E92 Complicated steering wheel/braking vibration/shimmy
Discussion
Hi, any help on the below would be greatly appreciated, I've copied this from E90post as you helpful bmw specific lot may be able to help 
Registered
0
REP
3
POSTS
Drives: E92 325I m sport (n52k)
Join Date: Jun 2016
Location: Alnwick, Northumberland
iTrader: (0)
Thumbs down Complicated e92 steering wheel/brake shimmy/vibration 😞
Hi, please bare with me as this post/problem is a little complicated, many thanks in advance!
Basically a couple of months ago I bought a 325I m sport ( http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/t...f=47&t=... As far as I can remember, infact I'm sure there was no vibration or problem.
With this being my first auto I did stamp on the brakes a few times thinking it was a clutch....dohhhh 😁 so have done some fairly heavy braking at times.
Now the problem as I remember was when I had my alloys "refurbed and painted" the company borrowed me some se 17" alloys for a couple of days (100 miles) that had a horrible vibration present,especially bad under braking. Now I wasn't too worried as I'd assumed they were buckled etc. And I would have my fresh alloys back soon so fast forward when I got my refurbed alloys back there was still a vibration there although not as bad with the "loan" wheels.
Since then a few weeks back I have had the Mot done which it passed with no advisories, they also rebalanced the front 2 alloys as the painter had just painted over the wheel weights.
I also had a full alignment done which was out slightly.
This still didn't fix it however so my mechanic friend and myself have cleaned the mating surfaces from the wheel/ hub and the wheel bolt holes which were full of flaking paint etc. This I think has improved it slightly but the annoying vibration is still there. 😞
It seems to be worse at 40/50 mph and light braking where it can be quite violent, although it's always there to a degree and I could be wrong.
My mechanic friend did say there was some "runout" on the brake discs, could it be this causing it even when not braking?
Could it be bushes or control arms? The cars got 93k on now.
Any help would be greatly appreciated as I want to get it sorted before a few long trips. Thanks for bearing with me!

Registered
0
REP
3
POSTS
Drives: E92 325I m sport (n52k)
Join Date: Jun 2016
Location: Alnwick, Northumberland
iTrader: (0)
Thumbs down Complicated e92 steering wheel/brake shimmy/vibration 😞
Hi, please bare with me as this post/problem is a little complicated, many thanks in advance!
Basically a couple of months ago I bought a 325I m sport ( http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/t...f=47&t=... As far as I can remember, infact I'm sure there was no vibration or problem.
With this being my first auto I did stamp on the brakes a few times thinking it was a clutch....dohhhh 😁 so have done some fairly heavy braking at times.
Now the problem as I remember was when I had my alloys "refurbed and painted" the company borrowed me some se 17" alloys for a couple of days (100 miles) that had a horrible vibration present,especially bad under braking. Now I wasn't too worried as I'd assumed they were buckled etc. And I would have my fresh alloys back soon so fast forward when I got my refurbed alloys back there was still a vibration there although not as bad with the "loan" wheels.
Since then a few weeks back I have had the Mot done which it passed with no advisories, they also rebalanced the front 2 alloys as the painter had just painted over the wheel weights.
I also had a full alignment done which was out slightly.
This still didn't fix it however so my mechanic friend and myself have cleaned the mating surfaces from the wheel/ hub and the wheel bolt holes which were full of flaking paint etc. This I think has improved it slightly but the annoying vibration is still there. 😞
It seems to be worse at 40/50 mph and light braking where it can be quite violent, although it's always there to a degree and I could be wrong.
My mechanic friend did say there was some "runout" on the brake discs, could it be this causing it even when not braking?
Could it be bushes or control arms? The cars got 93k on now.
Any help would be greatly appreciated as I want to get it sorted before a few long trips. Thanks for bearing with me!
Something is causing the vibration, clearly. Do you sometimes get steering wheel shimmy when you are not braking...just driving?
Tyres are sometimes not round. Drive for half an hour at motorway speeds. Directly afterwards (do not park on the warm tyres for more than a minute) remove the wheels and get them check for RFV, which is radial force variation. This can be checked at any garage with a wheel balancer equipped with road force measurement. If they are all less than 80 or 100N then you can probably remove that variable. You've checked the mounting to the hub...next is brakes...use a dti to measure unevenness....
Tyres are sometimes not round. Drive for half an hour at motorway speeds. Directly afterwards (do not park on the warm tyres for more than a minute) remove the wheels and get them check for RFV, which is radial force variation. This can be checked at any garage with a wheel balancer equipped with road force measurement. If they are all less than 80 or 100N then you can probably remove that variable. You've checked the mounting to the hub...next is brakes...use a dti to measure unevenness....
As a serial BM owner and someone who has experienced this many times, I sympathise with what can be an extremely frustrating problem. BMWs are sensitive cars that work best when attention to detail is properly observed - unfortunately not everyone who works on them appreciates this. Before you start spending money and ripping out various bushes, here are a few basic suggestions:
Firstly get the wheels balanced again at the most reputable tyre specialist near you - this is not as easy as it sounds, there is huge variance as to what constitutes proper balancing. Hunter machines in the hands of an experienced tech are a good bet IMO.
Secondly, make sure the mating surfaces between hub and wheel are clean. Any corrosion on either, get rid of it by rubbing down with a wire brush.
Thirdly, whenever a wheel is put back on the car, make sure the bolts is torqued by hand, categorically not an air tool. Do it in a classic alternate diamond sequence, to the factory spec (normally 88 lbs/ft or 120 Nm). If you want to go further, ask the fitter to tighten the bolts in two or three stages - say at 60, 90 and then 120 Nm - they might think you're being OTT but who cares if it might sort the problem? You want the most even mating between wheel and hub - manufacturers go to great lengths to achieve this on the production line. One reason why new cars rarely suffer from shimmy.
This has sorted 95% of similar issues for me. Give the car around 1000 miles to settle down and see what happens. Good luck.
Firstly get the wheels balanced again at the most reputable tyre specialist near you - this is not as easy as it sounds, there is huge variance as to what constitutes proper balancing. Hunter machines in the hands of an experienced tech are a good bet IMO.
Secondly, make sure the mating surfaces between hub and wheel are clean. Any corrosion on either, get rid of it by rubbing down with a wire brush.
Thirdly, whenever a wheel is put back on the car, make sure the bolts is torqued by hand, categorically not an air tool. Do it in a classic alternate diamond sequence, to the factory spec (normally 88 lbs/ft or 120 Nm). If you want to go further, ask the fitter to tighten the bolts in two or three stages - say at 60, 90 and then 120 Nm - they might think you're being OTT but who cares if it might sort the problem? You want the most even mating between wheel and hub - manufacturers go to great lengths to achieve this on the production line. One reason why new cars rarely suffer from shimmy.
This has sorted 95% of similar issues for me. Give the car around 1000 miles to settle down and see what happens. Good luck.
Many thanks for the detailed responses chaps, really appreciate it and gives me something to work with, I had contemplated just taking it to a bmw specialist for them to have have a look but the nearest one is quite a journey.
I don't think a "normal" garage would perhaps have the experience of common bmw weaknesses like control arms etc. And I'd probably just end up throwing unrequited parts at it.
I'll certainly have a look at getting them balanced "properly" and see where that goes.
Cheers
I don't think a "normal" garage would perhaps have the experience of common bmw weaknesses like control arms etc. And I'd probably just end up throwing unrequited parts at it.
I'll certainly have a look at getting them balanced "properly" and see where that goes.
Cheers
Get it sorted! Get the printouts of the radial force variation and post them on here.
These guys seem to have a road force balancer, http://www.tamtyres.co.uk/, and they are only 30 or so miles from you.
These guys seem to have a road force balancer, http://www.tamtyres.co.uk/, and they are only 30 or so miles from you.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


