Changing from a 635d to a 640d... worth it?
Changing from a 635d to a 640d... worth it?
Author
Discussion

RS Grant

Original Poster:

1,851 posts

264 months

Friday 15th July 2016
quotequote all
My dad currently has an 2010 635d Coupe which he's taken from ~30k to 90k miles and is currently thinking about changing it.. given he likes his car, the logical option would be to progress onto the newer 640d Coupe. There are a few niggles he's picked up with his 635d, so thought I'd see if anyone could give us an idea of whether they are still present in the 640d or not.

- Rear Seat Capacity, in particular headroom, is pretty poor in the 635d.. it's not a 4-seater if you plan to carry 4 normal sized adults. This will become apparent once he starts looking and test driving, but worth asking here first, is the 640d bigger/more spacious in the rear?

- Fuel Economy, his 635d averages 33-34mpg on the motorway sitting ~85mph for 2-3 hours at a time. Granted that's not exactly poor and it's not exactly great either, he had been hoping for nearer 40mpg given the Volvo D5 he traded in previously was returning 42-44mpg on exactly the same journeys. The 640d official figures look great, but how does the car perform in the real world when it comes to economy?

- Are there any known issues/recalls with the 640d which we should check have been addressed?


Cheers,
Grant

smashy

3,108 posts

189 months

Friday 15th July 2016
quotequote all
Grant the 4 Door version may be worth looking at re rear room ,says here the 2 extra doors arent just for show re room at the rear and I think the Gran coupe looks great.

http://www.topgear.com/car-reviews/bmw/6-series-gr...

Edited by smashy on Friday 15th July 19:24

MrBarry123

6,109 posts

152 months

Friday 15th July 2016
quotequote all
To my eyes, the E63 - your dad's current car - is a much better looking car than the F12 however I imagine the F12 is a better/nicer place to be when inside the car.

cslwannabe

1,570 posts

200 months

Friday 15th July 2016
quotequote all
We had a 640d for 2.5 years - was a great car. It did 40-42mpg, once saw an indicated 45mpg on a trip up to the west coast of Scotland but you won't get anywhere near 50mpg! Rear space is poor - don't know how it compares with a 635d but even with our 7 year old in the back the passenger seat position was a compromise. I think they look much better than the previous 6 and the 8 speed ZF gearbox is fantastic.

Slippydiff

16,502 posts

254 months

Friday 15th July 2016
quotequote all
MrBarry123 said:
To my eyes, the E63 - your dad's current car - is a much better looking car than the F12 however I imagine the F12 is a better/nicer place to be when inside the car.
I'd beg to differ I'm afraid smile the F12 feels nice, but definitely mass produced "nice", granted the E63 interior feels old, but it also feels like BMW doing the best interior they could at the time. It looks and feels a lot less "mass produced".

The cruncher for me though is the iDrive/phone/nav is pretty hopeless on the older car (and don't get me started on the heater/ventilation controls) hehe Whereas the F12 is far more modern, and thus better for it.

335d

758 posts

149 months

Friday 15th July 2016
quotequote all
For me the newer car is a lot better, so certainly worth the switch. I haven't been in the back of one though. As mentioned, the ZF8 is such a huge step forwards from the 6 speed slushmatic it replaced. The engine has improved too, but nowhere near as much as the gearbox.

DannyB2007

188 posts

231 months

Friday 15th July 2016
quotequote all
Missus went from e63 630i to f12 640d and i can confirm space is better than the previous model. Much better in every aspect in my eyes. Does 38/42mpg on her trips to and from work and running the kids about too. And goes well with 313bhp as standard. Id recommend one myself!

DannyB2007

188 posts

231 months

Friday 15th July 2016
quotequote all
Kids need to duck when lowering / raising the rag top still, that hasnt changed. Leg room is better though

smashy

3,108 posts

189 months

Friday 15th July 2016
quotequote all
That E63 was priced very nuttily wasnt it I remember seeing a new 630i conv in a dealers up for £66K and that was back in 2008 !!

Dryce

310 posts

163 months

Saturday 16th July 2016
quotequote all
RS Grant said:
- Rear Seat Capacity, in particular headroom, is pretty poor in the 635d.. it's not a 4-seater if you plan to carry 4 normal sized adults. This will become apparent once he starts looking and test driving, but worth asking here first, is the 640d bigger/more spacious in the rear?
It's not good in the 640d. Go for the Gran Coupe version - it adds 4 inches in wheelbase but the rear becomes a comfortable place for two adults.

[quote]
The 640d official figures look great, but how does the car perform in the real world when it comes to economy?
Depends on the driver's right foot.

I got 42mpg on longer journeys - you might do a bit better than that at constant speed on the motorway. The economy is good.

My feeling at the time I returned mine last year was that it wasn't good enough for the money. Great powertrain and good economy but at times the driving experience was poor which I blamed primarily on the steering when on some A and B roads. It's always been subject to heavy discounting - however in the last year it seems to have become even more aggresively priced at times. So the arithmetic of how good it is for the money is probably a bit better.


cerb4.5lee

45,325 posts

211 months

Saturday 16th July 2016
quotequote all
Other than the hassle of climbing in and out of the rear both me and the mrs are happy enough even on long journeys in the rear of the 640d Coupe( both short though me 5'8/mrs 5''1).

I think the interior is a decent step up over the 635d as that feels pretty dated now, mpg is awesome for its 1800kg weight and the performance it offers and it will do 40mpg regardless...well it has in our hands.

My main gripe with the 640d is that it's purely a cruiser and it's not very rewarding to thread through corners/throw around and I believe the 635d has a much more sporty feel to it.

cerb4.5lee

45,325 posts

211 months

Saturday 16th July 2016
quotequote all
MrBarry123 said:
To my eyes, the E63 - your dad's current car - is a much better looking car than the F12
Obviously looks are very subjective and I find most BMW's pretty ugly to look at, but the looks of the F13 Coupe to my eyes is it's greatest asset and really made me want one, even the Gran Coupe looks good so it just shows how good the original design is.

I have never got on with the E63's looks though but I didn't like the looks of my Z4MR either so I just think I'm not a Bangle design fan.

Ninja59

3,691 posts

143 months

Saturday 16th July 2016
quotequote all
Regarding MPG I nursed my 9000 mile F06 640D to the heady heights of 47.3 MPG in eco pro yesterday, granted some of that was on the M25, so it can be done near to the book figures, but then I got bored down the A2 so planted my foot back down it only dropped to 47...

I must admit I am glad we went with the GC, the coupe looks a squeeze getting in and out, I still have some that complain the roof is low getting in the rear minus that not bad.

The only gripe I have is the 20's 373's are easy to kerb (kerbed three since having it in Feb), two were me and are small the other is larger thanks to some plank coming excessively quick down our road and had no clue about me coming down frown. Will get them into Lepsons for refurb....

CSK423

838 posts

238 months

Sunday 17th July 2016
quotequote all
I've had a GC for 18 months and 24k miles now.

If rear leg room is a gripe on the coupe go for the Gran Coupe, it doesn't lose any driving ability and has actually been commented that it's the better drive according to some reviews.

Fuel - I've done various long motorway runs in it from the 4 hour eco mode 72mph cruise control = 51mpg to the 8 hour with pace (80'ish) comfort mode = 45mpg.

a typical motorway / around town will drag the average down to 38-42mpg.

RS Grant

Original Poster:

1,851 posts

264 months

Wednesday 20th July 2016
quotequote all
I appreciate the comments and replies... he's thinking more along the lines of a 640d GranCoupe now having seen a 640d Coupe and not being satisfied that the rear access is improved enough on the new car. The actual size in the back is still a slight concern but when he's taking family/colleagues out it's never a long journey, so it's more the access to the back which grinds on him; the 635d/640d Coupes are hardly small cars, access is really quite poor for their size.

Another thing, looking at the finance options through BMW the rate they quote on used cars is absolutely crazy, between 10-11% APR?! Think financing will absolutely be done elsewhere if he goes for an AUC. laugh

Sounds like >40mpg will be easily achievable for him on a motorway run sat on cruise control, which is a good improvement on what his 635d is returning.


Cheers,
Grant

Ninja59

3,691 posts

143 months

Wednesday 20th July 2016
quotequote all
It was 11% on my AUC car, in my case I found my funding elsewhere and bought outright.

I would also look out for any offers on new ones on lease depending on mileage....discounts are usually decent on the 6 either way.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Wednesday 20th July 2016
quotequote all
RS Grant said:
I appreciate the comments and replies... he's thinking more along the lines of a 640d GranCoupe now having seen a 640d Coupe and not being satisfied that the rear access is improved enough on the new car. The actual size in the back is still a slight concern but when he's taking family/colleagues out it's never a long journey, so it's more the access to the back which grinds on him; the 635d/640d Coupes are hardly small cars, access is really quite poor for their size.

Another thing, looking at the finance options through BMW the rate they quote on used cars is absolutely crazy, between 10-11% APR?! Think financing will absolutely be done elsewhere if he goes for an AUC. laugh

Sounds like >40mpg will be easily achievable for him on a motorway run sat on cruise control, which is a good improvement on what his 635d is returning.


Cheers,
Grant
In my F10 535d 299bhp which has a 42mpg combined official value best part of 400miles the other day I averaged 46mpg and for the return leg I certainly wasn't hanging about....
The new F10 535d 313bhp is 50mpg combined ditto the 640d so if I can do it I'm sure he will and maybe mid 50's will be achieved.