Porsche Cayman S / Boxster S or 991
Porsche Cayman S / Boxster S or 991
Author
Discussion

Boggy

Original Poster:

4,603 posts

256 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Guys

After much thought I have decided to out the Lotus (2013 Elise S) and opt for another Porsche. I have previously owned a 997, 2006 Cayman S but sold them both on as at the time didn't fit the our lifestyle.

We have owned our current Elise S now for a year I have probably covered 1000 miles which is a joke ! I'm also not doing any track days and the lure of another Porsche is very attractive.

I'll probably only cover 3k - 4k a year mostly long distance (100 miles plus) question is which one ?

I really love the look of the new shape Cayman/ Boxster - budget will be around 40k so do I carry on saving another 2 years or opt for either of the above.

Boggy


DJMC

3,541 posts

124 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Boggy said:
Guys

After much thought I have decided to out the Lotus (2013 Elise S) and opt for another Porsche. I have previously owned a 997, 2006 Cayman S but sold them both on as at the time didn't fit the our lifestyle.

We have owned our current Elise S now for a year I have probably covered 1000 miles which is a joke ! I'm also not doing any track days and the lure of another Porsche is very attractive.

I'll probably only cover 3k - 4k a year mostly long distance (100 miles plus) question is which one ?

I really love the look of the new shape Cayman/ Boxster - budget will be around 40k so do I carry on saving another 2 years or opt for either of the above.

Boggy
Have you driven the 991, 981, 718?

Within your current budget, only a used 981 will fit unless you have no options at all, then a 718 squeezes in.

As for saving... just go drive all three and see which you prefer. Then you'll have your answer, maybe.

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

267 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Coming out of a Lotus I feel confident the car you will want is a manual 981 S.

Boggy

Original Poster:

4,603 posts

256 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
DJMC said:
Have you driven the 991, 981, 718?

Within your current budget, only a used 981 will fit unless you have no options at all, then a 718 squeezes in.

As for saving... just go drive all three and see which you prefer. Then you'll have your answer, maybe.
Are they that different from the previous models ? 981 Boxster is the car I'm leaning towards at the moment.

Boggy

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

267 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Boggy said:
981 Boxster is the car I'm leaning towards at the moment.
As it happens, my modest Boxster 981 S is in for service today and they've given me a 2.7 PDK as loan car.

Trust me, you want a manual S ! driving

Boggy

Original Poster:

4,603 posts

256 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Yup,

Deffo going for a manual regardless, it will need to be the S due to the performance. I'm used to around 250bhp in a lightweight car so I'd get pretty bored otherwise. (previously driven the 2.7)

Boggy

Thorny

1,076 posts

231 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Boggy said:
Yup,

Deffo going for a manual regardless, it will need to be the S due to the performance. I'm used to around 250bhp in a lightweight car so I'd get pretty bored otherwise. (previously driven the 2.7)

Boggy
I've owned a 981 Boxster S PDK and was loaned a 981 Non-S manual for a few days, I think the combo of manual with the S would be great fun - I loved the non S, it was quite a basic car but great. I swapped the 981 for a 991 but only because I needed rear seats.

JayK12

2,369 posts

223 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Another vote for a manual S smile

Boggy

Original Poster:

4,603 posts

256 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
That's not an issue we have another car with 5 seats. I'm starting to think either the Cayman or Boxster

Boggy

JayK12

2,369 posts

223 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Boggy said:
That's not an issue we have another car with 5 seats. I'm starting to think either the Cayman or Boxster

Boggy
I drove PDK Cayman GTS and Boxster Manual GTS, bought the Boxster, Open top Manual experience cannot be beaten imo smile

p.s I never wanted a Boxster, wanted a Cayman lol

Adam190

126 posts

169 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Ozzie Osmond said:
Coming out of a Lotus I feel confident the car you will want is a manual 981 S.
The base 718 is just as quick as the 981S now. Crazy!


Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

267 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Adam190 said:
The base 718 is just as quick as the 981S now. Crazy!
Yes, albeit 718 in my opinion leans heavily towards PDK being the transmission of choice.

Boggy

Original Poster:

4,603 posts

256 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Performance is something I care about so it will need to be the S no matter what. I'd really like 400bhp however cost.

Boggy

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

267 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
^^^ With turbo torque and a computer shuffling 7 gears I shouldn't fret too much about the bhp figure. Seriously quick car, if that's the bag that you're into.