bmw 316ti as first car? or fiat punto HGT
bmw 316ti as first car? or fiat punto HGT
Author
Discussion

lukeviolin

Original Poster:

6 posts

122 months

Saturday 10th September 2016
quotequote all
hello everyone!
This is my first post, and I'm not sure I've posted in the right section.
anycase, I'm looking into my first car, I really really love bmw's, but the only ones I can afford seem to be the e46 316ti's compact (e36's are nice but got a 1.5 out of 5 star euro ncap rating). Are they a good choice? I'm looking for a cheap-ish reliable car that is enjoyable to drive on b roads. I have also considered a fiat punto HGT, a bit faster (0-60 is 8.6s compared with the bmw's 10.4s), but FWD, so probably less enjoyable, and is also thirstier. Fiat will be around 80-100k miles, and bmw quite high milage, at around 120k. I wiil try to do most work myself. reliability index says the punto is a lot more reliable than the bmw, but that does not seem the general opinion. oh yes I live in italy, and insurance does not really change depending on the car. I've looked into a toyota celica but apparently they dont like lpg, I drive a lot and here lpg cost's a third of petrol, so I really need to convert it
can anyone enlighten me? maybe some other cars in the £1-2k range
thank you in advance!

jboy72

383 posts

212 months

Saturday 10th September 2016
quotequote all
This is not a scientific answer but in your situation I wouldn't be considering the bmw. The fiat's 2 second 0-60 advantage should easily outweigh the rwd advantage of the bmw if it's fun you are after. My fwd 156 has a similar 0-60 time as the punto and handles more purely and more pleasingly than all rwd cars I have owned bar perhaps an e39 530i so fwd needn't rule fun out. Come to think of it how about a 156 or a 147? You will have many more to choose from in Italy than over here!

lukeviolin

Original Poster:

6 posts

122 months

Saturday 10th September 2016
quotequote all
I would love a 156 or a 147, there are plenty to chose from and they are cheap as chips, but I am really worried about alfa reliability. how is your 156 in terms of reliability and economy? I just adore the looks of them 😀

jboy72

383 posts

212 months

Saturday 10th September 2016
quotequote all
lukeviolin said:
I would love a 156 or a 147, there are plenty to chose from and they are cheap as chips, but I am really worried about alfa reliability. how is your 156 in terms of reliability and economy? I just adore the looks of them ??
Mine is a 2000 2.4 jtd with 140000 on the clock. It seems to do 40mpg pretty much regardless of how or where it is driven. Having a pleasant exhaust note I do tend to spend more time in the 3-4K rev range than I ordinarily would in a diesel as well. I have owned it for 3 years and have found it to be great, cheaper to maintain than any of my BMWs but that is of course because it is a lot more basic so that isn't really a fair comparison. Before I bought it the clutch and dmf were replaced and I had to replace the master and slave cylinders about one month after I bought the car. The hedgehog has just gone so I will have to replace that shortly. I certainly have no complaints. And as you have pointed out the original De Silva design is not just a car it is a work of art. I know beauty is in the eye of the beholder and all that but I used premium valet parking at gatwick recently so found myself between new Astons, Jags, Audis and the like and they just left me cold. The 156 stood out like a diamond in a cluster of Swarovski crystals.

lukeviolin

Original Poster:

6 posts

122 months

Saturday 10th September 2016
quotequote all
jboy72 said:
Mine is a 2000 2.4 jtd with 140000 on the clock. It seems to do 40mpg pretty much regardless of how or where it is driven. Having a pleasant exhaust note I do tend to spend more time in the 3-4K rev range than I ordinarily would in a diesel as well. I have owned it for 3 years and have found it to be great, cheaper to maintain than any of my BMWs but that is of course because it is a lot more basic so that isn't really a fair comparison. Before I bought it the clutch and dmf were replaced and I had to replace the master and slave cylinders about one month after I bought the car. The hedgehog has just gone so I will have to replace that shortly. I certainly have no complaints. And as you have pointed out the original De Silva design is not just a car it is a work of art. I know beauty is in the eye of the beholder and all that but I used premium valet parking at gatwick recently so found myself between new Astons, Jags, Audis and the like and they just left me cold. The 156 stood out like a diamond in a cluster of Swarovski crystals.
hmm you might just have convinced me to get one of those! I probably will opt for a petrol though, so i can convert it to lpg, as lpg is 50 cents a litre here and diesel is around 1.30 and petrol 1.45 plus you get access to city centres if you have a lpg car... yes yes i know italy has it's fair share of odd laws ??. 40 mpg is certainly very good though! reliability index rates the 156 as being one of the most unreliable cars, but I'm starting to really distrust them now. The punto hgt is still inviting being a fast nimble little car, but the 156 is just so irresistible, same goes for the 147

Edited by lukeviolin on Saturday 10th September 23:37

dammit!! I think I just got my heart on a 2.5 v6

Edited by lukeviolin on Sunday 11th September 00:31

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Sunday 11th September 2016
quotequote all
316ti was. The first BMW to feature valvetronic. It was a bad engine, unreliable and used more fuel than the old M43. I do not recommend it.

jboy72

383 posts

212 months

Sunday 11th September 2016
quotequote all
A 2.5 v6 sounds like a great idea. I have never driven a Busso but would love to...

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Sunday 11th September 2016
quotequote all
For £2k you would get into an E46 318ti.

I had one of these and adored it, it was a great car all round.

Use to rag the arse off it and still average 35mpg and see 40+ on a fast run.