F31 Professional Media over business nav
F31 Professional Media over business nav
Author
Discussion

numtumfutunch

Original Poster:

5,184 posts

169 months

Tuesday 30th August 2016
quotequote all


I know this has been done to death however the equipment changes with each model evolution so I was wondering what the current state of play is

I've been quoted £18 a month to upgrade the nav in a new 335 which seemed a no brainer until I made the mistake of actually thinking about it smile

The screen looks much nicer and the traffic info appeals but the facts are it's 500 quid over the lease and I have Waze on my phone which is excellent for dodging jams

I know I'm nit picking at 500 quid on a £££ car but am happy to listen to any opinion, and abuse.....

Cheers

Woodrow123

46 posts

157 months

Tuesday 30th August 2016
quotequote all
I've had my 330D about 8 weeks and when ordering I had the same conundrum. Ultimately I decided against the expensive upgrade for the same reason you are toying with - Google Maps (in my case), is more accurate and more up to date than 95%+ of the OE systems I've tried that offer real time traffic, and having used Waze to a limited extent, I believe that would be the same. Put the £500 into another option, or better still, in your pocket! Just my opinion mind you....

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Wednesday 31st August 2016
quotequote all
If you think its just satnav you are missing the point. It makes the whole infotainment system nicer to use, more functional and with better graphics and more screen space. It's just better - it looks odd with the tiny screen.

Origin Unknown

2,498 posts

200 months

Wednesday 31st August 2016
quotequote all
OP; If you are anything like me, you know every time you get in that car you'll look at that tiny screen and regret not upgrading smile As Fox says, and especially once you have seen the wider screen in someone else's car, it looks odd.

Wills2

29,933 posts

206 months

Wednesday 31st August 2016
quotequote all
Fox- said:
If you think its just satnav you are missing the point. It makes the whole infotainment system nicer to use, more functional and with better graphics and more screen space. It's just better - it looks odd with the tiny screen.
Agreed and the new idrive 5.0 looks fantastic well worth £18 a month




Edited by Wills2 on Wednesday 31st August 13:18

Woodrow123

46 posts

157 months

Wednesday 31st August 2016
quotequote all
Fox- said:
If you think its just satnav you are missing the point. It makes the whole infotainment system nicer to use, more functional and with better graphics and more screen space. It's just better - it looks odd with the tiny screen.
What extra functionality does it bring? I understand the real time sat nav, but I don't consider 'looks nicer' as a functional attribute. When I was ordering it just didn't seem to add as much value, to me at least, as the cost suggested...

apotts

254 posts

238 months

Thursday 1st September 2016
quotequote all
I have pro nav in my F10 535d, and it's the most monstrous waste of money ever. I am ashamed to have specced it and paid for it. I don't use the nav/RTTI due to all round crapness - Tomtom on my phone is miles better and I use it all the time.

The snags are:

  1. It looks cool.
  2. You spec it because you think the next person (or dealer) will slate the car's value, because the next buyer will "want" it.
  3. The next buyer will only "want" it, because of point 2.
It's a vicious circle, and the manufacturers know it. Hence the massive price!


Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Thursday 1st September 2016
quotequote all
apotts said:
I have pro nav in my F10 535d, and it's the most monstrous waste of money ever. I am ashamed to have specced it and paid for it. I don't use the nav/RTTI due to all round crapness - Tomtom on my phone is miles better and I use it all the time.

The snags are:

  1. It looks cool.
  2. You spec it because you think the next person (or dealer) will slate the car's value, because the next buyer will "want" it.
  3. The next buyer will only "want" it, because of point 2.
It's a vicious circle, and the manufacturers know it. Hence the massive price!
I think it's great and I wouldn't have a 5 Series without it. The interior is designed around it being there and it looks excellent, which I note you agree with.

However functionality wise I wouldn't be without it and use it constantly, there are a few things Tomtom does better but these are all cancelled out by how massively convenient it is having everything properly and fully integrated. With the exception of custom-rerouting which Tomtom does very well it's an excellent navigation system and there is simply no way I'd stick a Tomtom to the dash if I had it, as you seem to!

I'm one of those who filters any car without it, but not because of future residuals (Because thats a non-issue for used buyers - as the car gets older the difference in residual falls) but because I think it's an integral part of the car and is a wonderful system.

Sticking a phone to the dash is annoying enough in a rental car, I can't imagine doing that on a car fitted with Pro Nav!

James_G

366 posts

215 months

Thursday 1st September 2016
quotequote all
I had Pro Nav on my M135i (MY2013) and loved it. In fact it is the key reason I'd get back in a BMW. I never found it wanting on the accuracy front and never felt the need to revert to my phone / Garmin.

Things that I liked:

- Plug in an iPod using a normal lead, not a special BMW lead
- Google send to car - really miss that
- Proper widescreen, so running split screen for Nav, music and you can still see everything
- Comes with full black panel
- Looks nice!

I do wish it had built in speed limit display though - quite like having that now I am back to using a Garmin.


Wills2

29,933 posts

206 months

Thursday 1st September 2016
quotequote all
I think the pro nav is a lovely looking interface the best out of the German manufacturers, lots of useful stuff on there, split screen is great, not forgetting the sports display dials!


apotts

254 posts

238 months

Thursday 1st September 2016
quotequote all
Fox- said:
here is simply no way I'd stick a Tomtom to the dash if I had it, as you seem to!
Actually, I have my phone mounted on a vent mount on the right of the steering wheel, and I use the Tomtom app. I just find the RTTI to be hopeless, it will route you off main ring roads that are blocked, straight through the town/city centre which is more blocked.

So for me, it's just a big white navigation elephant.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Thursday 1st September 2016
quotequote all
apotts said:
Actually, I have my phone mounted on a vent mount on the right of the steering wheel, and I use the Tomtom app. I just find the RTTI to be hopeless, it will route you off main ring roads that are blocked, straight through the town/city centre which is more blocked.

So for me, it's just a big white navigation elephant.
You seem to be focused on a single aspect - realtime traffic.

What did you do before any navigation devices had online traffic? Refuse to use them and use a map instead?! For me the deficiencies of RTTI do not outweigh the benefits of not having a phone stuck on my dash for navigation whilst driving a large premium car with an enormous navigation screen integrated into the dash..