The problem with BMW 333M alloys
The problem with BMW 333M alloys
Author
Discussion

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Thursday 11th August 2016
quotequote all
I've read that they all corrode due to the clear coat peeling near the centre caps and bolts. The water gets in and that's that.

Having just bought an AUC X5 40d with these wheels, the dealer is sending all four to Lepsons for restoration. Research suggests that with the diamond cut finish, the problem will return within 6 months or so as it's a design flaw. I can see that Lepsons do American nickel chrome finishing http://www.lepsons.com/chrome-paint-finishes/ and wondered if this would be a better way to protect the wheels?

Is there anything else that can be done? I am keen to keep the OEM look.

GTEYE

2,511 posts

241 months

Thursday 11th August 2016
quotequote all
The Stiglet said:
I've read that they all corrode due to the clear coat peeling near the centre caps and bolts. The water gets in and that's that.

Having just bought an AUC X5 40d with these wheels, the dealer is sending all four to Lepsons for restoration. Research suggests that with the diamond cut finish, the problem will return within 6 months or so as it's a design flaw. I can see that Lepsons do American nickel chrome finishing http://www.lepsons.com/chrome-paint-finishes/ and wondered if this would be a better way to protect the wheels?

Is there anything else that can be done? I am keen to keep the OEM look.
They will corrode if any of the following occur:

1) Careless tyre fitters chip the lacquer when they remove the centre caps

2) Visiting hand car washes that spray aggressive wheel cleaning products - over time this will attack the lacquer

3) Stone chipping on the wheels from our lovely roads will lead to corrosion if left unattended

4) Kerbs - nuff said!

Basically and diamond cut lacquered wheels look great when new, but they really aren't that durable for real world use. It is possible, but they are hard work!

rayyan171

1,298 posts

124 months

Friday 12th August 2016
quotequote all
Shift the 333M wheels - they'll only give more issues and be costly to maintain their finish.

I recommend style 223 wheels, they were an option on pre/post LCI cars and they look great too and give the car a better ride due to thicker tyres. They don'y have to be 223's, other BMW non diamond cut wheels are good and maintain the OEM look too.

Honestly don't see the need for such big wheels on cars, my E70 has 227M wheels on and the comfort simply isn't as good as it would be if it were on 19" 223 wheels. The XC90 has 18" wheels and the ride comfort is bliss, like riding on cushions. Shame that it handles like a cushion too however...

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Friday 12th August 2016
quotequote all
GTEYE said:
Basically and diamond cut lacquered wheels look great when new, but they really aren't that durable for real world use. It is possible, but they are hard work!
So do you think the nickel plating would be better then? More durable?

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Friday 12th August 2016
quotequote all
rayyan171 said:
Shift the 333M wheels - they'll only give more issues and be costly to maintain their finish.

I recommend style 223 wheels, they were an option on pre/post LCI cars and they look great too and give the car a better ride due to thicker tyres. They don'y have to be 223's, other BMW non diamond cut wheels are good and maintain the OEM look too.
Well I don't think the dealer is going to do that, plus the tyres are brand new. As they are non-RFT, I actually found the ride perfectly acceptable although I wasn't in the car for long.

I don't mind the 223 wheels but I've only got a few days to make up my mind about what we get Lepsons to do to the 333m alloys. Powder coating was the other other option but if Black Chrome Two tone fixes the issue then that could be tempting: http://www.lepsons.com/chrome-paint-finishes/

GTEYE

2,511 posts

241 months

Friday 12th August 2016
quotequote all
The Stiglet said:
GTEYE said:
Basically and diamond cut lacquered wheels look great when new, but they really aren't that durable for real world use. It is possible, but they are hard work!
So do you think the nickel plating would be better then? More durable?
I would probably go for one of the painted finishes rather than a plating or diamond cut finish. The chrome paint finishes might not be bad compromise?

iluvkefalonia

25 posts

202 months

Friday 12th August 2016
quotequote all
I would contact Lepsons directly, they are the best people to advise.

ashway

533 posts

196 months

Saturday 13th August 2016
quotequote all
The Stiglet said:
I've read that they all corrode due to the clear coat peeling near the centre caps and bolts. The water gets in and that's that.

Having just bought an AUC X5 40d with these wheels, the dealer is sending all four to Lepsons for restoration. Research suggests that with the diamond cut finish, the problem will return within 6 months or so as it's a design flaw. I can see that Lepsons do American nickel chrome finishing http://www.lepsons.com/chrome-paint-finishes/ and wondered if this would be a better way to protect the wheels?

Is there anything else that can be done? I am keen to keep the OEM look.
When I had my X5 I had the wheels replaced twice under warranty for corrosion as you describe. It was (is) a well known problem and the backlog for replacement wheels so big I had to wait 6 months for the 2nd replacement set. I'd be pushing for a replacement rather than refurb especially with diamond cut

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Saturday 13th August 2016
quotequote all
This picture was when I collected them from Lepsons 18 months ago, they're still in the same condition.

They come off in the winter, and I don't use dick head tyre fitters.


Maracus

4,553 posts

199 months

Saturday 13th August 2016
quotequote all
I had my 403Ms all replaced by BMW at 2 years old. They had corroded around the centre caps.

mike150

497 posts

231 months

Saturday 13th August 2016
quotequote all
Has anyone asked or got a cash amount from BMW for a set of corroded wheels especially as there is a wait on getting them rather than a replacement set that are going to corrode in time.

If mine need done I would rather BMW gave me the cost of the wheel's and I bought an aftermarket set.

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Monday 15th August 2016
quotequote all
iluvkefalonia said:
I would contact Lepsons directly, they are the best people to advise.
Yep, I've been doing this but BMW aren't so happy as they are the 'client'. Probably not so happy because Lepsons know they've been done before and don't have enough material to guarantee a perfect diamond cut...

Looks like it will have to be a warranty job or painted instead cry

iluvkefalonia

25 posts

202 months

Tuesday 16th August 2016
quotequote all
The lacquer Always lifts on diamond cut alloys, my daughter had hers replaced under warranty on her F30 Sport, that's why I stuck with the standard painted 18 inch wheels on my F30 M sport rather than the 19 inch upgrade (403M I think).

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Wednesday 17th August 2016
quotequote all
I read so many tales of woe about diamond cut alloys in general over the past two days that I decided just to have them painted and went with Black Chrome Two Tone from Lepsons. I also had the clear plastic protectors fitted to the rear arches, lower rear doors and sills to protect from the ubiquitous stone chips.

Once I collect the car I will be sure to post some pictures of the wheels

jboy72

383 posts

212 months

Wednesday 17th August 2016
quotequote all
The Stiglet said:
I read so many tales of woe about diamond cut alloys in general over the past two days that I decided just to have them painted and went with Black Chrome Two Tone from Lepsons. I also had the clear plastic protectors fitted to the rear arches, lower rear doors and sills to protect from the ubiquitous stone chips.

Once I collect the car I will be sure to post some pictures of the wheels
I thought alloys were either diamond cut or not - it sounds like I am wrong and diamond cutting is an optional process? I am going to have my wheels refurbed shortly, even if they are currently diamond cut is this something I can decide against if I am happy with a standard finish?

I assume you haven't had much of an opportunity to enjoy the x5 40d yet? It is really growing on me I must say, an oddly serene driving experience. I wasn't too keen on the 8 speed when I drove my father's Discovery a few times but for some reason I really like it in the X5. Maybe previously I was just jealous and determined to prefer my 6 speed!

iluvkefalonia

25 posts

202 months

Wednesday 17th August 2016
quotequote all
Wheels that are diamond cut from the factory can be refurbed but painted or powder coated all over which is more durable, also easier to repair at home if scuffed.

jboy72

383 posts

212 months

Wednesday 17th August 2016
quotequote all
iluvkefalonia said:
Wheels that are diamond cut from the factory can be refurbed but painted or powder coated all over which is more durable, also easier to repair at home if scuffed.
Makes sense, thanks

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Wednesday 17th August 2016
quotequote all
jboy72 said:
I thought alloys were either diamond cut or not - it sounds like I am wrong and diamond cutting is an optional process? I am going to have my wheels refurbed shortly, even if they are currently diamond cut is this something I can decide against if I am happy with a standard finish?

I assume you haven't had much of an opportunity to enjoy the x5 40d yet? It is really growing on me I must say, an oddly serene driving experience. I wasn't too keen on the 8 speed when I drove my father's Discovery a few times but for some reason I really like it in the X5. Maybe previously I was just jealous and determined to prefer my 6 speed!
Diamond cutting uses a diamond lathe to take alloy material off the face of the wheel to make it shiny and mirror like. Combined with painting on the rest of the wheel, it provides an unusual and visually stimulating experience tongue out but is an absolute pain to keep it like that as the lacquer, which is used to protect the bare metal, struggles to bond properly. Stone chips, curbing, scratches from wheel fitters etc allow water to penetrate the clearcoat and then oxidisation occurs = corrosion. The alloys will begin to look milky and cloudy.

The problem about reconditioning is that you can only diamond cut the alloy once or twice before there isn't enough material on the alloy to guarantee the job. Things like the 'M' recess could be lost and swirl marks appear from the tooling, which will need to be blown in.

Far simpler is the painting method, which bonds properly to the wheel and doesn't suffer from the issues mentioned above. They are also easier to touch up as they don't need to be diamond cut.

Very much looking forward to collecting it on Saturday and having a proper drive. Glad that you're enjoying yours thumbup