Winter tires again
Winter tires again
Author
Discussion

omar2010

Original Poster:

19 posts

168 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
Hi Guys - I have decided to get continental winter tires for my e90 330d.

Should I get exactly the same set up as my summer tyres as some threads have suggested narrower ones may be better for grip in extreme temperatures.

My back tyres are currently Nexen run flat 255/35/18.

I am just gonna swap tires and not get new rims.

Thinking just swap like for like...

Thanks for any advice.

Allan L

799 posts

136 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
Logic says you should pick the best section for the job, but in these rule-bound days the insurers would probably insist that you use whatever section/diameter/rating tyres that the manufacturer has homologated.
I have to make the same decision soon on my 320d Touring (whatever E number it is) and I do not expect any help from the dealer who took my money or the UK office of the manufacturer, which replied to technical queries with sales slogans. Perhaps they understand the question better in Munich where the winters are harder than in UK.

E-bmw

13,651 posts

183 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
Check your manual, you may find the recommendations in there.

Generally there are many that say 10mm down on section which may need a corresponding rise in ratio.

Alternatively, find a way of asking the question in Germany as they have to use them by law in winter IIRC.

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
This is the UK. They are TYRES

Spuffington

1,355 posts

199 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
I tend to spend a bit of time on RealOEM before choosing my setup.

Have a look on your doorcard firstly on what tyres sizes are the ones marked with M+S then see about what rims were designed for those tyres. Then check on RealOEM which M+S tyres were OEM fitment and take your pick from there. As indicated above, I've never had a problem with insurance if I've gone with OEM spec wheels and tyres. And the reason I stick with OEM tyres rather than go a la carte with them? I've had too many used BMWs with non-OEM tyres to have seen how they markedly (often negatively) impact the handling of the vehicle, so prefer to stick with what BMW originally fitted.


aeropilot

40,905 posts

258 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
omar2010 said:
Hi Guys - I have decided to get continental winter tires for my e90 330d.

Should I get exactly the same set up as my summer tyres as some threads have suggested narrower ones may be better for grip in extreme temperatures.

My back tyres are currently Nexen run flat 255/35/18.

I am just gonna swap tires and not get new rims.

Thinking just swap like for like...

Thanks for any advice.
Yep....I run 225/255x18 winters tyres on my 135i, same size as summers.

I live down south, so this is fine.
If I lived in a more remote and hilly part of the UK, then I'd maybe consider narrower winters on 17"....so depends on your UK location?

msej449

177 posts

152 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
Generally, you can just replace your summer tyres with winter ones the same size, if you can find them. This should be fine (including with your insurer, but worth checking) - with one exception.

One reason why BMW reduces the size of the rear wheels on their 'certified' wheel+Tyre combinations is so that you can fit chains to the rears (even on an xDrive). So on my 330d the manual said that winters couldn't be fitted on the 18" x 8J (8"-wide) wheels but only on the 17" x 7.5J (7.5"-wide) wheels. This releases enough space to accommodate the parts of the chains that sit and rotate around the inner face of the tyres. Without this extra space, the chains could foul the suspension and brake parts as they rotate at speed.

It's a reasonable assumption that someone wanting winter tyres may also need to fit chains. Of course, there are marginal areas where it's unlikely (like southern England) but as a global manufacturer, the easiest thing is for BMW to make that assumption, and certify smaller rear wheels that are guaranteed to take chains no problem.

Going for the full option of winter wheels as well as tyres is always a tricky question for UK owners, especially Southern ones. We take our car to the Alps at least once every winter, sometimes more, so it's worth going the whole hog and having a winter set of wheels and tyres plus chains. But I can see why some people say that just swapping tyres is enough, if there are no circumstances where they'd need chains.

Just be aware that if you do just swap winter for summer tyres and leave the larger wheels on, then fitting chains to the rears will be a lottery and you'll be doing something that is explicitly not certified. And that apart from any issues of non-insurance, the key problem would be potential damage.

You will find people and retailers who will say that they've put chains on standard rear wheels and had no problems. Well, that's fine, but it'll be you with the chains broken and wrapped 'round your suspension and brake assembly if it doesn't work out, not them.

Edited by msej449 on Monday 1st August 13:41

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
Winter is rather tiring, yes.

E-bmw

13,651 posts

183 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
bad company said:
This is the UK. They are TYRES
And there is a point to that statement of your expert opinion?

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
E-bmw said:
bad company said:
This is the UK. They are TYRES
And there is a point to that statement of your expert opinion?
Yes there is. In the US they have tires, station wagons and sedans which they fill with gas.

We drive on tyres and have estate & saloon cars which we fill with petrol.

If we're not careful we will all be speaking American English. That may not be a problem to you but I try to retain English English.

silent ninja

867 posts

131 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
bad company said:
Yes there is. In the US they have tires, station wagons and sedans which they fill with gas.

We drive on tyres and have estate & saloon cars which we fill with petrol.

If we're not careful we will all be speaking American English. That may not be a problem to you but I try to retain English English.
Never a grammar nazi or anything like that, but English usage should be English and not Americanised, so I agree. Kids these days write "mom" a lot too, and say things like semester, high school... It's silly. Next they'll be saying aloo-mi-num and calling the government uncle Sam

f1nn

2,694 posts

223 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
Winter tyres.......August.

I bet you've finished your Christmas shopping already.

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
silent ninja said:
Never a grammar nazi or anything like that, but English usage should be English and not Americanised, so I agree. Kids these days write "mom" a lot too, and say things like semester, high school... It's silly. Next they'll be saying aloo-mi-num and calling the government uncle Sam
I think US based spellcheckers & predictive texting are to blame for a lot of that.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
bad company said:
E-bmw said:
bad company said:
This is the UK. They are TYRES
And there is a point to that statement of your expert opinion?
Yes there is. In the US they have tires, station wagons and sedans which they fill with gas.

We drive on tyres and have estate & saloon cars which we fill with petrol.

If we're not careful we will all be speaking American English. That may not be a problem to you but I try to retain English English.
At this moment in time, I'm glad you correctionisationated that error.

If the Yanks do two things well, those things are cocking up the English language and never using one word when eleven will do...hehe

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
At this moment in time, I'm glad you correctionisationated that error.
Very good. laugh

Feel free to bring the thread back on topic btw.

Sohlman

590 posts

285 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
Having run an e90 330i for three years I would suggest buying a second set of wheels and tyres it will be cheaper long term and more convenient.

Go on line via eBay and there are plenty of sets of square set OEM 17" alloys for the e90. I bought a set for £500 with 8mm of tread and Pirelli sortozero 225/45/17 tyres. Basically brand new and unused. I ran the car for three winters and when I sold the car sold the wheels separately with now 5mm of tread having covered around 10k mileage. I got back £460.

If you buy four quality tyres you are looking at around £400-500. Then you have to find a tyre fitter to mount unmount mount unmount etc. each time spending money. You get the picture plus you have more wear and tear on the alloys, tyres.

For me it's a no brainer

Googie

2,401 posts

157 months

Monday 1st August 2016
quotequote all
Sohlman said:
Having run an e90 330i for three years I would suggest buying a second set of wheels and tyres it will be cheaper long term and more convenient.

Go on line via eBay and there are plenty of sets of square set OEM 17" alloys for the e90. I bought a set for £500 with 8mm of tread and Pirelli sortozero 225/45/17 tyres. Basically brand new and unused. I ran the car for three winters and when I sold the car sold the wheels separately with now 5mm of tread having covered around 10k mileage. I got back £460.

If you buy four quality tyres you are looking at around £400-500. Then you have to find a tyre fitter to mount unmount mount unmount etc. each time spending money. You get the picture plus you have more wear and tear on the alloys, tyres.

For me it's a no brainer
Or have a look at these guys www.mrwinterwheels.co.uk- I picked up a new set of alloys and tyres last year for an E60 535d for c £800 all in. Looks like they are doing an early bird August discount offer at the moment !!

Mr Tidy

31,905 posts

158 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
FWIW OP I wouldn't want to run winter tyres on 19 inch rims - I'm sure smaller rims with narrower tyres would work better, and any tyres for 19 inch rims aren't going to be cheap!

My 325ti Sport has staggered rims with 245/40 x 17 rears. I bought a pair of Pirellis last year for £208. Then in November I got a set of 205/50 x 16 (a standard size for a 325ti) with Michelin Alpin winters on alloys for £180 with 4 to 5 mm tread on them - result!

They were fine throughout last winter (although we didn't get snow down here)!

But the bonus is I don't need to get tyres changed (which many tyre places aren't keen on) and can just swap the wheels over myself!

On a 330d I think you would need at least 17 inch rims to clear the front brakes, but you could probably get a complete set of 17 inch winters on rims cheaper than a couple of 19 inch winter tyres!

Good luck anyway! thumbup

Frances The Mute

1,816 posts

272 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
f1nn said:
Winter tyres.......August.

I bet you've finished your Christmas shopping already.
Winter tyre production will be coming to an end soon for the 2016/17 season so now is actually the best time to place an order.

omar2010

Original Poster:

19 posts

168 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
Thanks a lot guys. Fantastically helpful as always.