2011 335d M-Sport touring or 2010 530d SE Saloon?
2011 335d M-Sport touring or 2010 530d SE Saloon?
Author
Discussion

un1corn

Original Poster:

2,143 posts

168 months

Saturday 6th August 2016
quotequote all
In short, both same spec, colour, mileage. I've got a VXR vectra at the moment, which while nice and quick, is petrol (expensive fuel/tax), manual box (getting bored of manual, want to be lazy with auto) and is a very very hard ride.

I understand BMW runflats will be hard anyway.

If you had a choice from these two cars, which would you take? I assume none of them will have DAB at this year/model, which is a shame, but I'm sure I can sort something out with my phone/bluetooth option, or get it fitted. Anyway, in terms of fun driving, which would be nicer to drive? I don't expect either to drive like a ferrari, but my commute is basically one long straight line with opportunity for overtakes on some good A-roads. Is the 5-series a bit cumbersome and heavy? Will I appreciate the extra 3-series boot space?

Both cars at at/around the 60,000 mile mark with FSH, but the 335 is £2500 more than the 530. I'm using man-maths to justify the purchase here aswell.

Wills2

29,938 posts

206 months

Saturday 6th August 2016
quotequote all
e90 vs. F10? If so I'd take the F10 miles better.


roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Saturday 6th August 2016
quotequote all
335, speed matters biggrin

renorti

727 posts

227 months

Sunday 7th August 2016
quotequote all
530d, better car overall.

335d

758 posts

149 months

Sunday 7th August 2016
quotequote all
It is a trade between driving enjoyment and comfort. The 530d is a far more pleasant place to be, but rather soft and ungainly, particularly with SE suspension.

The 335d is a fair bit quicker and more fun, but quite dated now, and not terribly comfortable. It still has the old 6 speed slushmatic, whereas the 8 speed in the 530d is hugely better.

I would perhaps see if you could stretch to a 2012 F30/1 330d, which is about as quick as the old E91 335d, thanks to the hugely better gearbox, and it is a much more pleasant place to spend time.

un1corn

Original Poster:

2,143 posts

168 months

Sunday 7th August 2016
quotequote all
335d said:
I would perhaps see if you could stretch to a 2012 F30/1 330d, which is about as quick as the old E91 335d, thanks to the hugely better gearbox, and it is a much more pleasant place to spend time.
I don't like the inside of the F30, otherwise I'd take a punt. I'm very very fond of the E90/1 for some reason.

335d

758 posts

149 months

Sunday 7th August 2016
quotequote all
un1corn said:
I don't like the inside of the F30, otherwise I'd take a punt. I'm very very fond of the E90/1 for some reason.
There are certainly aspects of the F3x that people like less than the E9x, generally the lack of sharpness, but I think you may be almost alone in preferring the interior of the older car. Make sure you try a higher model, such as a 330d M Sport before rejecting the F3x entirely. My early impression of the F30 was quite poor as well, but it was a low spec loan car.

Having had both an E46 3 Series, and a couple of E39 5 Series, I skipped the E9X and E6x generation entirely, partly down to what I considered to be very poor quality interiors. I have since had an F10 and F30 which to me at least are a huge improvement in that respect, although perhaps at the expense of being less of a drivers' car.

MikeTFSI

6,091 posts

133 months

Sunday 7th August 2016
quotequote all
E90 needs to be a higher spec to be nice inside. I looked at a SE spec and it just seemed so bland. Almost put me off them completely. I then looked at an M Sport with leather and iDrive and it is so much nicer inside.

The F30 is probably the same. I'm not sure about the stick on screen, not as bad as the Mercs but still not integrated as nicely as the E90 screen.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Monday 8th August 2016
quotequote all
I bought an E92 and sold it within 3 months. The F10 is absolutely miles and miles better, IMHO. But to be fair it's a generation newer.

The Stiglet

2,063 posts

225 months

Tuesday 9th August 2016
quotequote all
Fox- said:
I bought an E92 and sold it within 3 months. The F10 is absolutely miles and miles better, IMHO. But to be fair it's a generation newer.
I'd take the E92. Had an F10 535d for the last 6 months (it was probably cursed so I'm biased) but there was much to dislike. Steering feel is poor with the electric steering, they roll quite a bit, they are too big and the offset pedals/driving position is a total PITA.

There are other benefits of course, but I was very disappointed.

335d

758 posts

149 months

Tuesday 9th August 2016
quotequote all
MikeTFSI said:
The F30 is probably the same. I'm not sure about the stick on screen, not as bad as the Mercs but still not integrated as nicely as the E90 screen.
I think you are going to have to get used to this stuck on screen. Interior shots of the new G30 5 Series show a big stuck on F30 style screen http://s2.paultan.org/image/2016/04/2017-G30-BMW-5...

It does seem to be the direction in which we are heading, although the Mercedes C Class version still looks a little extreme.

un1corn

Original Poster:

2,143 posts

168 months

Tuesday 9th August 2016
quotequote all
335d said:
I think you are going to have to get used to this stuck on screen. Interior shots of the new G30 5 Series show a big stuck on F30 style screen http://s2.paultan.org/image/2016/04/2017-G30-BMW-5...

It does seem to be the direction in which we are heading, although the Mercedes C Class version still looks a little extreme.
Thats my gripe about the f30. It looks like someone just stuck a phone in landscape and clipped it on.

The E90 looks more professional and integrated, which is why I prefer it.

Wills2

29,938 posts

206 months

Wednesday 10th August 2016
quotequote all
I think the BMW screen is the best of the "stuck on screens" it sits back into the dash a bit has a wide screen aspect ratio a lower profile and feels more integrated from the drivers seat than say Mercedes effort which really does look like you've blue tacked a cheap windows tablet to the dash.