E36 318iS Gearbox Mod?
E36 318iS Gearbox Mod?
Author
Discussion

Paul S4

Original Poster:

1,313 posts

241 months

Saturday 10th September 2016
quotequote all
I have a 1998 E36 318iS in Titan Silver. It is in mint condition and I have used it for several track days at Croft, and use it regularly ( but not in the winter months ). I drove it to Monaco a couple of years ago, and averaged about 33 mpg.

However, the standard 5 speed box is really low geared, and although this is fine for a track day, on more mundane motorway journeys it gets a bit noisy, especially with a Miltek stainless steel cat back exhaust.

So my question is; would an E36 328 box fit, this would presumably have a higher range of gears especially 5th,

or would it be better to fit a higher diff ?

And the last question, which I am sure is the most costly, is would an E36 M3 6 speed box fit !

MiggyA

193 posts

131 months

Saturday 10th September 2016
quotequote all
The 328 has basically the same ratios as the 318 so there would be no point in changing the 'box. But it has a 2.93 diff instead of the 3.44, so you'd be turning about 2750rpm at 70 rather than 3250. Will be quite sluggish off the line I think but then again being able to get to 65 with only one gear change could be seen as a plus..

As for a six speed, you've got E36 evo, E46 M3, and then apparently the E46 330i and diesel ones can be 'made' to fit with some fabrication, and presumably can be bought cheap: http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?t=124...

Ciff

50 posts

165 months

Sunday 11th September 2016
quotequote all
Try the 2.93 diff out of a 323 or 328 cheap enough to buy and easy to fit just swap output flanges over. 6 speed box going to need prop shaft and maybe different clutch, mounts etc
a 325 diff might also fit

e36 diff ratios

316i/318i ........... 3.38
318iS/320i ........... 3.45
323i .............. 2.93
325i ................. 3.15
328i .............. 2.93
M3 ............... 3.15
M3 Evo ............... 3.23

Edited by Ciff on Sunday 11th September 11:03


Edited by Ciff on Sunday 11th September 11:18

Paul S4

Original Poster:

1,313 posts

241 months

Sunday 11th September 2016
quotequote all
Thanks very much for all the information!
As always the knowledgable folk on PH help out. That has given me much to ponder over the winter...
As has been said the diff would seem the most obvious solution and also the cheapest. Since I am not planning on doing a lot of track days, (maybe one a year,) then it would make sense to change the diff.

Thanks again for the replies.

Paul S4

Original Poster:

1,313 posts

241 months

Sunday 11th September 2016
quotequote all


One of my Track Days at Croft Race Circuit last year.

BGarside

1,568 posts

168 months

Wednesday 14th September 2016
quotequote all
AFAIK the diffs used in the 323/328 are a different size to those in the 4 cylinder cars (medium case vs small case) which might affect the fitting of the propshaft or driveshafts. Better do some googling before you buy!

Paul S4

Original Poster:

1,313 posts

241 months

Thursday 15th September 2016
quotequote all
Thanks for that advice. If I get them done, I shall get my local Alfa BMW Independent specialist to do the work. I was aware that the output flanges (?) were different but if & when I decide proceed I shall do some more homework !

The conversion will also will compromise the acceleration somewhat but I can live with that for the reduced revs at motorway speeds. And of course an increase in mpg....hopefully!


iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Friday 16th September 2016
quotequote all
BGarside said:
AFAIK the diffs used in the 323/328 are a different size to those in the 4 cylinder cars (medium case vs small case) which might affect the fitting of the propshaft or driveshafts. Better do some googling before you buy!
Indeed. The 318is (and 316i, 318i and 320i) has the small 168 diff and the 323i/325i/328i have the 188 diff - longer and wider. You'll need a pair of driveshafts sand some adjustment on the prop sliding splines and centre bearing. Three hours should do it. The ratios are 3.15 for a 325i and either 3.07 or 2.93 for a 323i/328i. Pay 50 quid for an open diff - they never go wrong and there are plenty about. E46 and E36 Compact diffs do not fit.

Paul S4

Original Poster:

1,313 posts

241 months

Saturday 17th September 2016
quotequote all
iSore said:
Indeed. The 318is (and 316i, 318i and 320i) has the small 168 diff and the 323i/325i/328i have the 188 diff - longer and wider. You'll need a pair of driveshafts sand some adjustment on the prop sliding splines and centre bearing. Three hours should do it. The ratios are 3.15 for a 325i and either 3.07 or 2.93 for a 323i/328i. Pay 50 quid for an open diff - they never go wrong and there are plenty about. E46 and E36 Compact diffs do not fit.
Many thanks for that detailed and comprehensive data. PH is a gold mine !

MitchT

17,165 posts

240 months

Sunday 18th September 2016
quotequote all
I've had a 318iS coupé (M44 engine) for over 17 years so I know these cars well. I would have thought that lack of torque would be the main issue with longer gearing. In an ideal world maintaining the existing five gears and adding a sixth would be the answer, though the closest I guess you'd get would be swapping-in a six speed box and hoping you could get one with comparable ratios (on the first five gears) and diff.

Paul S4

Original Poster:

1,313 posts

241 months

Monday 19th September 2016
quotequote all
I was wondering about a 6 speed...but that would mean an M3 box.

Not sure if that would fit ( although I reckon it would/or could be adapted to fit), and also it is probably the most expensive option !

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Monday 19th September 2016
quotequote all
Paul S4 said:
I was wondering about a 6 speed...but that would mean an M3 box.

Not sure if that would fit ( although I reckon it would/or could be adapted to fit), and also it is probably the most expensive option !
A six speed from a later E46 330i or E60 525i/530i would bolt straight to the M42 - same bell housing bolt patterns. But the tunnel clearance might be tight plus you'd have to fart about with shortened props, gear linkages, clutches atc.

A 3.15 from a 325i isn't bad.