520d vs Passat TDI costs?!
520d vs Passat TDI costs?!
Author
Discussion

andrewukr6

Original Poster:

1 posts

124 months

Thursday 14th July 2016
quotequote all
Hi all. My fathers ancient Volvo just died, and he asked me to find something new for him. Diesel. Estate. After searching around I found a 2006 520d touring (60k) was actually little more expensive than the likes of a Focus estate or a toyota Rav4. Obviously the 520d touring is a fantastic car. I've never owned one myself but it seems to be the "perfect car" all around. He was set to buy, but:

The very local mechanics who have maintained his old Volvo 850, and warned him off the BMW as they say the costs are incredibly high for servicing and maintenance. Also that they are very complicated with 3 on board computers. Note he has no interest in official dealer services, he just wants it kept running with minimal of fuss and expense. Due to this he has now asked me to look at a VW passat diesel.

Perhaps they're right, I wasn't expecting a BMW to come with very cheap non dealer parts and servicing as it's a quality car. But I signed upto ask your advice! It may be the passat is not particularly cheaper to service non dealer? We're in the UK.

jboy72

383 posts

212 months

Thursday 14th July 2016
quotequote all
Hi - I am afraid I cannot be of enormous help, but I would make the following two comments:-

I would not buy a 520d. Whereas the current 20d is quite a good engine, the 20d at that time was not so good. Spec and speed tend to improve up the diesel range whereas running costs do not increase that dramatically. The 520d is not exactly slow but personally I would be tempted by a 525d or 530d if I was going to buy a diesel.

I am sure the local garage is spot on, maintenance costs of a 5 series may well be more than a Passat - but personally I would rather spend £1000s more on the upkeep of a 5 series than own a Passat, which I consider to be one of the least charismatic cars of the modern age. This is personal preference though. If your father likes the look and feel of a Passat and values practical frugality then a 2006 5 series is perhaps best avoided.

smashy

3,108 posts

189 months

Thursday 14th July 2016
quotequote all
...mind you a 2006 car will not have that pile of dung N47 Engine so thats a big plus in my book they didnt arrive till sep 2007 I believe

motoroller

657 posts

204 months

Thursday 14th July 2016
quotequote all
From experience, a B6 passat will be much cheaper to run than an E60 520d. The E60 is a much nicer car but the B6 is a real workhorse and parts are cheap.

Fuel-wise they are very similar but tyres, brakes, maintenance etc are very different.

Charlie Croker mk2

303 posts

131 months

Thursday 14th July 2016
quotequote all
Passat and related golf were Honest Johns most complained about car -- ever . For what that's worth . But back down to reality for a technophobe just what would be a reliable 10 year old car that is still in good condition , its a good question back to the BMW range maybe a 530d would be slightly better at this age ?

Mr Tidy

31,919 posts

158 months

Friday 15th July 2016
quotequote all
My only experience of 4 cylinder turbo-diesels is with BMW - a 320td followed by a 123d so in that sense I cannot give any comparison.

But maybe the first question ought to be does your FIL actually need a diesel anyway? What is his annual mileage? How far is his typical journey? Will the EGR valve and/or DPF get clogged up every few months? Headline economy looks good, but does either car actually suit what he will use it for?

Or would a smaller-engined petrol work better?