Z4m v Z4 35i/is
Z4m v Z4 35i/is
Author
Discussion

FastNLoud

Original Poster:

75 posts

158 months

Saturday 13th August 2016
quotequote all
Hey, has anyone got experience of driving/owning both of these cars and your opinions on which is better? I have a viewing of a z4m next week but have suddenly thought a 35i/is is now a similar price and a much newer car, so was wondering how they stack up. I did test a z4m years ago but missed the boat with it so ended up with my current car a z4 coupe.

jontysafe

2,370 posts

209 months

Saturday 13th August 2016
quotequote all
35iS a better every day car by a country mile.
Z4m a definite weekend warrior and more fun.

Owned a Z4MC and test drove over a weekend a Z4 35iS.

Very VERY different propositions

2.5pi

1,091 posts

213 months

Saturday 13th August 2016
quotequote all
We have a Z4 35iS, in fact this is the second , and I've driven a Z4M, ,( & owned E46 M3 )I love both but unless you're tracking it a folding hard top seems a better solution , the 3.5iS is a conundrum, , sub 5 secs to 60 but a slightly blunt instrument compared to the normally aspirated M cars . DCT is good , exhaust note is nicely fruity, traction is astonishing but it's not as involving as other M types , having said that we drove down to the Cote'd''azure top down all the way and I can't think of many more enjoyable trips, its properly fast .

35iS has adaptive dampers as well which make it a surprisingly comfortable, or sporting ride, all other Z4's lack that which explains the odd lacklustre review.

Driver101

14,451 posts

152 months

Saturday 13th August 2016
quotequote all
The Z4M Coupe for me.

It's a toy that will be worth more than you pay for it in a few years.

The 35i is the better daily car,but it'd still want the Z4M.

Sohlman

590 posts

285 months

Sunday 14th August 2016
quotequote all
I test drove one of the 35i when they where launched at a BMW launch event. We were on an airfield. It was very rapid and easily hit 135mph on the straight. However on high speed corners I have never experienced understeer like it. As it was a launch event we were not allowed to turn traction off, and the car is set up to understeer big time. I deliberately went in too fast in an 80mph corner goded by the BMW works driver sitting next to me. We washed across an entire runway. I was staggered by how bad it was. We then discussed this and he said they had a play before the event and even with traction off they are almost impossible to provoke the rear.

My conclusion is as a road car driving to 8/10ths it's great. Once you start to push it/ drive on track it' misses by some margin.


daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Sunday 14th August 2016
quotequote all
Driver101 said:
The Z4M Coupe for me.

It's a toy that will be worth more than you pay for it in a few years.

The 35i is the better daily car,but it'd still want the Z4M.
+1

If you can live with the Z4M as a daily driver proposition, its definitely going to at least hold its money / likely increase in value.


Billy_Whizzzz

2,677 posts

174 months

Sunday 14th August 2016
quotequote all
I have a Z4m and love it. I had a 3.0i before and found it a bit anodyne. I looked at Boxsters to replace it but felt that there were too many bore score issues, it wouldn't hold its value and didn't feel enough of an event, so bought an AUC with 28,000 miles just over 2 years ago. It's now on 41,000. I live in a rural place and do a lot of miles - so have a 2014 defender for all the running around locally and have just ordered a M140i which is coming in 3 weeks for all the winter motorway work. The Z4M is a utter delight - I adore the engine and drama. Maybe I'm getting old but if it was my every day car, on winter rutted water logged roads I'd find it a little hard going as my car and if be tempted to get a £1000 Micra aswell... But the 35is you could probably use all year round. FWIW the set up in the MR is slightly softer than a ZC but the adaptive suspension in the newer Z should be a big boon to daily use, even if over time it might be a bit boring. How about a 981 Boxster instead...?

rockford22

362 posts

163 months

Monday 15th August 2016
quotequote all
I'm on my third Z4 ( 2x e89 35i and 1 x e85 3.0i) and really wanted to give a Z4M a shot. Alas I have not driven one so can't comment directly but have experience of an E46 M3.

The 35i is a very competent car, responds very well to engine mods but certainly is not the ultimate in handling. The 35iS is improved in terms of suspension and a fruitier exhaust and by all accounts makes up for the 35i's short comings - they hold a few £k premium over the standard non iS and will probably hold their value better due to rarity.

I thought long and hard about getting the Z4M as my daily but couldn't live without the modern tech and comforts of the e89 along with the hard top roof for winter. I loved my e85 and enjoyed my time on the track with the e46 M3 but for day to running the 35i is more than capable of a bit of fun, if well spec'd can come with just about every toy you'd ever need (if you get bored then take it to one of the tusted BMW tuners and they'll have it running north of 380bhp for a relatively small chunk of change).

All of the above said and done - I'd still like a Z4M!

Edited by rockford22 on Monday 15th August 11:15

Mach

530 posts

256 months

Monday 15th August 2016
quotequote all
Can't comment on the Z4M as never driven one but I had an E46 M3 so fully appreciate what a fabulous engine it is.

I currently have a Z4 35iS although to be fair it's not a daily driver. I replaced my E92 M3 with it and have to say I've been quite surprised by it, in a good way! I am a huge fan of both E46 and E92 M3's, I loved them both. However, I just wasn't using the M3 in this country as every time the sun came out I took a bike. I fancied a convertible and have always thought the E89 Z4 is a great looking car so took a gamble, I really wasn't expecting alot after the M3.

As mentioned in a post above the adaptive suspension answers some of the ride criticisms. I binned the run flat tyres when they were 6 days old too and replaced them with Michelin Pilot Supersports which made a massive improvement.

It's used mainly for Euro trips and on smooth continental roads there is no doubt about it, it's a weapon! True, it doesn't have quite the finesse of an M car but crucially it has much better traction which makes good use of the stomping low down turbo torque. The DCT box is good but it's not set up as aggressively as it is in the M3 which is a bit disappointing.

However, I've driven it on the same mountain roads as the M3's and we have video evidence over a 20+ minute section that the 35iS was quicker overall. Not what I expected at all!

I wouldn't argue it's a better option than a Z4M, I think that's just personal choice but I'd definitely suggest trying one as I believe the 35iS is actually underrated.

Also, the cabin is a lovely place to be. The dashboard is unique to the car and so much nicer than the majority of modern BMW cabins, and I include the E92 M3 in that which to all intents and purposes had exactly the same dashboard as a 318D.