my old 335d in every way other than MPG.

At 17k a year though, I'd probably buy a diesel. But just a 530d.

sailingsmith

Original Poster:

21 posts

282 months

Sunday 12th June 2016
quotequote all
Take fuel costs out, unless we go back up to crazy money per litre, then purchase cost, depreceation, fuel, tax etc. work pretty similar over 4 years which is my norm for ownership.

Also, with those miles, the turbos etc. start coming potentially into play, mine went at 130,000 so back end of planned ownership.

Theophany

1,069 posts

161 months

Monday 13th June 2016
quotequote all
So costs are of no concern to you, you already have a 530D, so moving to a 535D seems pointless as you'll be going from an old diesel 5 series to a slightly faster old diesel 5 series. Which means the only reasonable conclusion I can draw from this you just want us to give you the justification to buy an old 5 series with a V8.

You have my blessing. thumbup

Swoxy

2,842 posts

241 months

Monday 13th June 2016
quotequote all
Also consider a 750i Sport ..




mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Monday 13th June 2016
quotequote all
Been driving diesels for about 5 years now, and just swapped into a 545i.

Smooooooth as warm chocolate.

And I'm doing 30k a year, but bugger it, you only live once. 25mpg average is good enough for me, 35 - 50 mile each way commute.

Follow your heart and the 6500rpm red-line. You know you want to.

eliot

12,000 posts

285 months

Monday 13th June 2016
quotequote all
Watch out for worn valve stem seals on the V8's once over 100k. Manifests as smoke when you rev the engine after idling for a few minutes.

ZX10R NIN

30,662 posts

156 months

Tuesday 14th June 2016
quotequote all
You're not wrong it's a £2500 job as well

eliot

12,000 posts

285 months

Tuesday 14th June 2016
quotequote all
ZX10R NIN said:
You're not wrong it's a £2500 job as well
It can be, but it can also be done DIY for far less than that:
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
I've sold the tool on already - so the cost was just the parts and my time.

sailingsmith

Original Poster:

21 posts

282 months

Tuesday 14th June 2016
quotequote all
Thanks everyone, I've looked into that job and although quite a lot of money if not done DIY, the potential of replacing turbos on the 535D is a similar cost (neither of which I relish!) so just part of the fun with cars like this. If I managed to find a 550i estate I would be very tempted, although I think my wife would rather a newer car.

Anyone running a x50i car with 150k on the clock (realistically the mileage I would plan to own it until)? How is everything? looking?

mobilejo

16 posts

135 months

Tuesday 14th June 2016
quotequote all
Thread title says - "BMW 550i (2008/9) or 535D (2012/13)" Just to confirm, you are comparing e60 to F10?

smashie

685 posts

182 months

Tuesday 14th June 2016
quotequote all
sailingsmith said:
....... If I managed to find a 550i estate I would be very tempted, although I think my wife would rather a newer car. ..........
Good luck with that. The last 2 up for sale have recently been sold. They seem to get snapped up quite quickly, especially if well looked after.
ETA: And 2008/9 not seen one of those in Estate form come up for sale yet.

sailingsmith

Original Poster:

21 posts

282 months

Tuesday 14th June 2016
quotequote all
mobilejo, yep, E60 and F10.... I want over 300BHP smile

sailingsmith

Original Poster:

21 posts

282 months

Tuesday 14th June 2016
quotequote all
smashie said:
Good luck with that. The last 2 up for sale have recently been sold. They seem to get snapped up quite quickly, especially if well looked after.
ETA: And 2008/9 not seen one of those in Estate form come up for sale yet.
I'm not in a rush so will keep my eyes open and see if the price is right along with everything else.

It's certainly a head and heart thing, one is leaning to each option.

Trabi601

4,865 posts

126 months

Tuesday 14th June 2016
quotequote all
sailingsmith said:
mobilejo, yep, E60 and F10.... I want over 300BHP smile
F10s are a massive step forward over an E60.

You'd be mad to go for another E60 when you can get the power you want in an F10.

Mr Tidy

31,919 posts

158 months

Wednesday 15th June 2016
quotequote all
Not exactly comparable, but for 9 years I had a 320td followed by a 123d.

Then I stopped doing business miles and got a Z4 Coupe and a 325ti and realised what BMW ownership was all about - biggish N/A petrol engines!

If you can make a 550i work for you, why exactly would you contemplate any diseasel?

Go for it! thumbup

Spuffington

1,355 posts

199 months

Wednesday 15th June 2016
quotequote all
I traded my E60 535d LCi for a E60 550i LCi - not a moment's regret.

Would still have had the car now if it weren't for the fact it had an untraceable leak in the cabin. With every rainshower came rear wet footwells. Tried everything, in the end I traded it for an X5.

But the engine was an absolute peach, as was the Dynamic Drive mine had fitted.

All of this is somewhat irrelevant though as if I had the choice between an E60 or F10, it would be the F10 every day of the week, regardless of powerplant.

Dubmaster77

172 posts

224 months

Friday 17th June 2016
quotequote all
Hmmm?? Why not the best of both comparable worlds and go for the 530i in the F10? Last oppuetunity to drive a "traditional" 6 cylinder petrol 5 er without the associated running cost of the V8 in the better f10 chassis...

ETA Though they appear to be very rare??

Edited by Dubmaster77 on Friday 17th June 20:58