Dodgy E90 325i
Discussion
I have bad luck with BMWs.
E39 had rough idle which a full lifter change sorted for over a grand, entire cooling system replaced then it started drinking oil, £300 and PCV later it was even worse so traded it in for the 325.
325 ALSO has rough idle(!!!) and dash intermittently flickers and dials jump when driving. Oh and reverse light doesn't work; it's not the bulb but some module. Dealer is getting one chance to resolve or it's refund time.
Apparently when I test drove it it must have been slightly warm (engine felt cool and there's no oil temp gauge inside) even though I asked for it to be stone cold. Turns out they knew it was a bit lumpy but didn't tell me. Is it really that common or am I just very unlucky??
'Affordable cars' in York, BTW.
Cheers
E39 had rough idle which a full lifter change sorted for over a grand, entire cooling system replaced then it started drinking oil, £300 and PCV later it was even worse so traded it in for the 325.
325 ALSO has rough idle(!!!) and dash intermittently flickers and dials jump when driving. Oh and reverse light doesn't work; it's not the bulb but some module. Dealer is getting one chance to resolve or it's refund time.
Apparently when I test drove it it must have been slightly warm (engine felt cool and there's no oil temp gauge inside) even though I asked for it to be stone cold. Turns out they knew it was a bit lumpy but didn't tell me. Is it really that common or am I just very unlucky??
'Affordable cars' in York, BTW.
Cheers
Is it the N52 engine 325i? (the earlier E90 that's actually 2.5 litres). We have one of those, and the engine has been fine for the last 7 years. I thought they were meant to be very reliable - with the only common concern being the (expensive to replace) electronic water pump failing. Never noticed the idle being particularly lumpy on ours - although on a cold start, it tends to take about 60 seconds to settle down to a quiet/low idle.
Thanks for the replies. I'm sticking to my consumer rights here, calling the dealer now to get it in writing that they recognise the faults and that they agree to repair it at their service centre (who I guarantee won't be able to fix it) and when they can't it'll go to BMW themselves. I'll get a hire car in between. Apparently.
I kind of had to jump out of the E39 as the MOT was up and would probably have been costly, so at least I'll have a hire car whilst this is in for work. If it's not fixed I can take my time finding something else as I can return the 325 within 30 days no questions or for up to 6 years after purchase if the faults are noted from day one, so at least I'll be able to get about.
As much as I love cars, I really hate them too.
I kind of had to jump out of the E39 as the MOT was up and would probably have been costly, so at least I'll have a hire car whilst this is in for work. If it's not fixed I can take my time finding something else as I can return the 325 within 30 days no questions or for up to 6 years after purchase if the faults are noted from day one, so at least I'll be able to get about.
As much as I love cars, I really hate them too.
Edited by hiscocks on Thursday 18th August 09:51
Thanks. The dash flickering has got worse I think. It's going back tomorrow and they'll have it until they fix it or until 30 days are up at which point it's theirs. I hope they do manage to fix it as there aren't many 325's around my area and I think it's just about the right mix of price and drivability as an everyday var (Have an RS2 for fun)
I'll update when I know any developments...
I'll update when I know any developments...
Learn2MergeInTurn said:
Any 'affordable cars' bmw is always going to be expensive to maintain, there is a reason they are cheaper than the rest!
Do your research before buying etc,
In short take it back to dealer and demand they sort!
The price was about right for the age/mileage, it wasn't amazingly cheap or I would have avoided for certain.Do your research before buying etc,
In short take it back to dealer and demand they sort!
They have the car now but sorting the dash is going to mean sending it away and a couple of weeks at least. I haven't got the time or patience for that so I'm going to ask for a refund. I've seen plenty of other 325s for sale which can't be as bad as that one was.
Right, juts had it out with the manager or deputy manager of 'affordable cars'
As I dropped the car off about two hours ago for a repair, I have to give them ONE chance to repair it before anything else happens. Also spoken to Citizens Advice who were great - if the car isn't 100% I can give it back within a week (at least, unless there's any of the original 30 days remaining on top of that) for a full refund. The manager at Affordable Cars seemed confused about this point and seemed to think I would have to return it again for a fix if it was due to a 'consumable part' (I asked which parts of a car you could eat, he wasn't amused)
Right now I'm in two minds - if it's fine when I get it back, OK. I'll be happy but I'll delight in removing the 'affordable cars' tagged number plates on the car. Otherwise, if it isn't right (and I'm 99% sure it won't be) then I'll be delighted to wave the new consumer rights act at my manager friend and ghostie the Bellingo van they gave me as a courtesy back into their parking lot of shabby dodgy cars.
Avoid, at all costs.
More updates as they happen, if anyone's interested!
As I dropped the car off about two hours ago for a repair, I have to give them ONE chance to repair it before anything else happens. Also spoken to Citizens Advice who were great - if the car isn't 100% I can give it back within a week (at least, unless there's any of the original 30 days remaining on top of that) for a full refund. The manager at Affordable Cars seemed confused about this point and seemed to think I would have to return it again for a fix if it was due to a 'consumable part' (I asked which parts of a car you could eat, he wasn't amused)
Right now I'm in two minds - if it's fine when I get it back, OK. I'll be happy but I'll delight in removing the 'affordable cars' tagged number plates on the car. Otherwise, if it isn't right (and I'm 99% sure it won't be) then I'll be delighted to wave the new consumer rights act at my manager friend and ghostie the Bellingo van they gave me as a courtesy back into their parking lot of shabby dodgy cars.
Avoid, at all costs.
More updates as they happen, if anyone's interested!
Don't know if its anything like my E92 330i which is the N53 engine.
Mine can be a tiny bit lumpy when starting up. It was giving my all kind of faults before including a front lambda sensor gone and 6 coilpacks replaced and it is running fine
With the lights flickering on and off id be looking into the overrunning alternator pulley or the alternator itself.
Good luck with the dealer. If you are mechanically minded have a look on e90post as they have a wealth of knowledge on that engine.
Mine can be a tiny bit lumpy when starting up. It was giving my all kind of faults before including a front lambda sensor gone and 6 coilpacks replaced and it is running fine
With the lights flickering on and off id be looking into the overrunning alternator pulley or the alternator itself.
Good luck with the dealer. If you are mechanically minded have a look on e90post as they have a wealth of knowledge on that engine.
Sam. said:
Don't know if its anything like my E92 330i which is the N53 engine.
Mine can be a tiny bit lumpy when starting up. It was giving my all kind of faults before including a front lambda sensor gone and 6 coilpacks replaced and it is running fine
With the lights flickering on and off id be looking into the overrunning alternator pulley or the alternator itself.
Good luck with the dealer. If you are mechanically minded have a look on e90post as they have a wealth of knowledge on that engine.
Thanks for the help. Yes I think it's going to be more tricky than they think. The standard response tends to be 'oh it's a coil' or 'We'll do an engine flush(!!)'Mine can be a tiny bit lumpy when starting up. It was giving my all kind of faults before including a front lambda sensor gone and 6 coilpacks replaced and it is running fine
With the lights flickering on and off id be looking into the overrunning alternator pulley or the alternator itself.
Good luck with the dealer. If you are mechanically minded have a look on e90post as they have a wealth of knowledge on that engine.
If it's not right I'm not accepting it.
They sent the dash away to a place down south but it's strange they have diagnosed it so quickly, it's almost like they had already found the issue... but if you ask me the dash isn't the problem, it's something causing it to go haywire. The dash itself works.
We'll see....
One thing i noticed was the clips holding the plugs for the coils are not a great fit and often need to be forced on.
Engine flushes aren't really going to be doing anything. But rough idle and lights dimming and getting brighter seems to me to point to the alternator. Should be able to test that with a voltmeter pretty easily. If tis been going for a while could of killed the battery off.
Good luck with it mate! cracking cars when running
Engine flushes aren't really going to be doing anything. But rough idle and lights dimming and getting brighter seems to me to point to the alternator. Should be able to test that with a voltmeter pretty easily. If tis been going for a while could of killed the battery off.
Good luck with it mate! cracking cars when running
Sam. said:
One thing i noticed was the clips holding the plugs for the coils are not a great fit and often need to be forced on.
Engine flushes aren't really going to be doing anything. But rough idle and lights dimming and getting brighter seems to me to point to the alternator. Should be able to test that with a voltmeter pretty easily. If tis been going for a while could of killed the battery off.
Good luck with it mate! cracking cars when running
Thanks, yes the two issues seem unconnected - the dash literally resets when driving intermittently - all goes off as if you've taken the key out, then it comes on and flashes the warning check lights and resets the trip computer, sounds the 'bong' noise (reverse light) and needles go back to their positions indicating speed and revs. They don't dim as such, which you're right would point to an alternator, but they literally turn off.Engine flushes aren't really going to be doing anything. But rough idle and lights dimming and getting brighter seems to me to point to the alternator. Should be able to test that with a voltmeter pretty easily. If tis been going for a while could of killed the battery off.
Good luck with it mate! cracking cars when running
The rough idle isn't terrible but it's enough to annoy. It disappears after 10 seconds of driving (not that I've driven the car enough to really test it) but I think when it starts getting cold here it'll get worse and the ECU will close off a cylinder and the engine light will come on. As it did in my E39. It certainly won't get better by itself and I really doubt they'll be able to sort it in any reasonable timeframe.
Still, we live in hope.
P.S Courtesy car Berlingo armrest has fallen off in my hand. Otherwise not a bad drive, quite comfy and smooth, even if the rear suspension feels like it's attached with cable ties
From the sound of that it sounds like its the Oxygen sensors are taking a little while to warm up to get the fuelling collect. My N53 does exactly the same. Not a huge amount you can do about it.
A pair of new lambda sensor up front could help solve the problems as the heating element may be failing.
A pair of new lambda sensor up front could help solve the problems as the heating element may be failing.
OK dash is back and has been repaired. Something wrong with a comm module apparently. Think they knew that before they sold the car tbh.
Annoying thing is that whilst it was off being sorted they couldn't look at the other things because the car can't be started/looked at without the instruments.
Great
So now they find the part they ordered (some footwell sensor part) is the wrong part so that'll take until weds at least.
Great
Now they'll fit that and then look at the rough running, which will take another couple of days because you'll have to wait until car is cold each time to see if it's been fixed. He said it could be rocker breather cover or something. But I'd be amazed if they find and fix it first time, so call it two days to fix and test each idea, we're looking at another week at least.
Great.
Annoying thing is that whilst it was off being sorted they couldn't look at the other things because the car can't be started/looked at without the instruments.
Great
So now they find the part they ordered (some footwell sensor part) is the wrong part so that'll take until weds at least.
Great
Now they'll fit that and then look at the rough running, which will take another couple of days because you'll have to wait until car is cold each time to see if it's been fixed. He said it could be rocker breather cover or something. But I'd be amazed if they find and fix it first time, so call it two days to fix and test each idea, we're looking at another week at least.
Great.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


