Variable Damper Control (VDC) on F35 X3: what am I missing?
Variable Damper Control (VDC) on F35 X3: what am I missing?
Author
Discussion

ajmcampbell

Original Poster:

518 posts

167 months

Sunday 14th August 2016
quotequote all
Bit of a curious one here...

Dad's just ordered an X3 30d SE with VDC and various other bits, however in the process of securing the deal the sales agent spent a considerable amount of time actively trying to persuade him not to get VDC, and pretty fervently to boot. "Never specced one of these before with it; you don't need it" seemed to be the line of argument, seems odd if there's commission in it for him?!

Such was his fervour, and considering that we experienced a similar reluctance to spec it when Mum was getting her 330d F31 a couple of years ago (she ended up without a VDC specced car) we wonder if we are we missing anything? Are there any problems with VDC, or is there some incentive for dealers not to supply it due to high demand? Perhaps there's a supply issue?

All of the reviews I've read suggest that it is a mandatory option, and I've only read good things on the forums so far, so I ask you, PH-ers, what's the catch (if any)!

Cheers

A

Wills2

29,918 posts

206 months

Sunday 14th August 2016
quotequote all
VDC on the SE cars isn't very good in my experience in that it doesn't add anything to the drive not enough difference between the settings and it's just the damping so the body roll is still there, he was probably just trying to save your dad some money.




ajmcampbell

Original Poster:

518 posts

167 months

Sunday 14th August 2016
quotequote all
Interesting; it was my impression that VDC-equipped cars have the same suspension setup across the model range, ergo VDC MSport has the same setup as VDC SE?
Perhaps I'm getting confused between the F31 options and those for the X3...

End goal of the spec was meant to provide decent ride quality and some limited off road ability for shoot days, both as a priority over handling.
Hence small wheels specced as well... with one eye on all-season tyres.
That said, a degree of push-on ability required to deal with the 30d engine.
It was assumed VDC would help to provide best of all worlds with this spec?
Perhaps the dealer just thought it wasn't worth it on the balance of requirements, as you say!
In some ways this would be more reassuring, as current worry is that it's played down as it's a troublesome system...

Cheers for your help!

A


Edited by ajmcampbell on Sunday 14th August 19:49

aeropilot

40,897 posts

258 months

Monday 15th August 2016
quotequote all
ajmcampbell said:
Interesting; it was my impression that VDC-equipped cars have the same suspension setup across the model range, ergo VDC MSport has the same setup as VDC SE?
Perhaps I'm getting confused between the F31 options and those for the X3...

End goal of the spec was meant to provide decent ride quality and some limited off road ability for shoot days, both as a priority over handling.
Hence small wheels specced as well... with one eye on all-season tyres.
That said, a degree of push-on ability required to deal with the 30d engine.
It was assumed VDC would help to provide best of all worlds with this spec?
Perhaps the dealer just thought it wasn't worth it on the balance of requirements, as you say!
I think the issue is sales guys in dealers have IMHO, zero technical understanding of the product.
Probably doesn't help with the SE spec as probably 80+% of sales are MSport, and VDC is pretty much mandatory on those with the rubber band RFT's etc.
I'm having a similar issue with various BMW dealers trying to spec and test drive a SE spec X5 with the adaptive suspension packs, for reasons almost identical to your Dad, and it doesn't help that there are a 'comfort' as well as 'dynamic' pack, plus you can have both combined!!!
It would appear that 98% of new X5 are specced without these options, so finding one to test drive is proving an nightmare. Finding a sales guy that knows anything about the tech spec of the comfort option is becoming an exercise in futility!!


ajmcampbell

Original Poster:

518 posts

167 months

Monday 15th August 2016
quotequote all
aeropilot said:
I think the issue is sales guys in dealers have IMHO, zero technical understanding of the product.
Probably doesn't help with the SE spec as probably 80+% of sales are MSport, and VDC is pretty much mandatory on those with the rubber band RFT's etc.
I'm having a similar issue with various BMW dealers trying to spec and test drive a SE spec X5 with the adaptive suspension packs, for reasons almost identical to your Dad, and it doesn't help that there are a 'comfort' as well as 'dynamic' pack, plus you can have both combined!!!
It would appear that 98% of new X5 are specced without these options, so finding one to test drive is proving an nightmare. Finding a sales guy that knows anything about the tech spec of the comfort option is becoming an exercise in futility!!
Very true indeed!
X5 was viewed as an alternative; similar issue here... also seemingly impossible to find SEs with a light interior and headlining...
That car is even more of a minefield to spec given the different suspension packages available... also confusingly found out that other options can change the suspension setup (at least in certain markets) e.g. 7 seats apparently can mean automatically you get air springs at the back sometimes?!
From what we found out, Adaptive Comfort is worth a tick on the options list, at least in theory. Again though, hard to say as no cars to test and a scarcity of dealers out there who know anything about it!

From what I can tell, most buyers either just go for the basic spec and don't worry about it, or spend their cash on the (IMHO rather ungainly on the X3) M Sport pack...
The bewildering range of options is giving me a headache, and we're meant to be the kind of people who would be interested in these things!

Cheers A

aeropilot

40,897 posts

258 months

Monday 15th August 2016
quotequote all
^yes

A few weeks ago, I actually managed to find a relatively local dealer that had a 3 month old X5 SE with Adapative Comfort pack fitted. I couldn't have time off to go and test it, so arranged it for following weekend, but on the Friday they rang to tell me they sold it the day before!!
I have managed to also find a MSport with the Dynamic pack fitted, and I test drove that and that was impressive, but confusingly, it also has a comfort setting, but I don't think this relates to the dampers, but sales guys was usless so I'm still unsure what the tech details are.
I've driven a SE and a MSport with standard suspension, and they are horrid, so I won't be buying a new X5 unless I can find and try the Adaptive comfort spec on a car. Got another couple of months leeway before looking at other options.
Size wise, I'd prefer a X3, but I want the comfort seat option so X5 it has to be.

ajmcampbell

Original Poster:

518 posts

167 months

Monday 15th August 2016
quotequote all
^^ haha we had a similar problem; an ideal spec ex demo X5 30d SE (one of a handful seen in 6 months) popped up at our local dealer! Dad happened to be popping in on the day to test drive X3, sent him the link, by the time Mum taken round the next day to view it was gone! Shows we're not the only ones after these apparently unicorn-like options...

Difficult one to distinguish between the two; X3 difference in size is handy (Dad's work takes him around small Cheshire back lanes for much of the day), but I wonder if an X5 could be a better financial bet at around the £40k mark... comfort seats indeed are also a desirable option, as is the truly massive sunroof that can be had on the X5. Main concern about any BMW X is how it will deal in the muddy stuff... roll on delivery in Oct and we'll no doubt find out!!

aeropilot

40,897 posts

258 months

Monday 15th August 2016
quotequote all
ajmcampbell said:
comfort seats indeed are also a desirable option, as is the truly massive sunroof that can be had on the X5. Main concern about any BMW X is how it will deal in the muddy stuff... roll on delivery in Oct and we'll no doubt find out!!
I've got the other problem - I hate the Pano roofs, don't want that!!

It depends on how muddy?

I won't be venturing off rough tracks etc., so X5 will cope with that OK.....but if you are heady off a track or dealing with slippery mud you'll need to fit terrain tyres, all season won't be adequate.
Worse conditions than that it won't cope - you need a Rangey smile

ajmcampbell

Original Poster:

518 posts

167 months

Monday 15th August 2016
quotequote all
^^ haha if only Rangies weren't pushing 90k in top spec now! furious
Shoot is pretty muddy and hilly... that said Dad's outgoing XC90 has managed well enough on bog standard all seasons, and it only has a Haldex system IIRC.
Only thing that stopped it was a flood...

PS isn't the solution to not liking a pan roof to shut the blind? wink

aeropilot

40,897 posts

258 months

Monday 15th August 2016
quotequote all
ajmcampbell said:
^^ haha if only Rangies weren't pushing 90k in top spec now! furious
Shoot is pretty muddy and hilly... that said Dad's outgoing XC90 has managed well enough on bog standard all seasons, and it only has a Haldex system IIRC.
Only thing that stopped it was a flood...

PS isn't the solution to not liking a pan roof to shut the blind? wink
Aah....OK if the XC can handle what he currently does with AST's, the X5 should do as well.
Yes, Rangey prices are out of my league new too, would have to be 2-3 year old if I went down that route - and trying to find a used Rangey in non-drug dealer spec is almost impossible. I also prefer the BMW IDrive tech as well, have got used to it over past 5 years, and I don't like touch screens.

As for the roof, I don't just don't want 50kg of bloody glass in the roof - I absolutely hate sunroofs of any kind, also don't like the reduced headroom being tall.

ajmcampbell

Original Poster:

518 posts

167 months

Tuesday 16th August 2016
quotequote all
Agreed, idrive is rather excellent... much easier to use muscle memory than try and look to use a touchscreen!
Ah fair enough re: sunroof, each to their own! The weight penalty is considerable...

ajmcampbell

Original Poster:

518 posts

167 months

Monday 31st October 2016
quotequote all
aeropilot said:
Aah....OK if the XC can handle what he currently does with AST's, the X5 should do as well.
Yes, Rangey prices are out of my league new too, would have to be 2-3 year old if I went down that route - and trying to find a used Rangey in non-drug dealer spec is almost impossible. I also prefer the BMW IDrive tech as well, have got used to it over past 5 years, and I don't like touch screens.

As for the roof, I don't just don't want 50kg of bloody glass in the roof - I absolutely hate sunroofs of any kind, also don't like the reduced headroom being tall.
OK so a while later and we have our answer... X3 30d SE with VDC (and your favourite sunroof!).
Thoughts on VDC on an SE so far... it is excellent at ironing out secondary ride imperfections in Comfort, and Sport is noticeably tighter for press-on driving. I'd say it's certainly an improvement on the stock SE suspension.
The primary ride is still fairly firm in any setting, even with the softest 17" non-RFT setup, but then I'm used to tooling around in a soggy W140!
Perhaps it will soften up a bit as the dampers bed in.
Car hasn't been on a shoot yet so off road prowess tbc! It has been used for towing already though, and the engine is as beefy as expected for this purpose.

Cheers A


aeropilot

40,897 posts

258 months

Monday 31st October 2016
quotequote all
ajmcampbell said:
aeropilot said:
Aah....OK if the XC can handle what he currently does with AST's, the X5 should do as well.
Yes, Rangey prices are out of my league new too, would have to be 2-3 year old if I went down that route - and trying to find a used Rangey in non-drug dealer spec is almost impossible. I also prefer the BMW IDrive tech as well, have got used to it over past 5 years, and I don't like touch screens.

As for the roof, I don't just don't want 50kg of bloody glass in the roof - I absolutely hate sunroofs of any kind, also don't like the reduced headroom being tall.
OK so a while later and we have our answer... X3 30d SE with VDC (and your favourite sunroof!).
Thoughts on VDC on an SE so far... it is excellent at ironing out secondary ride imperfections in Comfort, and Sport is noticeably tighter for press-on driving. I'd say it's certainly an improvement on the stock SE suspension.
The primary ride is still fairly firm in any setting, even with the softest 17" non-RFT setup, but then I'm used to tooling around in a soggy W140!
Perhaps it will soften up a bit as the dampers bed in.
Car hasn't been on a shoot yet so off road prowess tbc! It has been used for towing already though, and the engine is as beefy as expected for this purpose.

Cheers A

Nice.....Deep Sea Blue as well, nice to see someone pick an actual colour other than the usual black/white/grey that 95% of them seem to be.

I maybe putting deposit down today on the X5 order!

ian in lancs

3,853 posts

229 months

Tuesday 1st November 2016
quotequote all
this is about the switch setting on the transmission tunnel

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

a good link to a summary

http://f30.bimmerpost.com/forums/attachment.php?at...

Suspension is only changed by the switch if VDC/DDC is fitted; obviously.

My 3.0D M Sport X3 with firmer M Suspension and 18" wheels doesn't have VDC and is perfectly fine handling and ride and can certainly get a wiggle on. The extra mass and higher CoG is noticeable over our 325d Lux it's no M3! But, in anything other than dicking about it's absolutely fine. I'd save the money, weight and complexity, it's something else to go wrong and be costly to replace! I wouldn't bother.