E39 525i SE value
E39 525i SE value
Author
Discussion

James_G

Original Poster:

366 posts

215 months

Friday 17th June 2016
quotequote all
A work colleague has an 02 plate E39 525i SE that he wants shot of. 117k miles, metallic blue, grey leather, auto, some BMW history then local garage stuff. I've been in it and it goes well enough but it needs love, specifically:

Primewall tyres all round
Central locking on rear doors doesn't work
Keyfob intermittent
Damage to sill from car park high kerb interface
Headlights opaque
Missing lacquer on the bonnet
Needs a deep clean
Using lots of oil, CCV blocked I suspect, but could be something else.
2 months left on MOT

Presumably the value of these has dropped to a point where even if I am careful I could never recoup enough money to make buying it and running it a zero cost exercise while I tidied it up? Is this the worst of all worlds by virtue of not being diesel, not being the 530i and not being an M-Sport? Oh and WBAC said £380.

I don't need it as it does exactly what my current car does but I see it in the office car park looking forlorn and I feel sorry for it.

miniman

30,237 posts

293 months

Friday 17th June 2016
quotequote all
I'd say WBAC have made a particularly generous offer.

Sardonicus

19,464 posts

252 months

Friday 17th June 2016
quotequote all
miniman said:
I'd say WBAC have made a particularly generous offer.
^ yes

James_G

Original Poster:

366 posts

215 months

Friday 17th June 2016
quotequote all
Thanks, much as I expected. Shame really as it feels like there's plenty of life left in it, but it's just not economic.

He'll probably want £500 anyway.

Dubmaster77

172 posts

224 months

Friday 17th June 2016
quotequote all
Not being a diesel is probably a virtue in this case! To be honest most of what you have listed seems cosmetic and there are lots of e39 traits that require attention to keep them tip top. I was very lucky that the previous owner of mine had been very careful in keeping it tip top, and regularly serviced.

Even then it needed bits and pieces continuously doing to it to keep it in fine fettle.

Of the top of my head.....

The cooling systems are disposable and need completely replacing periodically which is about £350-£400 all in. We are talking. Rad, pump, thermo, hoses etc etc. Look in the lower grills of the bumper and see if the rad has bowed along its length.

I had to have the ABS ECU repaired £100

It was manual and the clutch was on the way out I'll forgive it as no trace of it being done previously and it was at 160k!
The bushes for the manual gear change needed doin, there is a kit.

The prop guibo makes a funny tinkling noise when you pull off.

The dreaded e38/e39 steering wheel shake!! Can be in some cases unfixable!! Mine was very slight and it never bothered me but you can throw a lot of cash trying to sort it out.

Gennerally the boot kids rot and I have seen a few recently with rear wheel arch repairs.

I would have kept mine but I moved back to Birmingham and was still working in Derby and the £100 + a week fuel bill was beginning to get to me! I should have kept it really though as cosmetically it was straight as an arrow and despite being an SE it had some desirable optima which made it quite a special car and I genuinely loved driving it.

528i

Manual! 30+ MPG average

M tech suspension ( this makes a massive difference! SEs otherwise can feel very barge like)

Split fold rear seats

Factory Xenons

Factory tow bar

I have emailed the guy I sold it too twice to give me first refusal if he sells it!!

They are a special car but you need to want to really love it or mash it into the ground!

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 17th June 2016
quotequote all
its worth a lot more than wbac i reckon just in parts but go in with eyes open... i think they are great cars and sorely miss my e39 525 sport touring

if he wants 500 id still go for it but if the ccv is failing or related vac hoses then its doable diy otherwise its 3-4 hours labour the parts kit is quite cheap

all other e39 niggles apply given vintage and mileage

Depthhoar

691 posts

159 months

Saturday 18th June 2016
quotequote all
James_G said:
A work colleague has an 02 plate E39 525i SE that he wants shot of. 117k miles, metallic blue, grey leather, auto, some BMW history then local garage stuff. I've been in it and it goes well enough but it needs love, specifically:

Primewall tyres all round
Central locking on rear doors doesn't work
Keyfob intermittent
Damage to sill from car park high kerb interface
Headlights opaque
Missing lacquer on the bonnet
Needs a deep clean
Using lots of oil, CCV blocked I suspect, but could be something else.
2 months left on MOT

Presumably the value of these has dropped to a point where even if I am careful I could never recoup enough money to make buying it and running it a zero cost exercise while I tidied it up? Is this the worst of all worlds by virtue of not being diesel, not being the 530i and not being an M-Sport? Oh and WBAC said £380.

I don't need it as it does exactly what my current car does but I see it in the office car park looking forlorn and I feel sorry for it.
Don't think you'll run it at zero cost but it could be an interesting project car if you're at all handy with the spanners.

Approx costs:
New (reasonable) tyres - £80 to £90 per corner.
Central locking - a DIY fix using breaker parts? say, £80
Key fob - If the key still starts the car then it will be the battery in the fob. There is a DIY battery replacement which is not entirely satisfactory but can give acceptable results for a few quid, otherwise it's a trip to the dealer for north of £100 per key.
Bodywork - sill and bonnet, say £700 at a reasonable body shop? (If the sill damage is cosmetic and nothing worse).
Oil consumption. Could be the CCV or something else. A bit of a lottery that one.
Headlights - an easy (and very satisfying) DIY involving masking tape, wet&dry, a bit of compounding and buffing. Low cost.

My main concern would be the condition of the gearbox. Some go on for 200k+ miles with little or no maintenance, others become an uneconomic repair (and effectively scrap the vehicle) at lower mileages even though they have had gearbox oil changes. Debate on whether gearbox oil changes are a good thing or not features regularly on BMW forums elsewhere.

Budget a few hundred £ for suspension work. There are innumerable arms, bushes and ball joints that can be regarded as service items. Worst case scenario, you can spend an awful lot of money sorting the suspension...and that doesn't include dampers.

I run two of these things, both manuals thankfully, which require quite intensive maintenance so that they are reliable and drive/perform well.

James_G

Original Poster:

366 posts

215 months

Monday 20th June 2016
quotequote all
Thanks for the further replies, much to ponder. Current owner has been test driving replacements at the weekend so I await his price with interest.

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Tuesday 21st June 2016
quotequote all
It';s a ropey 14 year old E39, and £380 is plenty. Even when in a poor state they still drive nice but it's not worth spending any money on. Well, replace the CCV but everything else can wait or FRO. There's always the danger with old sheds like this that you spend time and money getting everything done and then the head gasket goes or it loses reverse gear, rendering the car scrap. Old E39's can be quite needy and they're not getting more reliable as the years pass.

Buy for £380, run it until it expires terminally.

James_G

Original Poster:

366 posts

215 months

Friday 15th July 2016
quotequote all
It's arrived - thanks who replied.



In the end no money has changed hands, although I am on the hook for paying for a nice dinner for the original owner, me and our respectives wives, which is perfectly fine with me.

Other than needing a very good clean the only area of (visual) concern is this:



Oil loss seems to be from the valve cover gasket, which seems easy enough. Rear central locking does work which is a bonus, rear electric windows don't (I got them mixed up, clearly) but not so worried about that. Rear ditchfinders already replaced as they were illegal and some Dunlops have taken their place.

Might be worthy of my first Reader's Cars thread - will take a view.