340i residuals v other models?
Discussion
I'm currently considering buying a 340i to replace the 330d I'm leasing (goes back end of September).
I know there are good discounts available on the 340, so would probably be looking at £32-34k without options.
Looking at what places like WBAC are offering for sub-year-old 340s, I'm a bit concerned.
Yes, I know their prices aren't realistic in terms of what a private sale or a p/ex to a dealer could probably achieve but I wanted to get a sort of baseline to see how the trade is viewing them in terms of residuals.
I put the details for this car http://www.usedcars.bmw.co.uk/3-Series/3.0-340i-M-... into WBAC and it came back with under £20k. I' tried others with similar results, too.
By comparison, my 32 month old 330d is coming back at nearly £19k on the same websites.
What's going on?
Surely a very low mileage 10 month old 340i M-sport has got to be worth more than an average mileage 2 1/2 year old 330d M-sport?
Are the residuals really that bad on petrols?
I'll repeat again that I'm looking at this with a very broad brush and I know WBAC are as good as useless for true prices but I'm interested to see how the trade is viewing 340s in comparison to what I'm currently driving, as if they're seriously such a poor bet for residuals I might as well lease one as it's going to be a much better bet over 2 or 3 years.
I know there are good discounts available on the 340, so would probably be looking at £32-34k without options.
Looking at what places like WBAC are offering for sub-year-old 340s, I'm a bit concerned.
Yes, I know their prices aren't realistic in terms of what a private sale or a p/ex to a dealer could probably achieve but I wanted to get a sort of baseline to see how the trade is viewing them in terms of residuals.
I put the details for this car http://www.usedcars.bmw.co.uk/3-Series/3.0-340i-M-... into WBAC and it came back with under £20k. I' tried others with similar results, too.
By comparison, my 32 month old 330d is coming back at nearly £19k on the same websites.
What's going on?
Surely a very low mileage 10 month old 340i M-sport has got to be worth more than an average mileage 2 1/2 year old 330d M-sport?
Are the residuals really that bad on petrols?
I'll repeat again that I'm looking at this with a very broad brush and I know WBAC are as good as useless for true prices but I'm interested to see how the trade is viewing 340s in comparison to what I'm currently driving, as if they're seriously such a poor bet for residuals I might as well lease one as it's going to be a much better bet over 2 or 3 years.
PorkInsider said:
I'm currently considering buying a 340i to replace the 330d I'm leasing (goes back end of September).
I know there are good discounts available on the 340, so would probably be looking at £32-34k without options.
Looking at what places like WBAC are offering for sub-year-old 340s, I'm a bit concerned.
Yes, I know their prices aren't realistic in terms of what a private sale or a p/ex to a dealer could probably achieve but I wanted to get a sort of baseline to see how the trade is viewing them in terms of residuals.
I put the details for this car http://www.usedcars.bmw.co.uk/3-Series/3.0-340i-M-... into WBAC and it came back with under £20k. I' tried others with similar results, too.
By comparison, my 32 month old 330d is coming back at nearly £19k on the same websites.
What's going on?
Surely a very low mileage 10 month old 340i M-sport has got to be worth more than an average mileage 2 1/2 year old 330d M-sport?
Are the residuals really that bad on petrols?
I'll repeat again that I'm looking at this with a very broad brush and I know WBAC are as good as useless for true prices but I'm interested to see how the trade is viewing 340s in comparison to what I'm currently driving, as if they're seriously such a poor bet for residuals I might as well lease one as it's going to be a much better bet over 2 or 3 years.
If you get PCP quotes from BMW Financial Services I think you'll find the Guaranteed Future Values on 340i's and 335d's suggest a very similar level of depreciation for the two (certainly not enough of a difference to sway the purchasing decision one way or the other on cars of that price). If you try putting the details of a less than 1 year old 335d into WBAC I suspect the value will also be pretty low (it certainly was when I asked for a value on my F31 335d!). I know there are good discounts available on the 340, so would probably be looking at £32-34k without options.
Looking at what places like WBAC are offering for sub-year-old 340s, I'm a bit concerned.
Yes, I know their prices aren't realistic in terms of what a private sale or a p/ex to a dealer could probably achieve but I wanted to get a sort of baseline to see how the trade is viewing them in terms of residuals.
I put the details for this car http://www.usedcars.bmw.co.uk/3-Series/3.0-340i-M-... into WBAC and it came back with under £20k. I' tried others with similar results, too.
By comparison, my 32 month old 330d is coming back at nearly £19k on the same websites.
What's going on?
Surely a very low mileage 10 month old 340i M-sport has got to be worth more than an average mileage 2 1/2 year old 330d M-sport?
Are the residuals really that bad on petrols?
I'll repeat again that I'm looking at this with a very broad brush and I know WBAC are as good as useless for true prices but I'm interested to see how the trade is viewing 340s in comparison to what I'm currently driving, as if they're seriously such a poor bet for residuals I might as well lease one as it's going to be a much better bet over 2 or 3 years.
JNW1 said:
If you get PCP quotes from BMW Financial Services I think you'll find the Guaranteed Future Values on 340i's and 335d's suggest a very similar level of depreciation for the two (certainly not enough of a difference to sway the purchasing decision one way or the other on cars of that price). If you try putting the details of a less than 1 year old 335d into WBAC I suspect the value will also be pretty low (it certainly was when I asked for a value on my F31 335d!).
Thanks.I've tried a slightly older (few months) 335d M-sport in WBAC and it's coming back at £24k.
If I'm buying a car it's not going to be a diesel so in that respect the disparity between 335d and 340i residuals isn't really relevant.
Just looking at whether buying or leasing a 340i would be the better option really.
PorkInsider said:
Thanks.
I've tried a slightly older (few months) 335d M-sport in WBAC and it's coming back at £24k.
If I'm buying a car it's not going to be a diesel so in that respect the disparity between 335d and 340i residuals isn't really relevant.
Just looking at whether buying or leasing a 340i would be the better option really.
FWIW, prices for the old E9X generation 335i, then the top 3 series, were always poor on WBAC. And I mean worse than p/ex prices and way below private sale. Conversely, diesel cars did well. I was told that the quote is calculated based on what the cars are getting at the BCA auction (they are the parent company, unless it's changed) so whether it's anything skewing because the performance petrols are rarer cars, I don't know. But I wouldn't base any residual value decision on a WBAC quote or use them for a performance petrol, even though I have, at a very good price, sold diesel with them.I've tried a slightly older (few months) 335d M-sport in WBAC and it's coming back at £24k.
If I'm buying a car it's not going to be a diesel so in that respect the disparity between 335d and 340i residuals isn't really relevant.
Just looking at whether buying or leasing a 340i would be the better option really.
Smuler said:
FWIW, prices for the old E9X generation 335i, then the top 3 series, were always poor on WBAC. And I mean worse than p/ex prices and way below private sale. Conversely, diesel cars did well. I was told that the quote is calculated based on what the cars are getting at the BCA auction (they are the parent company, unless it's changed) so whether it's anything skewing because the performance petrols are rarer cars, I don't know. But I wouldn't base any residual value decision on a WBAC quote or use them for a performance petrol, even though I have, at a very good price, sold diesel with them.
I've sold a diesel to them myself and also got a good price, so inline with what you're suggesting.Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


