E39 520i vs E46 320d
E39 520i vs E46 320d
Author
Discussion

Jay9797

Original Poster:

5 posts

122 months

Sunday 4th September 2016
quotequote all
Hi, I'm new to the forum, but I have been browsing for a number of years, and have a question about what car I should get next.

A few details, I'm 19, soon to have one years NCB, and I'm interested in buying either a late E39 520i or a late E46 320d. The insurance costs of both are about the same, £1500. But obviously the MPG figures are very different. I currently own a 2004 Vauxhall Astra 1.7 diesel, and frankly it's boring as hell, so I really want a change.

I only drive around 3 miles, 3/4 days a week to college, with the occasional longer distance venture. So I don't think mpg will matter a huge amount.

For the 520i I would like to pay around £1500 for an example with less than 90k miles on the clock.

For the 320d I would be willing to spend around £2500 for an example with less than 120k miles. I would also consider getting a remap to up the power to around 180bhp, but obviously that would add to the insurance cost.

So the question is, if you were in my position, which car would you advise me to get?

craig1912

4,701 posts

143 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Wouldn't consider a diesel on that mileage. I also wouldn't consider a 5 series at your age! Get a 3 or 1 series petrol engined.

MikeTFSI

6,091 posts

133 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Why no 320i? That is what I would look for at this budget, a 2.2 6pot with 170hp would be better in the smaller, lighter package. Unless of course insurance is the problem.

Diesel would be barely warm at those miles, although no dpf to worry about so it could do it. If mpg is not a concern then no reason to have the diesel option. Remap would be an issue for the insurance so you would be better off finding a 328i or 330i and getting quotes on that.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
craig1912 said:
Wouldn't consider a diesel on that mileage. I also wouldn't consider a 5 series at your age! Get a 3 or 1 series petrol engined.
Is there some sort of age restriction on a 5 Series? Will the DVLA reject any change of owner applications for under 25's or something?

craig1912

4,701 posts

143 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Fox- said:
Is there some sort of age restriction on a 5 Series? Will the DVLA reject any change of owner applications for under 25's or something?
rolleyesshoot

Jay9797

Original Poster:

5 posts

122 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
MikeTFSI said:
Why no 320i? That is what I would look for at this budget, a 2.2 6pot with 170hp would be better in the smaller, lighter package. Unless of course insurance is the problem.

Diesel would be barely warm at those miles, although no dpf to worry about so it could do it. If mpg is not a concern then no reason to have the diesel option. Remap would be an issue for the insurance so you would be better off finding a 328i or 330i and getting quotes on that.
The 320i insurance becomes a laughable £2600, and the 328i and 330i are all over £3000. All quotes are ridiculous when I can get insured on a new Ford Fiesta ST for around £1000.

Even the less powerful 318d is more expensive to insure than the 320d. So really the 520i and 320d are the only real options.


Edited by Jay9797 on Monday 5th September 10:56

Jay9797

Original Poster:

5 posts

122 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Fox- said:
craig1912 said:
Wouldn't consider a diesel on that mileage. I also wouldn't consider a 5 series at your age! Get a 3 or 1 series petrol engined.
Is there some sort of age restriction on a 5 Series? Will the DVLA reject any change of owner applications for under 25's or something?
Exactly, while I'm sure the 1 and 3 series are good cars... the 5 series is just a 5 series, it's just a class above anything else in my budget.

Depthhoar

691 posts

159 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
The E39 520i will be a nice smooth ride and have a silky I6 engine but it will be hauling quite a large body around so don't expect much in the way of performance or fuel economy. Mpg likely to be very poor on short journeys though much better when motorway cruising.

Good choice though. Classy-looking understated car. Manual gearbox preferable to an auto.

However, buy a neglected one and you'll spend big fixing things.

Jay9797

Original Poster:

5 posts

122 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Depthhoar said:
The E39 520i will be a nice smooth ride and have a silky I6 engine but it will be hauling quite a large body around so don't expect much in the way of performance or fuel economy. Mpg likely to be very poor on short journeys though much better when motorway cruising.

Good choice though. Classy-looking understated car. Manual gearbox preferable to an auto.

However, buy a neglected one and you'll spend big fixing things.
Aye I'm very much tempted by the 6 cylinder, I didn't think I would get insured on one at my age, albeit it is a slightly underpowered one. The thing is with the power, it's 70 more horses than my current car. While 0-60 in 9 seconds isn't fast, it's 3 seconds faster than what I'm used to!

I would much rather go manual, more mpg and frankly I just enjoy a manual 'box. I did once drive my dad's XJ and I kept going to change gears.

I'm certainly going to get the best one I can afford, I'm going to assume full service history is very important?

Depthhoar

691 posts

159 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
This has been said many, many times before about most cars, not just E39s: buying one with a nicely stamped up service history is a good thing but best if there's also evidence of 'maintenance'. Servicing is basically changing fluids and filters; maintenance is changing non-service items - especially parts of the suspension and cooling system.

The petrol sixes seem quite hard on their cooling systems (the diesels seem better here). All E39s need their suspension fettling at circa 60k - 80k mile intervals. I've lost count of the number of arms, bushes and ball joints on the car but there's a lot. So look for evidence (receipts) for this sort of work.

They rot too, so look carefully at jacking points (removing covers to do so) as real problems here will scrap the car. Wheel arches & boot lid rot for fun but can be fixed. Check for oil leaks too.

Quite a few of the autoboxes will be on borrowed time (though some can run to high mileage) so on any test drive do the usual checks.

The E39 is quite easy to work on and I'd much prefer to buy one from an owner who's mechanically competent and has done the servicing and maintenance himself rather than a car with FBMWSH...with evidence of no other work.

It's time worn....but at about 15yrs old now you really need to buy on condition. An older car with higher mileage can be better than a younger one that's been mechanically neglected but is shiny.

Check out the small ads in owner forums - BMW5 can be quite a happy hunting ground.

Edited by Depthhoar on Monday 5th September 15:17

Jay9797

Original Poster:

5 posts

122 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Depthhoar said:
This has been said many, many times before about most cars, not just E39s: buying one with a nicely stamped up service history is a good thing but best if there's also evidence of 'maintenance'. Servicing is basically changing fluids and filters; maintenance is changing non-service items - especially parts of the suspension and cooling system.

The petrol sixes seem quite hard on their cooling systems (the diesels seem better here). All E39s need their suspension fettling at circa 60k - 80k mile intervals. I've lost count of the number of arms, bushes and ball joints on the car but there's a lot. So look for evidence (receipts) for this sort of work.

They rot too, so look carefully at jacking points (removing covers to do so) as real problems here will scrap the car. Wheel arches & boot lid rot for fun but can be fixed. Check for oil leaks too.

Quite a few of the autoboxes will be on borrowed time (though some can run to high mileage) so on any test drive do the usual checks.

The E39 is quite easy to work on and I'd much prefer to buy one from an owner who's mechanically competent and has done the servicing and maintenance himself rather than a car with FBMWSH...with evidence of no other work.

It's time worn....but at about 15yrs old now you really need to buy on condition. An older car with higher mileage can be better than a younger one that's been mechanically neglected but is shiny.

Check out the small ads in owner forums - BMW5 can be quite a happy hunting ground.

Edited by Depthhoar on Monday 5th September 15:17
Thank you very much! That information is invaluable to a young person such as myself! I am certainly leaning towards the 5 series, and unless an amazing 320d comes up, I think I shall go with that!

Luckily my dad has been working on cars for years, like E types and XJS' so if anything were to go wrong, I can rely on him to fix it!

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Jay9797 said:
Exactly, while I'm sure the 1 and 3 series are good cars... the 5 series is just a 5 series, it's just a class above anything else in my budget.
IT's also getting on a bit in terms of age and will break on a semi regular basis. This will become infuriating after a while. Especially if the end result of continually fixing things is a 520i, rather than one of the better engined models.