Micro Filters?
Micro Filters?
Author
Discussion

pointedstarman

Original Poster:

554 posts

177 months

Monday 8th August 2016
quotequote all
My F10 525d is now out of warranty so I don't feel as obliged to use OEM parts unless they're worth it.

The car is due an oil and micro filter service (oil/air/pollen & fuel filters). The OEM items add up to well over £200 but non OEM items can be had for less than half that.

I'll get the oil changed by BMW using their fixed pricing as I get a stamp in the book smile.

However, has anyone experience of the non OEM air / pollen / fuel filters or are the BMW items so mush better that they're worth the extra?

goldieandblackie

273 posts

125 months

Monday 8th August 2016
quotequote all
Just have the car serviced at a BMW independent specialist,as this will be around half the price of the main dealers and using quality parts at the same time.

pointedstarman

Original Poster:

554 posts

177 months

Monday 8th August 2016
quotequote all
That doesn't work as the big potential cost driver are the OEM parts which are pretty much the same whether you use dealer or specialist.

My local garage will do the fitting for £30 either way so labour isn't the issue (I could do the air / pollen filters myself but the fuel filter is under the car and I'd prefer someone else do that one.

Using none OEM parts is a bid cost saving but is the quality OK? That's my concern hence the question.

Huff

3,449 posts

222 months

Monday 8th August 2016
quotequote all
If you buy reputable bits such as MANN or other oem supplier, say the charcoal-activated cabin filters, via ECP or equivalent, then yes - it is OEM quality.

I've been very happy with the same in my cars; there's no reason to believe that BMW have some un-attainably-good unique supply. It's a paper air filter... it is a commodity, and very unlikely to be a unique part.

+1 for finding a good independant; you'll still get a stamp in the book, if you want it; and that - backed by a file of service receipts is certainly not going to put-off a buyer when the time comes. (To my mind, when buying s/h, a decent file of maintenance on service and proactive replacement bits says much more to me than whether or not anything was done at a dealer)


Edited by Huff on Monday 8th August 22:12

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Monday 8th August 2016
quotequote all
Bought an air filter for the X5 tuther week, £70 at BMW, got one from Euro for twenty something....stamped BMW. Go figure.

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Tuesday 9th August 2016
quotequote all
Mahle make the filters for BMW, you'll find the BMW badge ground off.

Craikeybaby

12,179 posts

256 months

Tuesday 9th August 2016
quotequote all
I got a micro filter from ECP for my E87 and it didn't look like it was made as well as the OEM part I removed, but haven't noticed any difference in how it works.

CarsOrBikes

1,158 posts

215 months

Tuesday 9th August 2016
quotequote all
All sorts of cheap parts exist from suppliers that say they're oe or oem, but who else says they are genuine quality? Then you have no comeback on anything really, if anything has a fault, and although some marks are ground off, does it mean they're always genuine BMW marks ground off? How can we be sure what's really oe from a factor.

The few manufacturers of aftermarket parts that might make parts for BMW don't make all the parts for all of the range of vehicles, so best not to assume they do, and none of them allow a 2 year warranty across the entire European BMW network like most genuine parts, backed up by the BMW warranty system, so including labour when agreed, and we know there is no European network of independents under such an umbrella haha. If something goes wrong you have to go back to that garage. Not always ideal, or warranted.

Personally I would always use genuine oil filters at the very least. If you saw some of the so called OEM aftermarket oil filters on removal only to find them collapsed in the housing, you perhaps consider other parts. Microfilters don't always fit well, and the aftermarket garages frequently don't use charcoal filters although available, but regular paper filters that allow other fumes in the cabin or particulates that the OE filter wouldn't. Air filters sometimes obstruct the lid of the housing, and a later garage may advise the customer that securing clips for it are broken, perhaps due to the struggle of getting non genuine parts to fit or even poor running fault perhaps.

Some aftermarket parts are good, and if using an independent you have to trust they will use those that are OE specification, if they actually know. Most will always buy the cheapest to them, and are quite particular about it. Don't be misled here, know where your parts come from, genuine or not.

One thing that is likely an issue for some, is that if you do ask whatever garage to use genuine parts, do you know if they have? Many might say yes they're OE quality but that doesn't mean the same. If you really want genuine parts, perhaps consider going to the main dealer and negotiate the price, then take them to your indy to fit, why not?

The dealer sells at a discount to the trade which often won't be passed to you, so why not discuss this purchase directly? It won't affect the dealer, as he probably doesn't usually sell many of the service parts to the trade anyway, as they buy the cheaper stuff. So will be happy to know customers are proud to have a bit of a deal, in order to get the best parts, then he sells more perhaps.

The BMW network are more likely to be able to repurchase your car if it has been serviced using genuine parts, and that affects values. If you kept a record of the amount the indy charged for aftermarket parts, compared to how much you could buy genuine parts for, for servicing, you'd perhaps conclude there is value to be had in sticking with genuine over the ownership period.

For me, I just don't generally have a labour bill, so I pick and choose where to get parts, and am guilty of trawling a few suppliers to get a deal I'm happy with. I certainly don't trust an independent's choice of aftermarket parts on my behalf, but would listen to opinion if they were happy to share experiences of ste makes, but of course they're unlikely to.


You also have the inconsistency of the aftermarket supplying a variety of manufacturers parts for the same application depending on what they have in stock, and the Indy will frequently let them. For example, 6 x 520d's and four different makes of filter perhaps.....who got what? Hard to believe customers are happy just because their service bill may be less than somewhere else.

I've taken a Mini into the dealers to pick up service bits, got my key read while there to see if any recalls, and found it was still under a service plan. Took a 1 series in for similar and found a recall due. Incidental, but handy.

Only my2p sorry, but cheap isn't always the answer. The biggest part of any proper service really is labour, not parts.